Rohit Shah

Part Six · The Shape of Change

Chapter 26

Places, Flows, and the Stranger

Space is not a container in which life happens; it is made, fought over, and lived. Cities, networks, and flows have changed what it means to belong somewhere.

Featuring Simmel · Lefebvre · Castells · Sassen · Appadurai · Robertson · Urry

Churchgate at six

Stand on the concourse of Churchgate station in south Mumbai at six in the evening. Every few minutes a local train pulls in, and the crowd on the platform surges toward it before it has stopped. People swing aboard through doors that never close, pressing into carriages built for a few hundred and carrying several times that number. Others pour off the arriving trains toward the offices and streets. Hawkers call out; announcements echo; the noise is continuous. Several million people use Mumbai's suburban railway every day. Watch the faces: most are closed, set, absorbed in phones or in some private space behind the eyes. People avoid each other's gaze, step around a man who has fallen, ignore the beggar, ignore the singer, ignore almost everything except the gap in the crowd that leads to the train. If you spoke to strangers here as you would to neighbours in a village, you would never reach your train, and you might be taken for a madman or a thief.

More than a century ago, Georg Simmel, whom we met as the philosopher of money, described exactly this crowd. In a 1903 lecture called The Metropolis and Mental Life, he wrote that the big city bombards the individual with nervous stimulation. Images change quickly, breaks are sharp and impressions unexpected, and there are thousands of strangers every day. A villager lives at a slower rhythm, with deep emotional relationships to a small number of people and places. If a city dweller responded to every encounter with the feeling a villager brings to his neighbours, he would be shattered. So the city dweller develops a protective organ: the intellect. He responds with his head rather than his heart. He becomes calculating, punctual, matter-of-fact. He develops what Simmel called a blasé attitude, an indifference to the distinctions between things, and a reserve toward others that, Simmel admitted, can border on aversion.

Simmel also saw the gift of the city. In the village, everyone knows your business; you are held by your neighbours' eyes. In the metropolis, you are anonymous, and anonymity lets you become someone new. The young woman who leaves a small town for a city may be lonely, but for the first time she is free of the village’s gaze. The Dalit youth who moves to the city may escape, at least in part, the daily humiliations of caste, in a place where nobody knows his family. The city also intensifies individuality, because among millions people must struggle to be noticed; hence fashion, eccentricity, the passion to be different. The city is also home to the stranger, Simmel’s other great subject. The stranger comes today and stays tomorrow, near and far at once, in the group but not of it. He is trusted with secrets because he is outside local quarrels, and in a crisis he is the first to be blamed.

Simmel's metropolis is a starting point. The thinkers of this chapter went further. They argued that space itself, the city, the region, the network, the route, is not a neutral stage on which social life happens but something produced by social life, shaped by power, and contested.

The production of space

Lefebvre began his Critique of Everyday Life in 1947 and continued it for decades. He argued that in modern capitalism the most important place of alienation, and of possible liberation, was not only the factory. It was everyday life itself: eating, dressing, commuting, shopping, leisure and family. Capitalism, he argued, colonized everyday life, turning it into passive consumption, repetitive routine, and boredom, and any real transformation of society would have to transform everyday life, recovering festival, play, and creativity.

His most influential work, The Production of Space of 1974, argued that space is not an empty container in which social life takes place. It is a social product, created by human activity and shaped by relations of power. Every society produces its own space. The medieval town, with its cathedral at the centre, its market square and its walls, expressed one social order. The modern capitalist city, with its business district, suburbs, highways, malls, gated colonies and segregated slums, expresses another.

Lefebvre distinguished three dimensions of space. Spatial practice is “perceived space”: the routines and routes of everyday life, how people actually move through and use space. It is the path a woman takes to the hand pump, or the commuter’s route to the station. Representations of space are conceived space: the abstract space of planners, architects, engineers, surveyors, and officials, the space of maps, master plans, zoning regulations, cadastral records, and working plans. Representational spaces are lived space: the space of inhabitants and users, charged with images, symbols, memories, and meanings, the sacred grove, the childhood courtyard, the corner where friends gathered, the place where something happened.

Modern capitalism, Lefebvre argued, tends to produce abstract space: homogeneous, fragmented, and hierarchical, treating space as a commodity to be divided into plots, bought, sold, and zoned for functions. Abstract space tends to override lived space, erasing the meanings that places hold for those who inhabit them.

