Rohit Shah

Introduction

Before We Begin

Why the questions that keep you awake before a marriage are older than marriage itself, and why they deserve better answers than reassurance.

Almost everyone who approaches a lifelong commitment carries a few quiet worries they would rather not say aloud. Does choosing one person close every other door? Does settling down mean settling into dullness? Can the warmth and spark between two people last for forty years, or does it fade into polite routine? What is one to make of the passing pull of someone new? Why does another couple’s apparent good fortune sometimes sting? And what, over a whole lifetime, actually counts?

None of these questions is foolish, and none is new. Montaigne, writing in the 1580s, passed on an old comparison: marriage is like a cage, where the birds outside despair of getting in and the birds inside despair of getting out. Kierkegaard, in 1843, gave one of his invented authors an outburst that has never stopped being quoted: marry, and you will regret it; do not marry, and you will also regret it. The Bhagavad Gita spends whole chapters on a mind pulled about by the senses. The Buddha described desire as a thirst that drinking does not quench. And a whole modern industry of psychologists, from John Gottman’s “Love Lab” in Seattle to Esther Perel’s consulting room in New York, has spent decades watching couples to learn what keeps love alive and what quietly kills it.

This short book brings those voices together. It is built around the questions above, roughly in that order. Each chapter combines three kinds of material:

  • Case histories. These are composite portraits of the patterns therapists and researchers see again and again. The names, professions and details are invented. No case describes a real individual. They are here because ideas land better when you can watch them happen to someone.
  • Research and clinical expertise. Mostly from a shelf of widely read books on love and marriage: Gottman, Levine and Heller, Perel, Nagoski, Lerner, Gibson, Finkel, Coontz, Schnarch, Buss, Peck and Fromm, along with a handful of well-known studies.
  • Philosophy and older wisdom. Kierkegaard, Schopenhauer, the Stoics, the Gita, Buddhist psychology, Kabir, Rilke, Girard and others. Science tells us how people tend to behave. Philosophy asks what we ought to want.

A warning before we start. This book will not tell you that the right person makes desire effortless, that jealousy can be switched off for good, or that a real commitment never feels like a loss. All three are false, and believing them does real damage. The promise here is more modest and, I think, more useful. Most of the turmoil you feel comes from a few understandable mechanisms. Once you can see them, they lose much of their power. And underneath the noise there is a question you can actually answer.

How to read this book

It comes in four parts.

Part One, “Choosing,” covers the fear of closed doors, what attraction is (and what it is often mistaken for), and how the family we grew up in shapes whom we pick and how we doubt.

Part Two, “Desire,” covers the intimate side of long relationships: why security and passion pull in opposite directions, how desire really works (it is not what films suggest), and what to do with the pull of attractive strangers.

Part Three, “Comparison,” covers jealousy, envy and the habit of measuring our partner against other people’s, and then infidelity, the most dramatic form the road not taken can take.

Part Four, “What Lasts,” covers what decades of research say makes a marriage endure, what the philosophers of love say love actually is, how to tell ordinary cold feet from a real warning, how to design a shared life that keeps both freedom and responsibility in balance, and the daily practices that move a person toward the steadiness these questions are reaching for.

Read it in order the first time. The later chapters lean on the earlier ones.

One more thing before we start. If you bring questions like these to this book, they are not signs that something is wrong with you. They are signs that you are taking seriously a decision that deserves it. The aim is not to make them go away. The aim is to answer them well.

Curated by Claude from my favourite reads. About this material