Rohit Shah

Chapter 1

The Tyranny of Open Doors

Why keeping every option open feels like freedom but tends to make us unhappier, and what the philosophers thought commitment was for.

Case history: Siddharth, 31

Siddharth is a surgeon in a large city, respected, busy and good-looking. He has been with Meera for four years. She is kind, funny and patient with his schedule, and both families like each other. Everyone expects a wedding. Every time the subject comes up, Siddharth feels something close to panic.

“It’s not that I don’t love her,” he tells a counsellor. “It’s that once I say yes, that’s it. I’ll never know what else was out there. There’s a resident in my department who’s brilliant and gorgeous, and I keep wondering whether I’d be happier with someone like her. Not her exactly. Someone like her. Someone more.”

Asked what “more” means, he can’t say. Asked whether he felt this way in earlier relationships, he admits he did. Asked whether he’d ever been with someone who made the feeling go away, he goes quiet for a long time.

Siddharth’s trouble isn’t Meera. It’s a mind trained to treat every choice as a loss. That habit has been studied in detail, and the results are counterintuitive.

The experiment with the photographs

In the early 2000s the Harvard psychologists Daniel Gilbert and Jane Ebert ran a deceptively simple study. Students in a photography course shot pictures around campus, learned to develop them, and were then told they could keep only one of their two favourite prints. The other would be filed away.

Half the students were told their choice was final. The other half were told they could swap any time in the next few days.

Before choosing, most students said they’d prefer the reversible option. Keeping the door open sounded better. But when they were later asked how much they liked the photograph they’d kept, the students with the final choice liked theirs more than the students who could still swap. Being able to change your mind didn’t make people happier with their choice. It made them less happy, and they never noticed.

Gilbert’s explanation is that people have what he calls a psychological immune system. Once a choice is final, the mind gets to work finding what is good in what we have. It notices strengths, softens flaws and builds a story of rightness. But that system only switches on once the matter is settled. While the door stays open, the mind keeps comparing, and constant comparison keeps any choice from becoming fully ours.

The mind starts making the best of what it has only once the decision is final. While the door stays open, it keeps shopping.

The implications for marriage are obvious and uncomfortable. The man who wants certainty before committing is asking for something that, psychologically, mostly comes after committing. Here the order of operations is inverted: you often can’t fully love what you haven’t fully chosen.

That does not mean any commitment will feel right once it’s made. (Chapter 11 is about doubts that really are warnings.) It means the particular feeling of “I can’t commit because I might miss something better” is not good evidence either way. That feeling tends to show up whoever the partner is.

Maximizers and satisficers

The psychologist Barry Schwartz, in The Paradox of Choice (2004), made popular a distinction first described by Herbert Simon, the economist and Nobel laureate. Some people are maximizers: they want the best possible option and feel driven to look at every alternative before choosing. Others are satisficers: they set a standard of “good enough” and choose the first option that meets it. Satisficers don’t necessarily have low standards. Their standards can be very high. What they don’t do is go on searching after the standard has been met.

A satisficer stops at the first option that meets the standard; a maximizer keeps searchingoptions considered, one after another →“good enough”satisficer stops heremaximizer keeps looking…
FigureBarry Schwartz’s distinction. A satisficer sets a high standard and stops at the first option that meets it. A maximizer keeps comparing, and in Schwartz’s studies tends to feel more regret, even when the outcome is objectively better.

In studies by Schwartz and his colleagues, people who scored high on maximizing reported, on average, less happiness, less optimism, more regret and more depression than satisficers. In some studies of job seekers, maximizers landed jobs with higher starting salaries and still felt worse about them. They had done “better” and felt worse, because they kept picturing the jobs they hadn’t taken.

You can probably see where this goes. A maximizer looking for a spouse faces a search with no natural end. However good a partner is, she can always be compared with an imagined better one. There is always someone more beautiful, more accomplished, more exciting, or (the most corrosive version) some unspecified more. Siddharth is a textbook maximizer. His problem would follow him into any relationship.

A word of caution about the research. Some well-known findings in this area, especially the famous “jam study” in which shoppers offered 24 flavours bought less than shoppers offered 6, have proved harder to replicate than first hoped. Choice overload is real but depends on circumstances. The maximizer–satisficer finding, and Gilbert’s work on reversible choices, have held up better. The broad lesson is solid even if particular numbers are debated: an endless search tends to rob you of the ability to enjoy what you find.

What you actually lose when you close a door

Let’s take the fear seriously rather than explain it away. When you marry someone, you really do give something up. You give up the possibility of other partners. You give up a certain kind of novelty, the thrill of the new person, the first kiss, the first unveiling of a stranger’s mind. The loss is real, and anyone who tells you otherwise is selling something.

