Rohit Shah

Part Three · Meaning and the Self

Chapter 11

Spoiled Identities and Total Institutions

If selves are made in the eyes of others, then some people are made to carry a mark, and some institutions set out deliberately to dismantle a self and build another. What happens to the person inside?

Featuring Goffman · Merton · Durkheim

The man at the gate

Imagine a young man who has spent eight years in an armed underground movement in the forest. He has carried a rifle, slept in different places every few nights, obeyed commanders, learned songs and slogans, lost friends, perhaps done things he does not speak about. One day, for reasons that are tangled, fatigue, illness, disillusion, family, an appeal broadcast on the radio, a promise of land or money, fear, he surrenders. He walks into a police camp, or is brought in through an intermediary, and his old life ends.

What happens next matters enormously, not only for him but for the success of any programme that hopes to bring people like him back into ordinary society. He is received, questioned, photographed, and registered. He may be housed for months in a rehabilitation centre with others like him, given new clothes, a daily routine, classes, vocational training, medical care, perhaps a small stipend, perhaps an identity card. He is watched, by guards and by former comrades, and he watches them. Eventually he is released into a village or a town, where he must find work, perhaps marry, perhaps reconnect with a family that may welcome him or fear him. And everywhere he goes, he carries something invisible: a past that others may know or suspect, which could be revealed at any moment. Because of it, some people treat him as dangerous, some as a traitor, some as a hero and some as a curiosity. He must decide whom to tell, when, and how much.

Every part of this story was analysed decades ago, in very different settings, by Erving Goffman. He wrote about the institution that strips away an old self and tries to build a new one, and about the stigma that follows a person afterwards and shapes every meeting. Goffman never studied insurgents. He studied mental patients, prisoners, the disfigured, the disabled, and members of despised minorities. But his concepts fit the surrendered fighter with uncomfortable precision, and they fit many other people too.

The total institution

In 1955 and 1956 Goffman spent a year at St Elizabeths Hospital in Washington, a huge government psychiatric hospital with about seven thousand patients. He posed as an assistant to the sports director so that he could move freely and watch the patients’ world from within. The resulting book, Asylums (1961), introduced the idea of the total institution. It is a place where many people in similar situations live and work together, cut off from the wider society for a long time, following a closed and formally managed routine.

Goffman's list of total institutions was startlingly broad. Prisons, mental hospitals, leprosaria, orphanages, army barracks, ships, boarding schools, monasteries, convents, work camps, concentration camps. An Indian reader can add residential schools, hostels, police and army training academies, juvenile homes, old-age homes, drug rehabilitation centres, camps for displaced people, and centres for surrendered combatants. What they share is this. In ordinary life we sleep, work and play in different places, with different people, under different authorities. In these institutions, the walls between those parts of life are broken down. In a total institution, every part of life happens in the same place under one single authority. Each daily activity is done alongside a large group of others, all treated alike and made to do the same things together. Every part of the day is tightly scheduled, imposed from above by written rules and a body of officials. And all the activities are joined into one plan built to serve the institution’s official aims.

The mortification of the self

Goffman described what happens to a person entering a total institution as the mortification of the self. The newcomer arrives with a self formed in the outside world, sustained by possessions, clothes, a name, relationships, roles, and routines. The institution systematically strips these away. Admission procedures, Goffman wrote, are like a kind of shaping and coding, in which the recruit is turned into an object that can be fed into the administrative machinery of the institution. He is photographed, fingerprinted, weighed, searched, assigned a number, stripped of his personal belongings, given institutional clothing, his hair cut to a standard style. His former roles, son, husband, worker, are suspended. He may be forced into humiliating postures of deference, made to address staff in particular ways, denied privacy in bathing and sleeping, subjected to constant surveillance, and punished for small infractions. His time is no longer his own; a bell or a whistle tells him when to rise, eat, work, and sleep.

