Rohit Shah

Part Four · Power

Chapter 18

Publics, Movements, and the Argument of Democracy

Most change is not made by armies but by people reading muster rolls aloud, hugging trees, marching to the sea, and arguing in tea shops. How do ordinary people make their troubles into public issues?

Featuring Addams · Mills · Touraine · Habermas · Tilly

Reading the muster rolls aloud

In December 1994, in a village called Kot Kirana in central Rajasthan, a small group of peasants and workers called the Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan (MKSS) held what it called a jan sunwai, a public hearing. Its members had spent months trying to get copies of official records. These were the muster rolls listing workers paid on government relief works, and the bills for materials bought for roads, school buildings and wells. When they finally obtained some, through sympathetic officials and persistent pressure, they did something simple and revolutionary. They read the records aloud, in public, before the very villagers whose names appeared in them.

A woman listened as the muster roll was read and heard her own name listed as having worked thirty days on a road; she had worked eight, or none. A man heard that he had been paid wages he never received. Villagers heard that cement and stone had been bought for a school building that stood half-finished, its walls crumbling. Names of dead people appeared on lists of labourers. A well that had been paid for did not exist. The villagers had always suspected that money meant for them was being stolen. Now they heard the evidence with their own ears, in front of their neighbours and local officials, and sometimes the contractors themselves, who were invited to reply.

These hearings, repeated in village after village, grew into a movement. In 1996 the organization held a forty-day sit-in, a dharna, in the market town of Beawar, demanding a legal right to obtain official information. The slogans were plain: our money, our accounts; the right to know is the right to live. Over the next ten years the campaign drew in journalists, lawyers, retired officials and activists across the country, and several states passed their own laws. In 2005 Parliament passed the Right to Information Act. Under it, any citizen can ask any public authority for records and must receive them within thirty days. Millions of requests have been filed under it, by villagers seeking ration records, students seeking their answer sheets, journalists investigating scandals, and pensioners seeking their files.

The story contains almost every theme of this chapter. Ordinary people discovering that their private troubles, unpaid wages, missing rations, crumbling schools, are public issues. A small association teaching its members to speak, ask questions, and confront officials. A public space where information is shared and reasons demanded. A repertoire of protest, the public hearing, the dharna, the slogan, chosen with care. And a movement that changed the law of a nation. How do such things happen?

The settlement and the democracy of daily life

Hull House was also a laboratory of social research. In 1895 its residents published Hull-House Maps and Papers, which mapped the nationality and wages of every household in the nearby wards. This was years before the Chicago School of sociology became famous for exactly this kind of work. Addams and her colleagues, many of them women shut out of university jobs, investigated child labour, sweatshops, sanitation, juvenile crime and slum housing. They campaigned successfully for the first juvenile court in the United States, for factory inspection laws, and for limits on women’s working hours. They practised what we would now call action research: studying problems in order to change them, together with the people affected.

Addams set out her philosophy in Democracy and Social Ethics (1902). Democracy, she said, is not just a form of government but a way of life: a habit of understanding people with sympathy across lines of class and culture. The well-meaning charity visitor who comes to judge the poor by middle-class standards misunderstands them. She sees carelessness where there is generosity, laziness where there is exhaustion, and ignorance where there is a different kind of knowledge. The poor, Addams observed, often had their own ethics of mutual aid and neighbourly kindness, more generous than those of the rich. Real democracy required that people of different backgrounds actually know one another, learn from one another, and work together on common problems.

For a long time, male sociologists dismissed Addams and the Hull House women as social workers rather than scholars, and the division between sociology and social work hardened along lines of gender. Today she is recognized as a pioneer of community-based research and public sociology. India has its own traditions in this spirit. In 1972 Ela Bhatt, a lawyer working with the textile workers’ union in Ahmedabad, founded the Self-Employed Women’s Association (SEWA). It organised women who worked outside the formal economy: street vendors, head-loaders, home-based garment workers, waste pickers and farm labourers. They had no employer to bargain with and no union to protect them. SEWA grew into a union of more than a million members, with its own cooperative bank, health insurance, childcare centres and training programmes. Like the Hull House residents, its members learned to speak for themselves before officials, banks and courts. The MKSS's public hearings belong to the same lineage: knowledge produced with and for the people it concerns.

