Rohit Shah

Chapter 11

Cold Feet or a Real Warning?

Not every doubt is a defence and not every doubt is a signal. What research on premarital doubts actually shows, and a set of questions for telling the difference before the wedding rather than after.

Most of this book has argued that many of the anxieties people feel before marriage are less about their partner than they seem: the fear of closed doors, the confusion of anxiety with chemistry, the habit of comparison, the fading of limerence. That’s true, and important. But it would be dishonest to stop there, because sometimes the doubts are right.

What the research shows

In 2012 the psychologists Justin Lavner, Benjamin Karney and Thomas Bradbury published a study that should be read by anyone approaching a wedding. They surveyed several hundred newlywed couples in Los Angeles shortly after their weddings, asking each spouse whether they’d ever been uncertain or hesitant about getting married. Then they followed the couples for four years.

The findings were sobering. Doubts were common: a substantial share of both husbands and wives reported them. And doubts mattered. Spouses who had reported premarital doubts were more likely to be divorced four years later, and those who stayed married were, on average, less satisfied. The effect was especially strong for wives’ doubts, but husbands’ doubts predicted trouble too. When both partners had doubts, the divorce rate was highest of all.

The authors’ conclusion was careful. Doubts shouldn’t be automatically dismissed as “just nerves.” They may carry real information. That doesn’t mean every doubter should call off their wedding. Many couples with doubts were happily married four years later. It means that doubts are worth examining, not suppressing.

Sorting doubtsOften travels with youDeserves real weightabout signals: career, looks, statusthe same doubt with every partnergrows as the wedding nearsfades when you feel secureabout values and charactercontempt, in either directionyou want different livesgrows after troubling events
FigureA rough sort of the chapter’s ten questions. Doubts on the left often say more about the person doubting; doubts on the right are about the relationship itself. Either way, research suggests doubts are worth examining, not waving away.

Premarital doubts aren't always "just nerves." In research, they predicted later trouble. They deserve to be looked at, not waved away.

So we’re left with a real dilemma. On the one hand, much doubt is a predictable product of attachment patterns, maximizing, comparison and fear of finality, and says little about the partner. On the other hand, some doubt is accurate perception. How do we tell them apart?

There’s no formula. But the research and clinical literature suggest a set of distinctions.

Ten questions for your doubt

1. Is the doubt about who she is or about what she signals? Doubts about values, character, kindness, honesty, how she treats you and others: these are about the person. Doubts about her career, her looks, her family’s status, how she’ll appear to colleagues: these are about signals. The first kind deserves great weight. The second, as Chapter 7 argued, usually says more about your ego than about the marriage.

2. Is there contempt, in either direction? Gottman’s research makes this the single most important question. Do you find yourself feeling disdain for her? Does she for you? Do you mock, roll your eyes, feel superior? Contempt is a serious warning sign. Its absence, even amid other doubts, is a very good sign.

3. Do you respect her, and does she respect you? Respect in Fromm’s sense: seeing her clearly as she is, and wanting her to grow in her own way. If you don’t respect your partner, or find yourself wishing she were fundamentally a different person, that’s significant.

4. Have you had the same doubt about every partner? If every relationship has been haunted by “not quite enough,” with the flaw shifting each time (her looks, then her ambition, then her family, then her humour), the problem probably travels with you. That’s Chapter 2’s deactivation and Chapter 1’s maximizing. If this doubt is new, specific and about something real in this relationship, it deserves more attention.

5. Does the doubt grow when things are good? Doubts that intensify precisely when the relationship deepens, at the engagement, the meeting of families, the setting of a date, often have an attachment component. Doubts that intensify after specific troubling events (she lied, she was cruel, she dismissed something important) are more likely to be accurate perceptions.