The conflict between conceived and lived space is visible wherever planners' maps meet people's worlds. Consider the Niyamgiri hills in southern Odisha. To a mining company and the officials who approved its plans, the hills were a deposit of bauxite, mapped, measured, and valued, to feed an alumina refinery built at their foot. For the Dongria Kondh, a community of about eight thousand people who live on their slopes, the hills were the home of their god Niyam Raja. They were the source of their streams, the forest where they gathered food and medicine, and the ground of their identity and memory. In 2013, after a long legal and political struggle, the Supreme Court ruled that the gram sabhas of the affected villages must decide whether the mining would infringe their religious and cultural rights. Twelve villages held assemblies; all twelve rejected the mine. It was one of the rare cases in which lived space prevailed over the representation of space, and it showed precisely the conflict Lefebvre described.

When a forest that is a dwelling of gods is redrawn as a mining lease, a planner's map is overriding a lived world.

The right to the city

In 1968, in a book titled The Right to the City, Lefebvre called for a radical reclaiming of urban life. The right to the city, he argued, is not simply the right to use the city's existing resources. It is the right to change ourselves by changing the city: to participate in shaping urban space, to inhabit the city as a collective work, an oeuvre, rather than a commodity. The slogan has been taken up by urban movements across the world. In Indian cities the idea echoes in struggles against the demolition of informal settlements, which house a large share of city people. It echoes in street vendors’ claims to space on pavements, which led to a national law in 2014 recognising their right to sell. And it echoes in debates over whom the new smart cities and expressways are built for. When a basti of thousands is cleared for a flyover or a beautification project, and its residents are moved to resettlement colonies far from their work, Lefebvre’s question returns: whose city is it?

The space of flows

Castells argued, in The Rise of the Network Society of 1996, that a new form of society had emerged in the late twentieth century, organized around networks powered by microelectronic information and communication technologies. The network, a set of interconnected nodes, had become the dominant organizational form, replacing the vertical hierarchies of the industrial age. Corporations became networks of subcontractors, suppliers, and partners spread across the world; finance became a global network of electronically linked markets trading in real time; even criminal organizations and social movements became networks. The economy had become informational, because productivity depended on the capacity to generate, process, and apply knowledge, and global, because its core activities operated as a unit on a planetary scale in real time.

The network society, Castells argued, transforms our experience of space and time. He separated two kinds of space. The “space of flows” is made of electronic networks, airports and financial centres, the channels through which power, money and information now move. The “space of places” is the localities where most people live, with their histories, meanings and face-to-face relationships. Power increasingly resides in the space of flows, while people remain in places. Elites are cosmopolitan, mobile, connected to one another across continents; ordinary people are local. A software engineer in Bengaluru may spend her day in meetings with colleagues in California and Germany, her work flowing through networks that span the planet. Meanwhile the woman who cleans her flat lives in a village swallowed by the city’s sprawl, and her world ends at her neighbourhood.

Bengaluru's own geography shows the pattern vividly. Its technology parks, such as Electronic City in the south, Whitefield in the east and the corridor along the Outer Ring Road, are nodes in the global space of flows. They are glass towers linked to the world by fibre-optic cables, where companies serve clients in New York and London. Around and between them lie villages swallowed by the city and informal settlements of construction workers from northern and eastern India. There are old neighbourhoods whose lakes have been encroached on and polluted, and traffic that can take two hours to cross a few kilometres. The two kinds of space are physically adjacent and socially worlds apart.

The second volume of Castells's work, The Power of Identity, argued that against the abstract, placeless power of networks, people increasingly turn to identity, religious, ethnic, national, regional, as a source of meaning. The network and the self, the global and the local, are the two poles of the new society. Castells described three kinds of identity. “Legitimising” identities support dominant institutions. “Resistance” identities dig trenches against domination, as in religious fundamentalism, ethnic nationalism and regional movements. “Project” identities aim to transform society, as in feminism and environmentalism. The decades in which India's technology hubs rose were also decades of resurgent identity politics, regional, religious, and caste-based, and Castells's framework suggests that the two are connected.

