Chapter 9
What the Long Marriages Know
Fifty years of research on what keeps couples together: John Gottman’s Love Lab, Eli Finkel’s all-or-nothing marriage, Stephanie Coontz’s history of the institution, and the Harvard study that followed hundreds of men for most of a century.
Case history: Mr and Mrs Iyer, married fifty-one years
Asked the secret of their long marriage, Mr Iyer, 79, laughs. “There’s no secret. We fought plenty. For the first ten years I thought we’d made a mistake.”
Mrs Iyer, 75, adds: “He’s stubborn. I’m stubborn. But one thing: we never insulted each other. Not once. Angry, yes. Shouting, sometimes. But I never made him feel small, and he never made me feel small. And every night, however angry we were, we had tea together. We’d sit on the balcony. Sometimes we didn’t speak. But we sat.”
“Also,” says Mr Iyer, “she’s funny. Fifty-one years and she still makes me laugh.”
The Iyers don’t know it, but they’ve described, almost point by point, some of the central findings of the most famous programme of marriage research ever conducted.
The Love Lab
Starting in the 1970s, the psychologist John Gottman, working first with the psychologist Robert Levenson and later at the University of Washington in Seattle, began bringing couples into a laboratory that came to be nicknamed the “Love Lab.” Couples were videotaped as they discussed their days and argued about their disagreements. Their heart rates, sweat responses and facial expressions were measured. Some couples spent whole weekends in an apartment-style lab fitted with cameras. Then Gottman’s team followed the couples for years to see who stayed together and who split up.
The results, summarized for a general audience in The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work (1999, with Nan Silver), were striking. Gottman claimed his team could predict, with high accuracy in their samples, which couples would divorce. Those claims have drawn methodological criticism, and predictions made after the fact always look more impressive than they are. But the patterns Gottman identified have proved influential and broadly consistent with other research.
The Four Horsemen
Gottman identified four ways of fighting that, in his research, were strong predictors of divorce. He called them, with some drama, the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse.
- Criticism: attacking a partner’s character rather than complaining about a behaviour. “You never think of anyone but yourself,” rather than “I was upset when you didn’t call.”
- Contempt: treating a partner as beneath you, through sarcasm, mockery, eye-rolling, sneering or name-calling. Gottman found contempt to be the single best predictor of divorce. Contempt, he argued, is fuelled by long-simmering negative thoughts about the partner, and it communicates disgust.
- Defensiveness: responding to complaints by counterattacking or playing the innocent victim, refusing to take any responsibility.
- Stonewalling: withdrawing from interaction entirely, shutting down, going silent, turning away. Often a response to feeling physiologically flooded.
Every couple shows some of these sometimes. What predicts trouble, Gottman found, is when they become the habitual way of fighting, and when they’re not offset by enough positivity.
Notice what Mrs Iyer said: I never made him feel small, and he never made me feel small. That’s the absence of contempt. Fifty-one years of anger, and never contempt.
Gottman's most robust finding: it isn't conflict that destroys marriages. It's contempt.
The magic ratio
Gottman also found that stable couples maintained, during conflict, a ratio of roughly five positive interactions for every negative one: touches, smiles, expressions of interest, humour, affection, acknowledgement. Unstable couples dropped closer to one to one. The specific number shouldn’t be treated as a law, but the principle is important: a good marriage isn’t one without negativity. It’s one where the positive substantially outweighs it.
Bids and turning toward
Perhaps Gottman’s most practical discovery concerns what he calls bids for connection. A bid is any attempt by one partner to get the other’s attention, interest or affection. It can be tiny: “Look at that bird,” a sigh, a hand on the shoulder, a comment about the news. The partner can respond in three ways: turn toward (engage), turn away (ignore or miss it) or turn against (respond with irritation).
In a study of newlyweds followed for six years, Gottman and his colleague Janice Driver found that couples who were still married at the follow-up had turned toward each other’s bids roughly 86 per cent of the time. Couples who had divorced had done so only about a third of the time. Lasting love, it seems, is built less in grand gestures than in thousands of small moments of responsiveness.
The Iyers’ evening tea on the balcony, even in silence, is a ritual of turning toward. They kept showing up for each other every day.
Friendship and the sound relationship house
Gottman’s broader model, which he called the Sound Relationship House, places friendship at the foundation of a lasting marriage. Its levels include building love maps (a detailed knowledge of your partner’s inner world: their worries, hopes, history, preferences), sharing fondness and admiration, turning toward instead of away, and, at the top, creating shared meaning: rituals, goals, values and a sense of purpose together.
