Chapter 7
The Neighbour’s Garden: Jealousy, Envy and the Comparing Mind
Why we measure our partner against other people’s, why a partner’s beauty or success can feel like a verdict on us, and what René Girard, Bertrand Russell, the Stoics and social psychology say about getting free of the comparing mind.
Case history: Aditya, 33
Aditya is an architect at a large firm, ambitious, well respected and rising fast. He’s engaged to Shreya, whom he met through friends at university. They’re close friends. They care for each other deeply. And yet Aditya finds himself unsettled in a way he’s ashamed to admit.
At a colleague’s wedding he meets the bride, a doctor with a degree from a famous university and an elegant presence that everyone notices. Over dinner he watches his colleague glow with pride. On the drive home he feels something sour. Shreya hasn’t achieved anything like that. What will people think when they meet her? Does her life reflect badly on me? Then he feels disgusted with himself for thinking it.
Few emotions are more common in modern relationships, or more rarely discussed honestly, than this one: the painful comparison of one’s partner with someone else’s. It deserves a careful look, because it often masquerades as a judgement about the partner when it’s really a judgement about oneself.
Jealousy and envy are different
Ordinary speech blurs the two, but psychologists distinguish them. Jealousy is the fear of losing something you have, usually a relationship, to a rival. Envy is the pain of wanting something someone else has. Aditya isn’t jealous in this sense. Nobody is threatening to take Shreya away. He’s envious, though in a peculiar, displaced way. He envies his colleague not for his own qualities but for his wife’s. What he envies is the reflected status a partner can confer.
That’s a crucial clue. Aditya’s distress has very little to do with Shreya as a person, with her kindness, her humour, their friendship, how she treats him. It has to do with how she looks to others, and therefore how he looks to others through her.
Borrowed desire: Girard
The French literary critic and anthropologist René Girard (1923–2015) developed one of the most illuminating theories of desire ever proposed. In Deceit, Desire and the Novel (1961) and in later works, Girard argued that human desire is mimetic. We don’t simply want things because of their intrinsic qualities. We want them because others want them, or have them. Desire, in Girard’s account, is triangular: there’s the person who desires, the object desired, and a model, someone whose desire shows us what’s worth wanting.
Girard found this pattern throughout great literature. Don Quixote wants to be a knight because he has read about knights. Emma Bovary wants the life of the heroines in her romantic novels. Proust’s characters fall in love with people because rivals desire them.
Mimetic desire explains why comparison is so contagious. Aditya didn’t arrive at the wedding wanting a doctor with a famous degree. He walked in content. But watching his colleague’s pride, watching others admire the bride, made her qualities suddenly desirable. The colleague became a model. And by contrast, Shreya, whom Aditya had loved without reservation an hour earlier, seemed less.
Girard's insight is that much of what we want, we want because someone else wants it. The comparing mind is often borrowing its desires.
The value of Girard’s theory is that it lets us question a desire’s authenticity. When you find yourself wanting your partner to be more beautiful, more successful, more impressive, ask: Whose desire is this? Did I want this before I saw someone else have it? Would I want it if nobody else could see?
Reflection and comparison: Tesser
The social psychologist Abraham Tesser developed what he called the self-evaluation maintenance model in the 1980s. It explains a curious feature of human life: why we sometimes bask in the success of people close to us, and sometimes feel threatened by it.
According to Tesser, when someone close to us performs well, two opposite processes can occur. In reflection, we bask in their glory. Their success makes us feel good about ourselves, the way a parent glows when a child wins a prize. In comparison, their success shows up our own inadequacy, and we feel diminished. Which process wins depends largely on whether the domain is relevant to our self-definition. If my wife is a brilliant painter and I’m an engineer who doesn’t paint, I can bask in her success. If she’s a better engineer than I am, I may feel threatened.
Tesser’s model explains a pattern that turns up in many marriages. Partners tend to be most comfortable with each other’s success when they excel in different domains. It also explains why a partner’s lack of conventional achievement can be painful to a high achiever. If my identity is built on achievement, I may want a partner whose achievements reflect well on me. Her lack of them feels like a dent in my own reflected glory.