Anyone who has been through basic training in an army or a police academy, or through the first weeks of a strict boarding school, will recognize parts of this. The haircut on the first day, the identical uniforms, the shouted orders, the drill repeated until it lives in the muscles, the punishments for small faults, the loss of all privacy, the erasing of civilian identity: none of these is accidental. Military institutions everywhere have understood that a soldier must be made, and that making him requires unmaking the civilian he was. The batch that emerges is bound together by shared ordeal, and each member has a new self built around the institution's values. The ragging that has troubled Indian colleges and hostels is a cruder, unofficial version of the same humbling. Senior students humiliate newcomers with forced performances, insults and sometimes violence. Its defenders say it breaks pride and builds bonds. It has caused real suffering and occasional deaths, which is why courts and universities have banned it.

Goffman insisted that mortification is not always intended as cruelty. Staff in total institutions often believe they are helping: curing, reforming, training, protecting. But the logic of managing large numbers of people in a single enclosed space, with limited staff and a single plan, produces practices that strip individuals of their selfhood, whatever the intentions. A dramatic and tragic Indian example came in 2001 at Erwadi in Tamil Nadu. People with mental illness were kept in chains in a cluster of private homes near a revered shrine, in the belief that being near the saint would cure them. A fire broke out and twenty-eight people, unable to free themselves from their chains, died. The tragedy led the Supreme Court to step in and drew new attention to how people with mental illness are treated. It showed, in the most terrible way, how an institution meant to heal could become a place where people were reduced to bodies to be held.

The logic of managing many people in one enclosed space strips individuals of selfhood, whatever the intentions of the staff.

The underlife

But Goffman's book is not only about domination. Its most original pages describe what he called the underlife of the institution: the countless small ways in which inmates resist, adapt, and preserve some sense of self. He called these secondary adjustments: practices that allow inmates to obtain forbidden satisfactions or to obtain permitted ones by forbidden means. Patients at St Elizabeths hid food in their clothes and used cigarettes as money. They found corners the staff could not see, built ties with particular attendants, made private territories in a ward where nothing was private, and mocked the staff behind their backs. They used the hospital's laundry to get their own clothes pressed, and its library as a refuge. Every prison in the world has its underground economy, its hierarchies among inmates, its smuggled phones and food, its slang, its rituals, its ways of passing time and keeping hope.

Goffman also described different modes of adaptation. Some inmates withdraw, retreating into themselves and paying attention only to what is immediately around them. Some take an intransigent line, openly refusing to cooperate. Some become colonized, finding the institution more comfortable than the outside world and building a life within it; such people sometimes deliberately get themselves readmitted after release. Some are converted, taking on the official view of themselves and trying to be perfect inmates. Most, Goffman observed, play it cool, combining strategies opportunistically to get through with as little damage as possible.

These small acts of resistance, he argued, reveal something about the nature of the self. Our sense of being a person, he suggested, comes partly from belonging to larger social units, families, organizations, communities. But our sense of being a particular someone, with a self of our own, often comes from the small ways in which we push back against those units, the gaps we carve inside them. We draw our standing from the walls and offices of the world; we draw our individuality from the cracks.

What this means for any institution that wants to change people

For anyone who runs a rehabilitation centre, a juvenile home, a hostel for first-generation students, a de-addiction centre, or a prison with reformative aims, Goffman's analysis carries a sharp warning and a quiet lesson. The warning is that the very methods used to manage people, such as uniforms, numbers, schedules, searches and constant watching, can produce withdrawal, cynicism and an inmate culture that works against the institution’s aims, instead of the change it hopes for. People who have been mortified rarely emerge as eager citizens. The lesson is that how a person is received at the gate shapes who he becomes inside. Institutions tend to get better results when they keep some dignity at admission, allow some personal belongings and privacy, involve inmates in decisions, keep links with families and the outside world, and treat inmates as people rather than cases. Research on prisons, psychiatric care, and the reintegration of former combatants in many countries has reached similar conclusions. A former fighter who is treated as a human being with a future, not merely a security risk with a file, is more likely to build that future.

