Chapter 2
What Attraction Is, and What It Is Mistaken For
Physical desire, romance and attachment are three different systems. Anxiety often passes itself off as chemistry. Attachment theory explains why the person who makes us calm can feel “boring,” and why the doubt itself is sometimes a strategy.
Case history: Karan and the two women
Karan, 29, an engineer, has had two serious relationships. The first was with Tanya. It was electric, unpredictable and exhausting. She’d go silent for days, then reappear full of affection. He was never sure where he stood. He thought about her constantly, checked his phone obsessively, and felt more alive than he ever had. It ended badly, and he took a year to recover.
The second relationship is with Priya. She replies to his messages. She says what she means. She’s warm, reliable and easy to be with. They talk for hours. She remembers what matters to him. And Karan finds himself wondering whether he’s really attracted to her. “There’s no spark,” he says. “With Tanya I couldn’t stop thinking about her. With Priya I feel… calm. Is that love, or is it just comfort?”
Karan’s question is one of the most common there is, and it rests on a misunderstanding that can wreck lives. To unpick it we need two pieces of science: the biology of love’s different systems, and the psychology of attachment.
Three systems, not one
The anthropologist Helen Fisher, who spent decades studying the neuroscience of love, proposed that what we call “love” is really three overlapping but distinct systems, each with its own brain chemistry and evolutionary job.
Desire (Fisher’s blunter word is lust) is the basic physical pull toward another person. Hormones like testosterone and oestrogen are heavily involved. It isn’t particularly choosy. It can be stirred by a stranger in a photograph.
Romantic attraction, what Fisher sometimes called romantic love and the psychologist Dorothy Tennov called limerence, is the obsessive, focused state of being “in love.” It involves the brain’s dopamine reward system, the same circuitry that drives craving. Its hallmarks are intrusive thoughts about one person, euphoria at signs of reciprocation, despair at signs of rejection, and a heightened energy and focus. Tennov, who interviewed hundreds of people in the 1970s, found that limerence typically lasts somewhere between eighteen months and three years, though the range is wide.
Attachment is the calm, secure bond of long-term partners, the feeling of comfort, safety and union. Hormones such as oxytocin and vasopressin play a role. It’s the system that keeps couples together long enough to raise children.
The three systems can run independently. You can feel a physical pull toward one person, romantic obsession for another and deep attachment to a third, all at once. That’s part of why human love is so confusing. It’s also why the absence of obsessive romantic feelings doesn’t mean the absence of love. It may mean the relationship is past the limerence phase, or never relied on it, and is running mainly on attachment.
Obsession, intrusive thoughts and anxious checking aren't evidence of a deep connection. Often they're evidence of uncertainty.
When anxiety passes for chemistry
There’s a famous experiment from 1974 by the psychologists Donald Dutton and Arthur Aron. An attractive female researcher approached men either on a frightening, swaying suspension bridge over a deep canyon or on a low, stable bridge. She asked them to fill in a questionnaire and gave them her phone number in case they had questions. The men on the frightening bridge were much more likely to call her afterwards, and they wrote more romantic content into a story they were asked to tell.
The interpretation is called the misattribution of arousal. The racing heart and adrenaline produced by the frightening bridge got read, at least partly, as attraction to the woman. The body doesn’t label its states neatly. A pounding heart can mean fear, excitement or desire, and the mind fills in the story.
Now think about Karan and Tanya. Her unpredictability kept him in a state of constant alarm: Does she still want me? Will she call? Is this over? That alarm felt like intensity, and intensity felt like love. With Priya there’s no alarm, and so, to a nervous system trained by the earlier relationship, no “spark.”
This leads us to attachment theory, which may be the single most useful framework for understanding modern romantic confusion.
Attachment styles
Attachment theory began with the British psychiatrist John Bowlby and the American psychologist Mary Ainsworth, who studied how infants bond with their caregivers. In the 1980s the researchers Cindy Hazan and Phillip Shaver showed that adults show similar patterns in romantic relationships. In Attached (2010), the psychiatrist Amir Levine and the psychologist Rachel Heller turned this research into a practical guide. Their framework, simplified, describes three main styles:
- Secure people are comfortable with intimacy and with independence. They can ask for what they need, they don’t panic when a partner is distant for a day, and they don’t feel smothered when a partner wants closeness. Roughly half the population, in most studies.
- Anxious people crave closeness and fear abandonment. They’re highly alert to signs that a partner may be pulling away and tend to respond with what Levine and Heller call protest behaviour: calling repeatedly, picking fights, trying to make the partner jealous. Roughly a fifth of the population.