6. Do you want the same life? This is among the most underestimated questions, and it’s practical rather than romantic. Do you agree, broadly, about children and when to have them? About where to live? About work, money, religion, how much social life, how to treat each other’s families? About whether each partner should have their own pursuits? Gottman’s research suggests many differences can be lived with. But some differences of life direction are hard to bridge, and it’s far better to discover them before the wedding than after. These are questions to ask her, not to guess at.

7. Can you talk about hard things? Bring up a difficult subject, your fears, your doubts about the future, what you want from marriage, and watch what happens. Can you both stay in the conversation? Can you disagree without contempt? Can you repair after a rupture? The capacity for honest, repairable conflict is one of the best predictors of a good marriage.

8. Is there desire, even quiet desire? Chapter 5 showed that desire in long relationships is often responsive rather than spontaneous, and that the absence of “spark” can reflect brakes, stress or a history of anxious relationships. But it’s worth asking honestly: when the conditions are right, when you’re rested, close, unhurried, do you feel drawn to her? Is there warmth, wanting, curiosity about her body and her? Quiet desire can be cultivated. A real aversion, or a complete absence of any physical wanting even in the best conditions, is harder to build on.

9. If no one else could see your marriage, would you still want it? Imagine a marriage nobody would ever know about: no wedding, no colleagues, no relatives, no social media, nobody judging. Would you still choose this person? If yes, many of your doubts are likely about status. If you hesitate, ask what you’d be missing.

10. Is the doubt fair to her? This question is often forgotten. Marriage isn’t just something you choose. It’s something you offer. Your partner deserves a spouse who chooses her wholeheartedly, not one who keeps her as a provisional arrangement while scanning the horizon. If you can’t give that, she deserves to know, and to be free to find someone who can. If you can, she deserves to hear it.

Your partner deserves to be chosen wholeheartedly, not kept as a provisional arrangement. That's part of the decision too.

What to do with what you find

If your doubts are mostly about signals, comparisons and finality: The chapters in this book offer practices for working with them. Talk to someone you trust, or a counsellor, about the patterns. Notice how the doubts behave. Consider that this may be the ordinary anxiety of a major commitment, made worse by a mind that has been trained to keep options open.

If your doubts are about values, life direction or respect: Talk to her, directly and soon. These are conversations that need to happen before marriage. Say what you want, not what you fear in her. (“I want a partner who has her own work and interests,” rather than “I’m afraid you’ll be dull.”) Ask her what she wants. Listen carefully. You may discover that your fears were assumptions. Or you may discover a real gap. Either is better than marrying on guesses.

If you find contempt, aversion or fundamentally different visions of life: Take that seriously. The cost of calling off an engagement is real: social embarrassment, family disappointment, pain for both of you. The cost of a marriage built on contempt or incompatibility is usually much greater, and borne for much longer, by both of you and possibly by children.

If you remain genuinely unsure: Consider premarital counselling, which many couples find useful even without serious concerns. Consider whether the timeline can allow more time. A wedding date is a powerful pressure, but a date can move. A marriage is much harder to undo.

A note on the families

In many Indian contexts, by the time doubts surface, families have met, ceremonies have been held, and social commitments have been made. This makes doubts feel unspeakable. But the families’ investment, however real, is not a reason to marry. A difficult conversation now is far kinder to everyone, including both families, than an unhappy marriage later. And many doubts, once spoken aloud to a trusted person, turn out to be smaller than they felt in silence. Others turn out to be bigger. Either way, silence helps nobody.

What to take from this chapter

  • Premarital doubts predicted higher divorce rates and lower satisfaction in research. Examine them, don’t suppress them.
  • Distinguish doubts about who she is (values, character, respect) from doubts about what she signals (status, appearance, how others see her).
  • Contempt and absence of respect are the most serious warning signs. Their absence is a strong positive.
  • Ask her about life direction (children, work, money, freedom) instead of guessing.
  • Ask whether you’d choose her if no one else could see, and whether your doubt is fair to her.

Curated by Claude from my favourite reads. About this material