Spoiled identity

In 1963 Goffman published Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity, which follows people out of institutions and into the encounters of everyday life. A stigma, he wrote, is an attribute that is deeply discrediting, that reduces its bearer in the minds of others from a whole and usual person to a tainted, discounted one. He described three kinds of stigma. The first is marks on the body, such as physical deformities and disabilities. The second is supposed flaws of character, such as a history of mental illness, prison, addiction, unemployment or radical politics. The third he called “tribal” stigma: race, nation, religion or, we might add, caste. It passes down family lines and stains every member of a family equally.

Crucially, Goffman insisted that stigma is not a property of the person but of a relationship between an attribute and the expectations of an audience. The same attribute can be stigmatizing in one setting and neutral or even admirable in another. A scar from a battle may bring honour among soldiers and fear among villagers. A former insurgent may be a traitor to his old comrades, a dangerous man to his new neighbours, a hero to some in his community, and a success story to the officials who run the rehabilitation programme. The stigma lies in the eyes that see.

The discredited and the discreditable

Goffman's most useful distinction was between the discredited and the discreditable. The discredited are those whose stigma is visible or already known: the person with a visible disability, a disfigurement, a skin colour that marks him in a prejudiced society, a famous criminal record. They must manage tension in every interaction, aware that others are aware, coping with stares, pity, avoidance, awkward attempts at normality. The “discreditable” are those whose stigma cannot be seen at once and can be hidden. Examples are a person living with HIV, someone who has had psychiatric treatment, a former prisoner, a former fighter, a Dalit who has moved to a city where nobody knows his caste, or a gay person in a hostile place. They must manage information: decide whom to tell, when, and how; control what is revealed; live with the constant possibility of exposure. Goffman called the practice of hiding “passing”, and described its methods and costs in detail. People avoid certain topics, invent cover stories, keep away from those who might know, and live with the dread that an old acquaintance will turn up at the wrong moment.

Think of a young man from a Dalit family who has studied, found a job in a city, and lives among colleagues of mostly higher castes who assume he is one of them. He may change or shorten his surname, avoid talk of caste, and dodge questions about his village and family. He may feel a jolt of fear when a colleague mentions a town near his home, and listen in silence to casual jokes about “quota candidates”. He is passing. The cost is constant vigilance and a quiet alienation from his own origins. When the truth comes out, as it often does through marriage talks or a visit from relatives, he may face exactly the change he feared: the slight cooling, the sudden formality, the joke that stops when he walks into the room.

Or think of people affected by leprosy. For centuries, in India and around the world, people with leprosy were driven out of their villages and forced into separate colonies. They begged and were often abandoned by their families, whether or not they were infectious, because the disease was thought to be a curse or a punishment. In the 1980s effective treatment made the disease curable. But even when people were fully cured, the stigma remained, on their scarred bodies and in other people’s minds. Many could not go home. Hundreds of leprosy colonies still exist in India, home to cured people and their children and grandchildren, who carry the stigma though they have never had the disease. Goffman would call this courtesy stigma: the stigma that spreads to those associated with a stigmatized person, families, children, carers. It is why the families of prisoners, of the mentally ill, of manual scavengers, often suffer the same exclusion as the stigmatized person himself.

Stigma is not a property of the person but of a relationship between an attribute and the expectations of an audience.

The own and the wise

Goffman described how stigmatized people find support among two kinds of others. The own are those who share the stigma: fellow patients, fellow former prisoners, fellow members of a despised group, who understand without explanation and among whom one can relax. Self-help groups, from Alcoholics Anonymous to networks of people living with HIV to organizations of former leprosy patients, are built on this principle. The wise are those who do not share the stigma but are intimately familiar with it and accept the stigmatized person as normal: nurses, social workers, family members, certain officials, friends. The wise are crucial to reintegration, because they offer a bridge between the stigmatized person and the wider world.

In the rehabilitation of former combatants, the own and the wise both matter. Former fighters often find their deepest understanding among each other, and they can organize, support one another, and sometimes become powerful advocates for peace. But they also need “the wise”: a sympathetic official, a teacher at a training centre, an employer willing to give them a chance, a village elder willing to speak for them. Without such people, the world outside stays closed.