The sociological imagination

The movement in Rajasthan began with villagers realizing that what each of them had experienced as a private misfortune, a missing wage, a stolen ration, was part of a pattern. Mills gave this realization its most famous formulation. In The Sociological Imagination of 1959, he described ordinary people who feel trapped, as if their lives were a sequence of snares they cannot escape from inside the small world of home and job. They are right to feel this, he said, but they do not understand where the trap comes from. What they lack is not information, of which they have far too much. It is a particular habit of mind: the ability to see how the great movements of history are playing out inside individual lives. He called it the sociological imagination, the ability to hold biography and history in a single gaze.

Mills distinguished personal troubles from public issues. A trouble belongs to a person and the narrow circle around him; an issue belongs to the structure of a whole society. If one man in a large city is out of work, we can reasonably look at his habits, his skills, his luck. If a quarter of a nation’s workers lose their jobs at once, no amount of examining individual characters will explain it. Something has gone wrong with the structure of opportunity itself, and the remedy must be sought there. The same is true of marriage, war, debt, migration, depression. One farmer's suicide is a private grief; thousands of farmer suicides in a region, year after year, are a public issue concerning credit, prices, water, and policy. One village’s missing wages may be the work of a dishonest contractor. Missing wages in thousands of villages are a public issue. They raise the question of how public money is accounted for and who has the right to see the accounts.

Mills: from private trouble to public issuea troubleone village, one cheatan issuethousands of villages: a structure
FigureC. Wright Mills’s distinction. One village’s missing wages may be one dishonest contractor. Missing wages in thousands of villages point to how the whole system is built, and the remedy must be sought there.

When one man is unemployed, that is his trouble. When millions are, that is an issue.

The sociological imagination is consoling as well as illuminating. It tells the suffering individual that his suffering is not simply his own fault. And it is the first step of every social movement: the moment when people stop blaming themselves and begin to look at the structures around them.

The power elite

Mills applied his imagination to the structure of power in his own country. In The Power Elite of 1956, he argued that American democracy was largely a façade. Real power was concentrated in three interlocking hierarchies: the giant corporations, the federal government, and the military. At the top of each stood a small group: the corporate rich, the political leadership, and what he called the warlords. They moved easily between the three, came from similar backgrounds, went to the same schools and clubs, and married into each other’s families. They made the decisions of national and global weight, about war and peace, boom and slump, while ordinary citizens were reduced to watching politics. Five years later, President Dwight Eisenhower, himself a former general, warned in his farewell address against the unwarranted influence of the military-industrial complex. Mills had named it first. His White Collar (1951) portrayed the new middle class of clerks, salespeople and managers. They had lost the independence of the old farmers and small businessmen and become “cheerful robots” in huge bureaucracies, selling not only their labour but their personalities.

The public sphere

Jürgen Habermas, whom we met as the defender of communicative reason, wrote his first book about a space that makes movements like the right to information campaign possible. The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere, published in 1962, traced the history of what he called the bourgeois public sphere, which emerged in eighteenth-century Europe. In the coffee houses of London, the salons of Paris, and the reading societies of German towns, private individuals came together to discuss matters of common concern: literature, politics, commerce, the conduct of rulers. They read newspapers and pamphlets, argued about them, and formed what came to be called public opinion. In principle, in this space, rank and birth did not matter; what mattered was the force of the better argument. The public sphere became a check on state power, a place where rulers could be criticized and their policies subjected to rational scrutiny.