But look closely at what that “possibility” is made of. Every unlived life you imagine has something in common: it is imaginary. The brilliant resident Siddharth fantasizes about has no bad moods, no family quarrels, no illnesses, no habits that grate after ten years. She doesn’t need anything from him at three in the morning. She can’t disappoint him, because she exists only as a sketch his longing has drawn. Comparing a real partner with an imagined one is comparing a person with a daydream, and the daydream always wins.

The psychoanalyst Adam Phillips has written about this in a way that’s useful here. A great deal of human life, he suggests, is spent mourning the lives we didn’t live, and those unlived lives tend to look better than the lived one precisely because we haven’t had to live them. The cure isn’t to stop imagining. It’s to recognize the unlived life for what it is: a story we tell ourselves, often about something other than the person we think we’re dreaming of.

What Siddharth wants isn’t, in the end, a different woman. It’s a different version of himself: younger, less committed, admired, at the start of everything. That longing is very human. But no other partner can satisfy it, because it isn’t about a partner.

Kierkegaard’s two lives

The Danish philosopher Søren Kierkegaard (1813–1855) thought harder about this than almost anyone, partly because he lived it. He broke off his engagement to Regine Olsen, the woman he loved, and spent the rest of his short life writing about the decision.

His first great book, Either/Or (1843), sets two ways of life side by side. The first, which he calls the aesthetic, belongs to a gifted young man who lives for interesting experiences. He fears boredom above all and avoids anything that would tie him down: marriage, a career, a fixed identity. In a famous essay called “The Rotation of Crops,” this young aesthete explains his method. A farmer who exhausts one field moves to another. The wise person, he says, should treat experiences the same way, never letting anything become routine and always changing the soil. But he then adds a twist. Truly sophisticated living isn’t about changing fields at all. It’s about changing how you cultivate the same field: finding novelty through attention and arbitrariness rather than endless new things.

The second half of the book is a set of long letters from an older man, a judge named William, who is happily married. He answers the aesthete. You think marriage kills romance, he writes in effect, but you have it backwards. First love left to itself is fragile. It’s a mood, and moods pass. Marriage is what gives first love a history. Choosing again and again, through ordinary days, turns an emotion into a self. The aesthete’s freedom, the Judge argues, is really a kind of despair. He’s so busy keeping options open that he never becomes anyone in particular.

For Kierkegaard, the man who keeps every door open never becomes anyone in particular. Choosing is how a self gets made.

Kierkegaard didn’t settle the argument in the Judge’s favour. He left it hanging, deliberately. The two halves are an “either/or” the reader has to decide for themselves. But the Judge’s central point has lasted: freedom isn’t only the absence of commitments. It’s also the ability to make one and keep it. The aesthete can do anything and therefore is nothing. The married man has closed doors, and inside the room he chose he has built something real.

The paradox of the promise

The philosopher Hannah Arendt, in The Human Condition (1958), described the promise as one of humanity’s great inventions. Human affairs are deeply unpredictable, she argued. We can’t know what we or others will do, or how we’ll feel in ten years. A promise is how human beings create “islands of predictability” in that sea of uncertainty. When I promise, I bind my future self to my present intention. I become someone who can be counted on.

Seen this way, the marriage vow isn’t a claim that your feelings will never change. That would be a foolish thing to promise, since nobody controls their feelings. It’s a promise about conduct and direction: whatever I feel on a given day, I’ll keep turning toward you, keep choosing us, keep working at this. Feelings rise and fall inside that structure. The structure stays.

This lifts a great deal of pressure. You don’t need to be sure you’ll feel passionate love at sixty. Nobody can be sure of that. What you need to know is whether this is a person you’re willing to keep choosing, and who’ll keep choosing you.

Back to Siddharth

In counselling, Siddharth eventually stopped asking “Is Meera the best possible person?” and started asking better questions. Do I respect her? Does she make me a better version of myself? When things go wrong, do we find our way back to each other? Is my restlessness about her, or did I bring it with me?

He found that the restlessness was older than the relationship. It had been there in medical school, in his choice of specialty, in his friendships. He always suspected that something better was happening somewhere else. Seeing that didn’t make the feeling vanish. It did make it less convincing. He began to treat it the way a person with chronic back pain treats a twinge: real, unpleasant, and not a reason to take drastic action.

The rest of this book will add complications. Sometimes restlessness is a signal. Sometimes desire really has drained out of a relationship. Sometimes the person really isn’t right. But start here: the fear of closed doors is not, by itself, information about your partner. It’s mostly information about how the human mind handles finality. It’s one of the most universal fears there is, and it’s at its loudest just before the door closes.

What to take from this chapter

  • Satisfaction with a choice often grows after the choice is final. Waiting to feel certain before committing can be backwards.
  • Maximizing, the endless search for the best, reliably lowers happiness, whatever the quality of what you find.
  • The unlived life always looks better because it’s imaginary. Compare real people with real people, not with daydreams.
  • A vow is a promise about conduct and direction, not a forecast of feelings.

Curated by Claude from my favourite reads. About this material