Gottman also made an observation that frees many couples from despair. In his research, about 69 per cent of relationship conflicts were “perpetual problems”: disagreements rooted in fundamental differences of personality or values that never get fully resolved. One partner is tidy, the other messy. One wants more socializing, the other less. One is a saver, the other a spender. Happy couples, Gottman found, don’t resolve these problems. They learn to live with them, with humour, acceptance and ongoing dialogue, rather than gridlock.
This means the goal isn’t to find a partner without differences. There’s no such person. The goal is to find a partner with whom your particular set of differences is livable.
The all-or-nothing marriage
The psychologist Eli Finkel, in The All-or-Nothing Marriage (2017), set Gottman-style research in historical context. Finkel argued that American marriage, and by extension marriage in much of the modern world, has passed through three eras.
In the institutional era, before roughly 1850, marriage was primarily about economic survival and social order: food, shelter, children, inheritance. In the companionate era, from roughly 1850 to 1965, marriage came to be about love, companionship and the division of roles. And in the self-expressive era, since around 1965, people increasingly expect marriage to help them grow, to fulfil them, to support their self-discovery and personal development.
Finkel’s central claim is that the best marriages today are better than ever, because partners who invest deeply in each other can help each other flourish in ways earlier generations rarely expected. But the average marriage is struggling, because we’re asking more of it while often investing less time and energy in it. He compares it to climbing Maslow’s hierarchy of needs: modern couples ask their marriages to fulfil needs at the peak, self-actualization and personal growth, but the oxygen up there is thin, and you need a lot of investment to breathe.
His practical advice is twofold. Either invest more in the marriage, with time, attention and genuine engagement in each other’s growth, or ask less of it by meeting some needs elsewhere: in friendships, community, work and personal pursuits. Finkel calls this the “lean marriage” option, and argues it can be just as healthy. Not every need has to be met by one person.
Finkel's warning: we ask our spouse to be our best friend, lover, therapist, co-parent and life coach. No single person can carry all of that without help.
Marriage, a history
The historian Stephanie Coontz’s Marriage, a History (2005) widens the frame further. For most of human history, Coontz shows, marriage was not primarily about love. It was about property, alliances between families, labour, inheritance, political power and the rearing of children. Love was considered a poor basis for something so important. In many societies, excessive love between spouses was even viewed with suspicion, as a threat to obligations to the wider family.
The idea that marriage should be based on love, Coontz argues, became widespread in Western Europe and North America only in the late eighteenth century. It was a revolutionary idea, and it gave marriage new meaning and new fragility. When marriage is based on love, it can end when love seems to end.
Coontz’s history is valuable because it frees us from the assumption that there is one natural form of marriage. Arranged marriages, love marriages, marriages of companionship, marriages of partnership: all are human inventions, each with characteristic strengths and weaknesses. Many Indian couples today live at a junction of several eras at once, part institutional (family, duty, social expectation), part companionate, part self-expressive. That’s part of why the questions feel so tangled. One is often trying to satisfy several different ideals of marriage at once.
The Harvard study
Finally, what does marriage do for a whole life? The Harvard Study of Adult Development, which began in 1938 and is among the longest-running studies of human lives ever conducted, followed hundreds of men (and later their wives and children) for more than eight decades. Under its directors George Vaillant and later Robert Waldinger, its most consistent finding was simple: the quality of close relationships was among the strongest predictors of health and happiness in later life, stronger than wealth, fame, social class or IQ.
In Waldinger’s widely shared summary, the people who were most satisfied in their relationships at age fifty were the healthiest at age eighty. Good relationships seemed to buffer people against the pains of ageing. And “good” didn’t mean conflict-free. Many of the happiest couples bickered. What mattered was whether, in the end, they could count on each other.
What lasts, in summary
Put the research together and a picture emerges, remarkably close to what the Iyers described without any of it:
- Respect, the absence of contempt, matters more than the absence of conflict.
- Friendship, knowing and liking each other, is the foundation.
- Small daily responsiveness, turning toward bids, builds more than grand gestures.
- Positivity should substantially outweigh negativity.
- Accepting perpetual differences works better than trying to eliminate them.
- Not asking one person to meet every need protects the marriage.
- Being able to count on each other is what the decades finally reward.
Notice what isn’t on the list: an impressive résumé, a striking appearance, the approval of outsiders, endless excitement, the absence of other attractive people in the world. These may matter in the first year. Fifty years in, the Iyers didn’t mention any of them.
What to take from this chapter
- Contempt, not conflict, is the strongest predictor of divorce. Respect is non-negotiable.
- Lasting couples turn toward each other’s small bids for connection, again and again.
- Most conflicts are perpetual. The task is to live well with differences, not to remove them.
- Modern marriage asks a lot. Invest more, or ask it to carry less.
- Over a lifetime, relationship quality predicts health and happiness more than wealth or status.