Rohit Shah

Chapter 6

The Glance: Attention, Desire and the Attractive Stranger

Why noticing beautiful people is normal, how attention decides what happens next, and what evolutionary psychology, Stoicism, the Gita and Buddhist practice offer the person who wants to stop feeling shaken every time someone attractive walks by.

Case history: Rajat, 34

Rajat has been married for six years, happily by his own account. But he’s troubled by something he calls “the ambush.” At the gym, at work, scrolling through his phone, he’ll see a strikingly attractive woman, and something seizes him. A rush of desire, then a sinking feeling, then a spiral of questions. Why don’t I feel that about my wife? Am I missing out? Did I settle? Sometimes the feeling lingers for hours. He replays the image. He feels guilty, then resentful, then guilty again.

“I’m not going to cheat,” he says. “I just want to be able to look at someone attractive and move on. Right now it feels like every pretty face is a referendum on my marriage.”

The glance is normal

Start with something that should be obvious but often isn’t: noticing attractive people is not a sign that anything is wrong with you or your relationship. It’s what human brains do.

The evolutionary psychologist David Buss, in The Evolution of Desire (first published in 1994), argued that human mating psychology was shaped over hundreds of thousands of years to detect cues associated with health, fertility and reproductive value. In his large cross-cultural survey of mate preferences across 37 cultures, physical attractiveness ranked highly for both sexes, and somewhat more highly, on average, for men. Our ancestors who paid attention to such cues left more descendants. We inherited their attention.

Buss’s work is controversial in places. Critics argue that evolutionary psychology sometimes overstates biological explanations, underweights culture and treats average differences between sexes as more fixed than they are. Read it critically, as the reading list this book grew from advises. But the core point is hard to dispute: the initial pull toward an attractive stranger is largely automatic. It happens before thought. You don’t choose it any more than you choose to feel startled by a loud noise.

There’s also what researchers sometimes call the Coolidge effect, renewed interest in response to a new partner, first described in animal studies and named after a (probably apocryphal) story about President Calvin Coolidge and his wife visiting a farm. Novelty itself excites mammalian brains. A stranger, simply by being a stranger, carries a charge that a familiar partner can’t. This isn’t a judgement on your partner. It’s a feature of the circuitry.

The first glance isn't a choice, and it isn't a verdict on your marriage. What matters is what you do in the second, third and fourth moments.

The second glance is where things happen

If the first glance is automatic, the second isn’t. Here is where psychology has something genuinely useful to say.

In 1997 the psychologist Rowland Miller published a study with a memorable finding. He showed people in dating relationships a series of slides, some of attractive people of the opposite sex, and secretly measured how long they spent looking at them. People who spent more time attending to attractive alternatives were more likely to have broken up with their partners two months later. Attention to alternatives wasn’t just a symptom of relationship trouble. It predicted it.

Other research points in the same direction from the other side. Studies by the psychologists Dennis Johnson and Caryl Rusbult in the late 1980s, and by Jeffry Simpson and colleagues around the same time, found that people in committed relationships tend to rate attractive alternatives as less attractive than single people do. This is sometimes called derogation of alternatives. Later work by Jon Maner and colleagues found that reminding people of their love for their partner reduced how much their attention stuck to attractive faces. Committed people, it seems, develop a kind of perceptual protection. They don’t stop seeing. They stop dwelling.

The lesson is that attention isn’t passive. What we dwell on grows. And dwelling is, at least partly, under our control.

The Gita’s chain

The Bhagavad Gita, composed probably between the fifth and second centuries BCE, contains one of the most precise descriptions of this process in any literature. In the second chapter, Krishna tells Arjuna (verses 62 and 63, rendered loosely here) that when a person dwells on the objects of the senses, attachment to them arises. From attachment comes craving. From craving, when it’s frustrated, comes anger. From anger comes delusion. From delusion, the loss of memory. From the loss of memory, the destruction of discernment. And when discernment is destroyed, the person is lost.

Notice where the chain begins. Not with seeing, but with dwelling, dhyāyataḥ, contemplating, turning something over in the mind. The Gita doesn’t ask anyone to stop seeing. It asks us to watch what happens next.

The Gita's chain from dwelling to ruinseeingdwellingattachmentcravingangerdelusionlost discernmentthe moment to notice
FigureBhagavad Gita 2.62–63, rendered as a chain. Seeing is not the problem. The chain begins with dwelling, turning something over and over in the mind, and that is where attention can be gently taken back.

And notice where it ends. For Rajat, the chain runs almost exactly as described. He sees. He dwells, replaying the image. Attachment forms. Craving follows. Then comes a kind of anger, not at the stranger but at his wife, for not being her, and at himself. Then delusion: the story that he has settled, that his marriage is a failure, that real happiness lies with someone like this stranger. Discernment, the ability to see his marriage as it actually is, is lost.