India developed its own public spheres under colonial rule. From the nineteenth century, newspapers flourished in Bengali, Marathi, Hindi, Urdu, Tamil and other languages. They created reading publics that debated social reform, colonial policy, religion and the state of the country. Bal Gangadhar Tilak's Kesari in Marathi was one of many papers that colonial authorities repeatedly prosecuted for sedition. Public meetings, debating societies, libraries, and reform associations spread through towns. In Calcutta, the adda, the long, unhurried conversation among friends in tea shops, homes, and college canteens, became a celebrated institution of intellectual life, where politics, poetry, cinema, and gossip mixed freely. Village tea stalls, chaupals where elders gather, and the steps of temples and mosques have long served as informal public spheres where news is shared and opinions formed.

Habermas acknowledged that the historical public sphere was limited, excluding women, workers, and the propertyless. And he argued that in the twentieth century it was transformed and degraded. Mass media, owned by corporations and driven by advertising, turned citizens from critical participants into passive consumers of culture and politics. Public relations and political marketing replaced rational argument; public opinion became something manufactured rather than formed. The public sphere, he wrote, was refeudalized: politics again became a display of power before an audience, as in the courts of kings, rather than a debate among citizens. Watch a prime-time TV debate where panellists shout over each other, the anchor decides the verdict before the discussion starts, and the aim is outrage rather than understanding. You are watching what Habermas called refeudalisation. In a reflection published in 2022, Habermas argued that digital platforms had broken the public sphere into even smaller pieces. They became echo chambers where people meet only what confirms their views, and where the line between public discussion and private chatter dissolves.

The philosopher Nancy Fraser, whom we meet in a later chapter, criticized Habermas's account for treating a single public sphere as the ideal. Groups kept below, such as women, workers, and racial and caste minorities, have always formed their own “subaltern counterpublics”, she argued. These are parallel spaces where they create and share counter-arguments, work out their own understanding of their needs, and then carry these into the wider debate. The Dalit little magazines and pamphlets of 1970s Maharashtra, the women’s study circles of the 1980s and the MKSS hearings are counterpublics in Fraser’s sense. In these spaces, people shut out of the main conversation first found their own voice.

Repertoires of contention

Charles Tilly, whom we met as the theorist of state formation, spent much of his career studying how ordinary people protest. Compiling vast databases of strikes, riots, demonstrations, and petitions from centuries of newspapers and archives in France and Britain, he discovered that people do not invent new forms of protest each time. They draw on a limited repertoire of contention, a set of familiar performances that a society knows how to stage, much as a jazz musician draws on a familiar stock of tunes while improvising.

In eighteenth-century Europe, the repertoire was local, specific and often violent. Crowds seized grain in food riots and sold it at what they thought a fair price. “Rough music” shamed neighbours who broke community norms. People sacked a tax collector’s house or tore down fences around common land. By the nineteenth century a new repertoire had emerged: national, modular, and autonomous. The demonstration, the public meeting, the petition drive, the strike, the formation of special-purpose associations. This shift was tied to the growth of the national state and capitalism: as power moved to national capitals and parliaments, so did protest. Tilly argued that the social movement itself was invented at a particular time: in Britain in the late eighteenth century. It combined a sustained campaign of making claims, a repertoire of performances, and public displays of what he called WUNC: worthiness, unity, numbers and commitment. Marchers in their best clothes display worthiness; matching banners and slogans display unity; crowds filling the streets display numbers; willingness to be arrested, to fast, or to stay in the cold displays commitment.

