Chapter 10
Love as an Art, Not a Feeling
Erich Fromm on love as a capacity you practise, M. Scott Peck on why falling in love isn’t love, Rilke on two solitudes, Buber on meeting, and Kabir on the narrow lane where there’s no room for two.
Case history: Farhan, 36
Farhan has been in three long relationships. Each began with intense love and each ended, a few years in, when “the feeling faded.” He describes himself as a romantic. He believes in the one, in a connection so powerful that it carries a couple through everything. “When it’s right,” he says, “you’ll just know.”
Recently, watching his parents care for each other through his father’s illness, his mother spooning soup, his father joking weakly to make her laugh, he found himself wondering whether he’d misunderstood something important. “They don’t look like they’re ‘in love,’” he says. “They look like something else. Something I don’t have a word for.”
The art of loving
In 1956 the German-American psychoanalyst and social philosopher Erich Fromm published a short book that has never gone out of print: The Art of Loving. Its premise is in the title. Love, Fromm argued, is not primarily a feeling that happens to us, a “pleasant sensation” one falls into if lucky enough. It’s an art, like music, medicine or carpentry, which requires knowledge, effort, discipline, concentration and patience.
Fromm believed that most people get love wrong in three ways. First, they see the problem of love as the problem of being loved, of being lovable, attractive, desirable, rather than of loving, the capacity to love. Second, they see love as a problem of finding the right object, the right person, rather than of developing the right faculty. They think loving is easy and finding someone worth loving is hard. Fromm thought the reverse. Third, they confuse the initial experience of falling in love, the sudden collapse of barriers between two strangers, with the lasting state of being in love, what he called standing in love.
For Fromm, most people think loving is easy and finding the right person is hard. He thought it was the other way round.
The falling, Fromm observed, is intense precisely because two people were strangers. Its intensity often reflects how lonely they were before, not how deep the connection is. And it’s bound to fade as the strangers become familiar. People who mistake the falling for love conclude, when it fades, that love is gone, and they go looking for a new stranger. Farhan’s three relationships are this pattern exactly.
The four elements
What, then, is mature love? Fromm described it as an active power that breaks through the walls separating us from others while letting each person keep their own integrity. Union under the condition of preserving one’s individuality, close to Schnarch’s differentiation in Chapter 4. He named four elements common to all forms of love:
- Care: active concern for the life and growth of the one we love. Fromm said that where there’s no active concern, there’s no love, however strong the feelings.
- Responsibility: not duty imposed from outside, but the voluntary readiness to respond to another person’s needs, expressed or unexpressed.
- Respect: from the Latin respicere, to look at. The ability to see a person as they are, to be aware of their unique individuality, and to want them to grow in their own way, for their own sake, not to serve me.
- Knowledge: the effort to know another person deeply, beyond the surface, beyond my own projections and concerns.
Notice how closely these track Gottman’s findings in the last chapter, from a completely different starting point. Respect is the antidote to contempt. Knowledge is the “love map.” Care and responsibility are turning toward bids.
Fromm also made a claim that bears on Farhan’s romantic hopes: love is a decision, a judgement, a promise. If love were only a feeling, he reasoned, there would be no basis for the promise to love someone for ever. Feelings come and go. But a decision and a commitment can be kept.
Falling in love is not love
The American psychiatrist M. Scott Peck made a similar argument in The Road Less Traveled (1978), one of the best-selling works of popular psychology ever written. Peck defined love as the will to extend one’s self for the purpose of nurturing one’s own or another’s spiritual growth. Every word of that definition was deliberate. Love is an act of will, not just feeling. It extends the self, involving effort, stretching and discipline. And it aims at growth, of both people.
By this definition, Peck argued, falling in love isn’t love at all. Falling in love, he suggested, is a temporary collapse of ego boundaries: the sudden, ecstatic sense of merging with another person. It’s effortless. It happens to us. And it always ends. When the ego boundaries snap back into place, as they inevitably do, people discover they’re two separate individuals with separate needs and wills. That, Peck argued, is the moment when real love can begin, because now love requires work.