The Gita’s prescription isn’t suppression. It’s the cultivation of sthitaprajña, a steady wisdom that can let sense impressions come and go without being carried away by them. Krishna compares such a person to a tortoise drawing in its limbs. The tortoise isn’t destroyed by the world. It simply doesn’t throw itself into everything that passes.

The Gita doesn't ask us to stop seeing. It asks us to notice the moment where seeing becomes dwelling.

The Stoic test

The Stoic philosopher Epictetus (c. 50–135 CE), a former slave who became one of antiquity’s great teachers, built his whole philosophy on a distinction between impressions, which happen to us, and judgements, which we make about them. In the opening of his Enchiridion, the short handbook compiled by his student Arrian, he advises his students, in effect, to meet every vivid impression by saying: You’re an impression, and not at all the thing you appear to be. Then examine it. Ask whether it concerns things within your control or outside it.

Applied to Rajat: the impression is This person is striking, and I’m drawn to her. The judgement he adds is Therefore my marriage is lacking, and I’m missing out. The first is an impression. It came unbidden, and it can be acknowledged. The second is a judgement, and it’s both questionable and optional. A striking stranger tells you almost nothing about your marriage. She tells you that you have eyes.

Epictetus’s discipline is to pause between impression and judgement. That pause is where freedom lives.

Buddhist practice: noting and the second arrow

Buddhist psychology offers a practical tool for exactly this pause. In mindfulness practice, when a strong desire arises, the practitioner is taught to note it plainly, wanting, wanting, and to observe it as a passing event in the body and mind, without either acting on it or fighting it. Desire, observed this way, turns out to be less solid than it seems. It rises, peaks and fades, often within minutes, if it isn’t fed.

The Buddha’s teaching of the two arrows is also useful here. In a discourse known as the Sallatha Sutta, he describes a person struck by an arrow, who then strikes himself with a second arrow. The first arrow is the unavoidable pain or pull of experience. The second is the suffering we add through our reaction to it: the rumination, the self-blame, the stories. Rajat can’t avoid the first arrow, the glance. But the second arrow, the hours of replaying, comparing and guilt, is self-inflicted. That he can learn to put down.

Ulysses at the mast

Not every temptation can be met with calm observation alone. Sometimes the wise move is to arrange things so you don’t have to rely on willpower at all. In Homer’s Odyssey, Odysseus (Ulysses, in Latin) wants to hear the song of the Sirens, which lures sailors to their deaths. He has his crew plug their ears with wax and tie him to the mast, with orders not to release him however much he begs. He hears the song. He survives.

Psychologists call this precommitment, and it’s often more effective than willpower. For a married person, it might mean not following accounts designed to provoke desire, not lingering in one-on-one late-night conversations with someone you’re attracted to, not keeping open the channels where something could develop. These aren’t signs of weakness. They’re signs of self-knowledge.

Fantasy is not betrayal

One more point, because it often torments conscientious people. Esther Perel, among many therapists, argues that daydreaming is a normal and healthy part of the inner life, including fantasies about people other than one’s partner. Fantasy, in her view, is an expression of the imagination, a space of freedom, and doesn’t by itself threaten a relationship. Many people bring that imaginative energy back into their own relationship.

There’s a meaningful difference between a passing fantasy and an obsession, and between imagination and action. The fantasy that comes and goes is just the mind playing. The fantasy that you nurse, return to compulsively and use to devalue your partner is something else. It’s the chain the Gita describes. The question isn’t “Did I have an attractive thought?” It’s “What am I doing with it?”

What Rajat practised

Rajat’s therapist gave him a simple routine. When the “ambush” came, he was to do three things. First, name it: “That’s attraction. That’s my brain doing what brains do.” Second, refuse the second arrow: “This tells me nothing about my marriage.” Third, redirect: bring to mind something specific he valued about his wife, or simply return attention to what he’d been doing.

He also made some precommitments. He unfollowed accounts that existed mainly to provoke. He noticed that the ambushes hit hardest when he was tired, stressed or feeling undervalued, and started treating them as a signal to look after himself rather than as a verdict on his marriage.

A few months later he described a change. “I still notice beautiful women. I probably always will. But it doesn’t grab me the same way. It’s like weather. It comes, it goes. My marriage isn’t up for a vote every time.”

What to take from this chapter

  • The first glance at an attractive stranger is automatic and normal. It says nothing about your relationship.
  • Attention to alternatives predicts relationship breakdown. What you dwell on grows.
  • The Gita traces the chain from dwelling to attachment to craving to anger to delusion. The intervention point is the dwelling.
  • Separate the impression (“she’s beautiful”) from the judgement (“my marriage is lacking”). Only the first is automatic.
  • Precommitment, structuring your life to reduce temptation, often works better than willpower.
  • Passing fantasy is normal. What matters is whether it’s cultivated into dissatisfaction.

Curated by Claude from my favourite reads. About this material