The way out isn’t necessarily to stop caring about achievement. It’s to notice that a partner is not a mirror. Shreya’s worth doesn’t lie in what she reflects onto Aditya. And Aditya’s worth doesn’t depend on what his wife’s résumé says about him.
The status trap
In Status Anxiety (2004), the philosopher Alain de Botton described the peculiarly modern form of this suffering. In societies that claim to be meritocratic, where anyone can supposedly become anything, people come to believe that their position reflects their worth. Failure is no longer bad luck. It’s a personal verdict. And so we become anxious about status in a way that may be more intense than in rigidly hierarchical societies.
Marriage gets pulled into this anxiety. A spouse becomes part of one’s portfolio of achievements: their job, their looks, their family, their degrees. In many communities, including many in India, this is reinforced by marriage markets that explicitly rank prospective partners by education, income, looks, caste, family background and career. It’s hardly surprising that people carry the logic of the marriage market into the marriage itself, and keep evaluating their partner long after the evaluation is supposed to be over.
But a spouse chosen as a status symbol is in an impossible position. Status is always relative. There will always be someone with a more impressive spouse. A marriage valued for what it signals to others will always feel precarious, because it depends on the opinions of people who aren’t in it.
A marriage valued for what it signals to outsiders will always feel insecure, because it rests on the opinions of people who aren't in it.
Russell on envy
The philosopher Bertrand Russell, in The Conquest of Happiness (1930), counted envy among the chief causes of human unhappiness. He observed that envy is especially corrosive because it takes pleasure in nothing: the envious person isn’t satisfied by what they have, only pained by what others have. Russell’s remedy, in summary, was a kind of redirection. Cultivate an absorbing interest in things outside yourself, and above all stop measuring your life by comparison, because there’s always someone further along on any scale you choose. Comparison, he suggested, is a game nobody can win, since the field of comparison is infinite.
The Stoics had arrived at a similar conclusion centuries earlier. Epictetus advised his students that if someone else has something you lack, they paid a price for it that you didn’t pay, whether in effort, compromise or attention. You can’t have the reward without the price. And the Stoics kept returning to a basic question: is this within my control? Another man’s wife isn’t. My own conduct, my own gratitude, my own way of seeing are.
Comparing the visible with the invisible
There’s one more trap in comparison, and it’s perhaps the most important. When Aditya compares Shreya with his colleague’s wife, he’s comparing the whole of Shreya, whom he knows intimately, flaws included, with the visible surface of a woman he met at a dinner. He sees the degree and the elegance. He doesn’t see her temper, her insecurities, the arguments in that house, the loneliness that may or may not exist in that marriage. He’s comparing a full portrait with a postcard.
Social media makes this worse. We compare our partner’s ordinary weekday with other couples’ curated anniversaries and holidays. Every comparison is rigged.
What Aditya discovered
Aditya brought his discomfort to a mentor, a senior partner at his firm whom he trusted. The mentor listened and then asked a question that stayed with him: “When you’re sick, who do you want beside you? When you fail, whose voice do you want to hear? When you’re old, who do you want to be talking to?”
Aditya realized that every honest answer was Shreya. The doctor at the wedding was an impression, a postcard. Shreya was a life.
The mentor added something else. “The people whose opinion you’re worried about,” he said, “will be at your wedding for three hours. You’ll be married for fifty years.”
That didn’t make Aditya’s ambitions, or his wish for a partner with her own pursuits, illegitimate. (Shared values and a partner with her own life matter a lot. See Chapters 9, 11 and 12.) But it let him separate two very different questions. Do I want a life with her? is a question about the marriage. Will she impress people? is a question about his ego. Only the first is worth building a life on.
What to take from this chapter
- Jealousy fears losing what you have. Envy wants what others have. Comparing partners is usually envy of reflected status.
- Desire is often mimetic: we want what others want. Ask whose desire you’re feeling.
- A partner’s success comforts us when it’s in a different domain and threatens us when it’s in ours. A partner is not a mirror.
- A marriage valued for its signal to outsiders rests on the opinions of people who aren’t in it.
- Every comparison sets a whole person against a postcard. The game can’t be won.