Becoming what you are called

In 1948 Merton described the self-fulfilling prophecy: a false definition of a situation that evokes a new behaviour which makes the originally false conception come true. His most famous example was a bank run. A perfectly sound bank is rumoured to be in trouble. Depositors, fearing for their money, rush to withdraw it. The bank, which like all banks keeps only a fraction of deposits in cash, cannot pay everyone at once, and fails. The rumour was false when it started; it became true because people acted on it.

The mechanism applies with terrible force to stigma. If employers believe that members of a particular group are unreliable and refuse to hire them, the group's resulting poverty and frustration appear to confirm the belief. If teachers expect certain children to fail, they treat them in ways, less attention, fewer questions, lower expectations, that produce failure. In the 1960s, researchers told teachers, falsely, that certain randomly chosen pupils were about to blossom. Over the year those pupils tended to make bigger gains, probably because the teachers treated them differently. If a society defines a community as criminal, its members find doors closed, are watched and arrested more often, and may come to see crime as one of the few paths left to them.

India’s most extreme case is the Criminal Tribes Act of 1871. Under it, the colonial government declared whole communities to be criminal by birth, “addicted to the systematic commission of non-bailable offences”. Many were nomadic herders, traders, entertainers and forest peoples. Members of these communities had to register with the police, report regularly, obtain passes to travel, and in many cases were confined to settlements. Generations grew up treated as criminals by birth. After independence the Act was repealed in 1952 and the communities were “denotified”. But many states soon placed them under new “habitual offenders” laws, and the stigma lived on in police practice and public attitudes. Members of denotified tribes, such as the Pardhis of central India, have continued to report being rounded up whenever a theft occurs nearby, beaten in custody, and denied work and housing. The self-fulfilling prophecy is visible: a community denied land, education, and legitimate work, and treated always as suspect, is pushed toward the margins where survival may involve the very activities it was accused of.

Why every society needs its deviants

Crime, Durkheim argued in The Rules of Sociological Method of 1895, is normal. It is found in every society, and a society without crime is impossible. Imagine, he wrote, a society of saints, a perfect monastery. Even there, faults that would seem trivial in ordinary life would provoke the same scandal that crime provokes elsewhere: a careless word, a moment of laziness, a lapse in ritual. Every society defines some acts as deviant, and if the most serious offences disappear, it simply raises the standard and finds new offences. More provocatively, Durkheim argued that crime performs a function. When a crime is committed and punished, the members of a society come together in shared outrage, and their common values are reaffirmed and strengthened. The deviant marks the boundary of the group: by showing what is not acceptable, he shows everyone else what is.

This insight, developed by later sociologists, explains why societies so often need their stigmatized outsiders, and why moral panics flare. The figure of the criminal, the addict, the traitor, the polluting outsider, serves to reassure the respectable that they are respectable. It also suggests that stigma is not simply an error to be corrected by information. It performs work for those who impose it, which is why it is so persistent.

The return

Go back to the young man at the gate. Goffman tells us several things. The institution that receives him will shape who he becomes, and procedures meant to manage him may also humiliate him. The hidden life he finds there will matter as much as the official programme. And when he leaves, he will either be discreditable, guarding a dangerous secret in every new relationship, or discredited, if his past is known, facing stares, fear and closed doors. Merton tells us that if his new neighbours expect him to return to violence, their suspicion may help push him back. Durkheim tells us that some part of the community may need him to remain a symbol of the enemy, so that it can feel united against what he represents. And the whole analysis tells us what would help. He needs a welcome that keeps his dignity, links with his family and a chance at real work. He needs the support of people who share his past and of those wise enough to accept him. And he needs the slow work of changing what the people around him expect.

These are not only matters of minds and labels. They are written into bodies: into how people stand, eat, wash, touch, and are touched. Stigma and status live in the flesh, and the long history of how human bodies came to be trained, restrained, and ranked is the subject of the next chapter.

Curated by Claude from my favourite reads. About this material