- Avoidant people value independence highly and feel uncomfortable when a partner gets too close. They tend to keep partners at arm’s length, often without realizing they’re doing it. Roughly a quarter of the population.
(There’s a fourth, less common pattern, sometimes called fearful-avoidant or anxious-avoidant, that combines a longing for closeness with a fear of it.)
These styles aren’t fixed sentences. They’re tendencies, shaped by childhood, by temperament and by later relationships, and they can change, especially through long experience with a secure partner. But they shape whom we’re drawn to with startling force.
The anxious-avoidant trap
One of Levine and Heller’s most important observations is that anxious and avoidant people are disproportionately drawn to each other, and that the pairing is usually painful. The avoidant partner pulls away. The anxious partner’s alarm fires, and they pursue. The pursuit makes the avoidant partner feel crowded, and they pull away further. The cycle produces enormous emotional intensity, the highs of reconciliation and the lows of distance. People caught in it often mistake that intensity for passion.
Meanwhile, Levine and Heller observe, secure partners can strike anxiously attached people as “boring,” precisely because they don’t set off the attachment alarm. The anxious person has learned to read a nervous system on high alert as the feeling of love. A secure partner offers something unfamiliar: steadiness. And unfamiliar can feel like nothing at all.
To a nervous system used to alarm, safety can at first feel like the absence of love.
The avoidant’s toolkit: doubt as a strategy
There’s another side of attachment theory that bears directly on pre-marital doubt, and it needs careful handling, because it’s easy to misuse in either direction.
Levine and Heller describe a set of what they call deactivating strategies. These are mental and behavioural habits that avoidantly attached people use, usually without awareness, to keep a partner at a distance when closeness starts to feel threatening. Paraphrasing their list, these include:
- Saying or thinking “I’m not ready to commit” while staying in the relationship for years anyway.
- Focusing on a partner’s small imperfections: the way she talks, eats or dresses, her career, her looks. A minor flaw gets inflated into a deal-breaker.
- Fantasizing about an ex, the “phantom ex,” as the one who would have been perfect.
- Holding an idealized image of “the one,” a person who doesn’t exist but against whom every real partner falls short.
- Flirting with or fantasizing about others as a way of creating distance.
- Pulling away precisely when things are going well.
The striking point is the timing. Deactivation intensifies as intimacy grows. The closer the relationship comes to permanence, at an engagement or a wedding date, the louder the inner critic may become. The doubts feel like objective observations about the partner (“I’ve just noticed she’s not ambitious enough”). Functionally, they may be a defence against the vulnerability of real closeness.
Two cautions are essential here.
First, not every doubt is deactivation. Sometimes your partner really has a quality that matters. Sometimes you really aren’t compatible. Attachment theory doesn’t license you to dismiss every reservation as a defence mechanism. Chapter 11 looks at how to tell the difference.
Second, don’t diagnose yourself or your partner from a list. These patterns are tendencies on a continuum, and most people show a mix. Use the framework as a question, not a verdict: Is it possible that some of my doubts follow a pattern? Do they intensify as we get closer? Have I had similar doubts about every partner, focused on different flaws each time?
If the answer is yes, that’s worth knowing. It suggests the problem may lie less in whom you’ve chosen than in how you respond to being chosen.
The question beneath the question
Back to Karan. In therapy he came to see that what he called “spark” with Tanya was in large part the activation of his attachment system: the uncertainty, the chase, the relief when she returned. He’d been, in Levine and Heller’s terms, an anxiously attached person in a relationship with an avoidant one. His calm with Priya wasn’t the absence of love. It was what love feels like when it isn’t under threat.
That didn’t mean Karan could ignore questions of desire. Attraction matters in a marriage. We’ll spend Part Two on it. But he learned to ask a different question. Instead of “Do I feel the same rush I felt with Tanya?” he asked, “When I’m with Priya, do I feel drawn to her? Do I want to touch her, be near her, know her more?” The answers were more encouraging than he expected. They were quieter than the old rush, but present.
He also learned something about desire that we’ll take up in Chapter 5. In long relationships, desire often doesn’t arrive spontaneously, like lightning. It responds to closeness, context and attention. Karan had been waiting for lightning. He began, instead, to light fires.
What to take from this chapter
- Physical desire, romantic obsession and attachment are separate systems. The fading of obsession isn’t the fading of love.
- Physical alarm can feel like attraction. Intensity born of uncertainty is easy to mistake for depth.
- Secure partners can feel “boring” to people used to anxious relationships. That feeling usually fades, and it’s a poor guide.
- Doubts that grow louder as commitment gets closer, and that latch onto small flaws or an idealized “one,” may be a defence against intimacy. Treat this as a question, not a diagnosis.