India's history offers a remarkable case of repertoire invention. Gandhi’s satyagraha joined elements from Indian traditions, such as the fast as penance, the hartal as a day of mourning when shops close, and the pilgrimage, with modern mass mobilisation. It displayed WUNC with extraordinary power. The salt march of 1930 was a masterpiece of performance. A frail old man walked 240 miles with a small band of followers, through villages where crowds gathered, to the sea, to pick up a handful of salt in defiance of an unjust tax. It showed worthiness through simplicity and non-violence, and unity through discipline. It showed numbers through the crowds on the route and the millions who followed his example, and commitment through tens of thousands willing to go to jail. The colonial state found it extraordinarily hard to respond, because every act of repression made the performance more powerful. Since independence, Indian movements have built a rich repertoire. There is the dharna and the hunger strike, the rasta roko road blockade, and the gherao, which surrounds an official until he responds. There is the candle-light march, the padyatra, the public hearing, the jail bharo campaign of courting mass arrest, and now the online petition and the hashtag.

Marchers in their best clothes display worthiness; filling the streets, numbers; courting arrest, commitment.

Social movements and the struggle over the future

Touraine argued that the industrial society Marx studied was giving way to what he called a “programmed society”. In it, the key resources were no longer land or factories but knowledge, information, technology and the power to shape a society’s cultural models. In such a society, the main conflict was no longer just between capitalists and workers. It was between those who run the great machines of production, administration and communication, such as technocrats, planners and corporate managers, and those whose lives they program: students, consumers, patients, residents, women, ecological activists, and regional and ethnic minorities. The central question became who controls what Touraine called historicity: a society's capacity to act upon itself, to produce its own orientations, to decide its own future.

For Touraine, social movements are the central actors of society. A social movement is not just a protest or a pressure group; it is a collective actor contesting the control of a society's main cultural orientations. He defined movements by three principles. Identity is how a movement defines itself and whom it speaks for. Opposition is how it defines its adversary. Totality is what the struggle is about: the vision of society it defends.

India's environmental movements fit Touraine's framework closely. In March 1974, in the village of Reni in the Garhwal Himalaya, a group of women led by Gaura Devi stopped loggers sent by a contractor to fell trees in the forest above their village. They stood between the men and the trees and refused to move. The Chipko movement, named from the Hindi word for embrace or cling, had begun the previous year in nearby villages and spread across the hills. Its identity was that of hill villagers, especially women, whose daily lives depended on forests for fodder, fuel and water. Its adversary was a system of commercial forestry that auctioned their forests to outside contractors. Its totality was a vision of development based on local needs and ecological limits rather than revenue. The movement led to a ban on commercial green felling in the Himalayan forests of Uttar Pradesh in 1980. From the late 1980s, the Narmada Bachao Andolan opposed the displacement of hundreds of thousands of people by the Sardar Sarovar and other dams on the Narmada. It used marches, hunger strikes, legal battles and “monsoon satyagrahas”, in which activists stood in rising waters. It put Touraine’s question in the starkest terms: who decides what development means, and for whom? Its opponents defended the dams as bringing water to drought-stricken regions of Gujarat and Rajasthan; the conflict was precisely a struggle over historicity.

In his later work Touraine worried that modern society was being torn between two sides. On one side is the impersonal world of markets and technology. On the other is the closed world of communities, identities, nationalism and religious fundamentalism. The individual is crushed between cold calculation and tribal identity. The task of democracy, he argued, was to defend the subject: the individual's capacity to be an actor, combining reason with cultural identity, resisting both the market and the tribe.

The argument that never ends

Democracy, in the light of these thinkers, is not a machine that runs by itself once elections have been instituted. It is an argument that never stops, carried on in tea stalls and newspapers, public hearings and courtrooms, marches and messaging groups. In it, people discover that their private troubles are public issues. They organise to deal with them, invent performances that move their fellow citizens, and struggle over who decides the future. It depends on spaces where people can speak and be heard, on associations that teach them to act together, and on a habit of mind that links their own lives to the structures around them.

Not everyone enters this argument on equal terms. Some voices are excluded, ignored, or treated as less than fully human. The next part of this book turns to the great lines of exclusion, colour, caste, colonialism, and gender, and to the thinkers who saw the world from the far side of those lines.

Curated by Claude from my favourite reads. About this material