Rohit Shah

Chapter 8

The Road Not Taken: What Infidelity Reveals

Why people who love their partners still stray, what an affair is often really looking for, and what the study of betrayal teaches anyone about protecting a marriage before trouble starts. With Esther Perel’s The State of Affairs.

Case history: Sunita, 42

Sunita has been married for seventeen years to a good man. She has two teenage children, a respected career and a comfortable home. Two years ago she began an affair with a colleague. When it was discovered, everyone around her wanted to know what was wrong with her marriage.

“That’s what I can’t explain,” she says. “Nothing was wrong. My husband is kind. We rarely fight. I wasn’t unhappy with him. I was unhappy with me. With the woman I’d become: responsible, efficient, invisible. With this other man I felt like I was twenty-five again. Alive. Like someone who had a future instead of just a schedule.”

Affairs aren’t always about the marriage

The conventional view of infidelity holds that people cheat because something is lacking at home: not enough intimacy, not enough love, not enough attention. That’s sometimes true. But Esther Perel, in The State of Affairs (2017), drawing on years of work with couples dealing with infidelity around the world, argued that it misses a large part of the picture.

People who stray, Perel observed, are often not looking for another person so much as another self. The affair offers a way back to a version of oneself that seemed lost: younger, freer, more desirable, less burdened. What’s being sought isn’t necessarily a better partner. It’s a different experience of being alive. Paraphrasing one of her most quoted ideas: sometimes, when we seek the gaze of another, it isn’t our partner we’re turning away from but the person we’ve become.

Many affairs aren't a search for a better partner but for a lost self: younger, freer, more alive.

This doesn’t excuse betrayal. Perel is clear that affairs cause profound pain and that the betrayed partner’s suffering must come first in any recovery. But it does explain why people in happy marriages sometimes stray, and that makes it useful knowledge for anyone hoping to protect a marriage.

The longing for the unlived life

Sunita’s affair is a dramatic answer to a question raised in Chapter 1: the mourning of unlived lives. The affair is, in a way, the unlived life made briefly real. And it shares the defining feature of all unlived lives: it’s insulated from ordinary reality. Affairs typically happen in stolen hours. There are no bills to pay, no sick children, no in-laws, no household chores. Lovers meet only in their best moods, with all the urgency of secrecy and scarcity. It’s hardly surprising that an affair can feel more alive than a marriage. It’s being compared with a marriage on the marriage’s most ordinary days.

Many people who leave their marriages for an affair partner find that the new relationship, once it has bills and children and chores of its own, becomes as ordinary as the old one. The excitement belonged to the circumstances, not to the person.

What the research says

Infidelity is hard to study reliably, since people aren’t always honest about it, even in anonymous surveys. Estimates vary widely depending on how infidelity is defined and who’s asked. But some findings have been fairly consistent across studies:

  • Infidelity is common in nearly all societies, despite near-universal disapproval of it.
  • Relationship dissatisfaction raises the risk, but many people who stray report being reasonably satisfied with their partners.
  • Opportunity matters a great deal. Workplaces, travel and social situations where people spend extended time alone with someone they’re attracted to are common settings for affairs to begin.
  • Emotional affairs, intense, secret, intimate connections that stay non-physical, are often a precursor to physical ones. The secrecy and emotional intimacy are often what make the relationship feel special.

The psychologist Shirley Glass, who studied infidelity for decades, described affairs in her book Not “Just Friends” (2003) using a vivid image of walls and windows. In a healthy marriage, she argued, partners have a window between them, open and transparent, and a wall that protects the relationship from outsiders. In an affair, the arrangement reverses. A wall goes up between the spouses (secrets, things not shared), and a window opens with the affair partner (confiding, intimacy). Glass observed that many affairs begin not with desire but with friendships that gradually cross these boundaries: confiding in a colleague about marriage problems, sharing what isn’t shared at home.

Walls and windows in a healthy relationshipwindow between partners,wall toward outsidersHealthyWalls and windows when an affair takes holdwall between partners,window toward a thirdWhen an affair takes hold
FigureShirley Glass’s walls and windows. In a healthy marriage the partners keep a window open between them and a wall toward outsiders. In an affair the arrangement reverses: secrecy walls off the spouse, and the window opens toward someone else.

Glass's test: is there a window between you and your spouse, and a wall around the marriage? Or have you built them the other way round?

Why this matters before marriage

You might wonder why a chapter on infidelity belongs in a book for people who haven’t married yet. The answer is that the study of affairs is a study of what marriage leaves unmet, and therefore a guide to what to protect.

First, it tells us that the hunger for aliveness doesn’t go away when we marry. If we don’t find ways to feed it inside the marriage and in our own lives, through growth, new experiences, creative work, adventure and the Perel-style separateness of Chapter 4, it may look for food elsewhere.

Second, it tells us that the self matters as much as the partner. Sunita’s affair was about the woman she’d become. If she had kept more of herself alive, her friendships, her ambitions, her playfulness, her body, she might not have felt the need to rediscover it in secret. This is a warning for both partners. A marriage in which either person disappears into roles (provider, mother, efficient manager) is vulnerable.

Third, it tells us that boundaries are a practical matter, not only a moral one. Glass’s walls and windows suggest concrete habits: don’t confide in an attractive outsider about problems in your marriage, be transparent with your partner about your friendships, notice when a friendship starts to feel like a secret.

Can marriages survive infidelity?

Perel, Glass and many other clinicians report that many marriages do survive affairs, and some even emerge stronger, though always at great cost. Recovery typically requires the unfaithful partner to end the affair completely, to take full responsibility without blaming the spouse, to be transparent for a long time, and to tolerate the betrayed partner’s anger and questions. It also requires both partners to look honestly at what the marriage had become.

Perel describes how some couples, after an affair, effectively begin a “second marriage” with the same person, building something new on the ruins of the first. But she’s also clear that this kind of crisis is a terrible way to learn what could have been learned earlier. The better course is to ask the questions an affair would force before there’s an affair: Am I alive in this marriage? Is my partner? What have we stopped saying to each other? What parts of ourselves have we let die?

Sunita’s aftermath

Sunita’s husband was devastated. For a long time he couldn’t look at her. They went to therapy, not expecting much. Over two years, slowly, something changed. Sunita began to reclaim parts of herself she’d let go: she started painting again, travelled with friends, took on new challenges at work. Her husband, in turn, admitted that he too had gone numb in the marriage. He’d been dutiful but absent, safe but dull.

“The affair wasn’t worth it,” Sunita says. “The pain I caused was terrible. But I learned something I wish I’d known at twenty-five. Nobody else can keep me alive. That’s my job.”

What to take from this chapter

  • Affairs often seek a lost self rather than a better partner. They happen in happy marriages too.
  • An affair’s excitement belongs largely to its circumstances: secrecy, scarcity, no responsibilities.
  • Opportunity and gradually crossed boundaries matter. Keep a window open to your spouse and a wall around the marriage.
  • Protect your own aliveness, and your partner’s, inside the marriage. Nobody can do it for you.
  • Ask the questions an affair would force before there’s an affair.

Curated by Claude from my favourite reads. About this material