The global city

Many observers in the 1980s assumed that globalization and information technology would make cities less important: if information can travel anywhere instantly, why should companies cluster in expensive urban centres? In The Global City of 1991, Sassen showed the opposite. The very dispersal of economic activity across the globe, factories in China and Mexico, back offices and call centres in India and the Philippines, created a new need for centralized command and control. Coordinating a global network of production, finance, and trade requires highly specialized services: corporate law, accounting, financial engineering, advertising, consulting, insurance. These services gather in a small number of global cities: first New York, London and Tokyo, and later Paris, Frankfurt, Hong Kong, Singapore, Shanghai, Dubai and Mumbai. They become the command posts of the world economy.

Global cities, Sassen showed, produce a sharp polarization. At the top are highly paid professionals in finance and corporate services, whose incomes drive up housing prices and create demand for luxury consumption. Their lifestyles in turn require a vast army of low-wage workers, often migrants: cleaners, cooks, nannies, drivers, security guards, delivery riders, construction labourers. The global city is both a site of extreme concentration of wealth and a magnet for the poor, a place where the global North and the global South meet in the same streets. The middle tends to shrink.

Mumbai displays this structure with almost diagrammatic clarity. The Bandra-Kurla Complex is a business district of glass towers housing banks, company headquarters, consulates and the stock exchange’s newer offices. It stands within sight of Dharavi, one of Asia’s largest informal settlements, home to perhaps a million people in a little over two square kilometres. Dharavi is also a dense economy of leather tanning, pottery, garment making, recycling and food processing, with an estimated yearly turnover in the hundreds of millions of dollars. Many of Dharavi's residents work in the services that keep the global city running. In three decades, Gurugram outside Delhi grew from villages and farmland into a city of corporate towers, malls and gated housing. It is staffed by people from the surrounding villages and by migrant workers renting rooms in the old village centres. Glittering wealth and makeshift labour sit side by side.

Rooftops of Dharavi in Mumbai, a dense settlement of small homes and workshops
PlateDharavi, Mumbai: homes and workshops packed into a little over two square kilometres, within sight of the glass towers of the Bandra-Kurla Complex. Photo: Kounosu / Wikimedia Commons

Sassen also challenged the idea that globalization means the decline of the nation-state. National states, she argued, have been active participants in globalization, rewriting their own laws to accommodate global capital, creating special economic zones, and denationalizing parts of themselves. In Expulsions of 2014 she argued that the global economy is increasingly marked by brutal expulsions: of people from land, homes, jobs, and countries, and of living things from the biosphere. The language of inequality, she suggested, no longer captures a system that does not merely leave people behind but pushes them out.

The work of the imagination

Appadurai rejected the idea that globalization simply means the homogenization of world culture, its Americanization. Cultural flows, he argued, move in many directions, and local cultures indigenize global forms in unexpected ways. He proposed five dimensions of global cultural flow, which he called scapes, to emphasize that they look different depending on where one stands. Ethnoscapes are the landscapes of people who move: tourists, migrants, refugees, exiles, guest workers. Mediascapes are the flows of images and stories through films, television, newspapers, and the internet. Technoscapes are the global configurations of technology crossing borders. Financescapes are the flows of capital through currency markets, stock exchanges, and investment. Ideoscapes are the flows of political ideas: democracy, rights, freedom, sovereignty. These scapes are disjunctive: they move at different speeds and in different directions, producing tensions and unexpected combinations.

Appadurai's most important insight concerned the imagination. In a world of electronic media and mass migration, he argued, the imagination has become a social practice, an organized field of everyday activity. Ordinary people across the world now imagine possible lives, in other places, other careers, other selves, shaped by images from films, television, and the internet, and by stories carried back by migrants. A young man in a Bihar village watches Hindi films and dreams of Mumbai. A nurse in Kerala imagines a life in the Gulf, Britain or Canada, guided by stories from relatives who went before. A Gujarati family’s son is in New Jersey. A girl in a hill town learns English from videos and dreams of working in a city she has only seen on a screen. Their imagined worlds are shaped by global flows, and these in turn shape what they do. Since the 1970s, migration to the Gulf states has transformed Kerala’s economy and society. Money sent home has built houses, paid for education and changed family structures. The Gulf has become a central part of Kerala’s imagination, in films, songs and the dreams of the young. The imagination is no longer the preserve of artists and visionaries; it is a force in everyday life.