Peck was also sharp about dependency, which he insisted is not love. A person who says “I can’t live without you” is describing parasitism, he argued, not love. Genuine love leaves the lover free and wants the beloved free. It’s chosen, not compelled.
Peck: the end of falling in love isn't the end of love. It's the moment when real love becomes possible.
Two solitudes
The poet Rainer Maria Rilke (1875–1926), in letters to a young poet and to friends, offered an image of love that many people have found clarifying. Rilke thought the highest task of a bond between two people was for each to stand guard over the solitude of the other. Love, in his view, wasn’t the merging of two incomplete people into one. It was the meeting of two whole people who protected each other’s inner space, who greeted and bordered each other while each stayed fully themselves.
An older version of the same idea comes from the Lebanese-American poet Kahlil Gibran, whose The Prophet (1923) is often read at weddings. Gibran’s prophet counsels couples to let there be spaces in their togetherness, and to stand together yet not too near, like the pillars of a temple, which stand apart and so hold up the roof.
Both images point to the same truth Perel described from the consulting room: closeness that leaves no room for separateness eventually suffocates both love and desire.
I and Thou
The philosopher Martin Buber (1878–1965), in I and Thou (1923), distinguished two fundamental ways of relating. In the I–It relation, we treat others as objects: things to be used, evaluated, compared, analysed, valued for their function. In the I–Thou relation, we meet another person fully and directly, as a whole presence, not reducible to their qualities or uses.
Most of daily life, Buber acknowledged, is necessarily I–It. We can’t meet every shopkeeper as a Thou. But in love, the I–It stance is poison. When we evaluate our partner’s résumé, appearance or social value, compare them with others, or ask what they say about us, we’re treating them as an It. Every comparison in Chapter 7 was an I–It act. Love, for Buber, lives in the moments when we stop evaluating and simply meet.
Kabir’s narrow lane
The fifteenth-century mystic poet Kabir, writing in the vernacular Hindi of North India, compressed much of this into a couplet that’s still sung today:
जब मैं था तब हरि नहीं, अब हरि हैं मैं नाहिं।
प्रेम गली अति साँकरी, जामें दो न समाहिं॥
When I was, Hari was not; now Hari is, and I am not.
The lane of love is very narrow; two cannot fit in it.
Kabir was speaking of love for the divine, and the “two” that can’t fit are the ego and the beloved. But the couplet speaks to human love as well. As long as the I takes up the whole lane, with its comparisons, its status, its fears, its keeping of options and its worry about how things look, there’s no room for the other person. Love asks the ego to step aside a little. Not to disappear, as Rilke and Fromm would insist, but to stop filling every space.
Nishkama: love without the ledger
The Gita offers one more idea worth borrowing. Its central ethical teaching is nishkama karma, action performed without attachment to its fruits. Krishna tells Arjuna that he has a right to his actions but not to their results. Act well, wholeheartedly, and let go of the demand that the world pay you back in a particular currency.
Applied to marriage, this suggests a kind of love that doesn’t keep a ledger: I’ve given this much, so I deserve that much back. I’ve sacrificed this, so she must provide that. Ledger-keeping, as Gottman and Lerner would both recognize, is a slow poison. That doesn’t mean tolerating exploitation or abandoning fairness. Mutuality matters. But at its best, love is something you do, fully and generously, rather than a transaction you audit.
Farhan’s new word
Farhan read Fromm at a friend’s suggestion. He told her afterwards that he’d finally found the word for what he saw between his parents. It wasn’t a feeling. It was a practice, sustained over forty years.
“I always thought love was something that happened to you,” he said. “I kept waiting for it to happen and stay. But it doesn’t stay. You have to keep doing it.”
What to take from this chapter
- Love is an art, a capacity to develop, not mainly a feeling to find. The real problem is loving, not finding someone worthy of love.
- Falling in love is a temporary collapse of boundaries. Its fading is where mature love begins, not where love ends.
- Mature love combines care, responsibility, respect and knowledge.
- Healthy love protects each partner’s solitude and individuality.
- Comparison and evaluation are I–It acts. Love lives in meeting the person as a whole.
- Love without a ledger, given wholeheartedly, is the Gita’s answer to the anxious bargaining of the ego.