Appadurai also described cricket as an example of indigenization. Cricket was a thoroughly English, colonial game, first played by British officers and Parsi clubs. Indians transformed it, through regional-language radio commentary from the 1950s, through television and through business, into a national passion and a vehicle of Indian identity. India became the financial centre of world cricket, and the Indian Premier League one of the richest sports competitions on earth. The colonizer's game became the colonized's festival. His later book, Fear of Small Numbers of 2006, asked why globalization produced not only flows and connections but an upsurge of ethnic violence. Majorities, he argued, can come to feel threatened by small minorities, whose existence reminds them that the national whole is incomplete, and the anxiety of incompleteness can turn into the violence of purification.

Glocalization

Globalization, Robertson argued, refers both to the compression of the world, the intensification of connections across it, and to the intensification of consciousness of the world as a single place. It is not only economic but cultural: people increasingly think of themselves as living in one world, comparing their lives, institutions, and identities with those of others everywhere.

Robertson's best-known contribution is the concept of glocalization, a term borrowed from Japanese business language, where it referred to adapting farming techniques to local conditions and later to tailoring global products for local markets. Robertson argued that the global and the local are not opposites. Globalization does not simply erase local cultures; it creates new forms of locality and intensifies local identities. The local is produced, in part, by the global. Think of the global fast-food chain that, in India, took beef and pork off its menu, introduced a potato-patty burger and separate vegetarian kitchens, and adjusted its spices. Think of the satellite TV boom of the 1990s. It was expected to Americanise Indian culture and instead produced an explosion of channels in Tamil, Telugu, Bengali, Marathi, Bhojpuri and other regional languages. Or think of yoga. It travelled from India to the West, became a fitness and wellness industry with studios, brands and clothing lines, and came back to Indian cities in its new global form, alongside an International Day of Yoga declared by the United Nations in 2014. The universal and the particular, Robertson argued, constitute each other: every global phenomenon becomes local somewhere, and every local identity is increasingly defined in global terms.

A world in motion

Urry first made his name with The Tourist Gaze (1990). It showed that tourism is an organised way of consuming places through a way of seeing. Guidebooks, postcards, photos, ads and now social media define what is worth seeing and how to see it, usually in contrast to everyday life. The tourist gaze transforms the places it falls on. Villages and monuments are reshaped to match visitors' expectations; local people learn to perform authenticity; festivals are rescheduled for tourist seasons; heritage sites are redesigned as backdrops for photographs. Tribal dance troupes perform for visitors at resorts. Old havelis become heritage hotels. A waterfall in a forest region gets viewing platforms, car parks and selfie points, and the forest communities around it become part of the scenery. Urry's analysis does not condemn tourism, which brings income and connection, but shows how the gaze of outsiders reshapes the lives of the gazed-upon.

In Mobilities of 2007 he analysed the many systems of movement, walking, railways, cars, aircraft, the internet, and their consequences. He was particularly concerned with the system of automobility, the car-based way of life that shaped twentieth-century cities, suburbs, families, and economies and locks in high-carbon living. Delhi, with its expanding flyovers, its millions of private vehicles, its winter smog, and its long commutes, is a vivid case of a city reshaped around automobility. In his last years Urry wrote about climate change, the offshoring of wealth and carbon emissions, and the futures of societies that would have to learn to move less.

The stranger at the station

Return to Churchgate at six. The commuters are Simmel's metropolitans, blasé and reserved, and also his strangers, migrants from every state, near and far at once. The station is a node in Lefebvre's produced space and Urry's mobilities, its timetables and crowds shaped by the city's planners and its people's routines. The offices they are leaving belong to Sassen's global city, and some of them work in Castells's space of flows, while many live in the space of places in distant suburbs or informal settlements. Their phones carry Appadurai's mediascapes; their dreams are shaped by his work of the imagination; the snacks they buy are glocal. The city is not a container. It is a living, contested, ever-changing production, made by all of them every day.

In all these flows, one thing has been taken for granted: that the actors are human beings. The last chapter of this book considers a strange and powerful idea, that roads, machines, microbes, documents, and rivers are actors too, and that society cannot be understood without them.

Curated by Claude from my favourite reads. About this material