Rohit Shah

Chapter 12

Freedom and Responsibility: The Shape of a Shared Life

The fear that marriage will mean a dull routine, children too soon and a weight of responsibility instead of a friendship with room to breathe. What research on children, housework and partnership shows, and how to design the life rather than drift into it.

Case history: Manish, 34, and Kavya, 32

Manish loves Kavya’s company. They can talk for hours about books, films and politics. They travel well together. But as their wedding approaches, a new anxiety creeps in. Kavya has just left a draining corporate job to take time out and work out what comes next, and Manish has begun to picture a future he dreads. She’ll stop working. The families will press for a baby within a year. He’ll become the sole earner, the man responsible for everything, coming home tired to a house organized around duties. “I want a friend I’m married to,” he says. “I’m afraid I’m going to get a household I’m responsible for.”

What Manish hasn’t done, it turns out, is ask Kavya what she wants.

The fear is reasonable, and it’s a forecast

Manish’s fear deserves respect. The shift from courtship to household is real. Daniel Gilbert’s research on affective forecasting, the way we predict our future emotions, shows that people are generally poor at it. We overestimate how long bad feelings will last and underestimate how much we’ll adapt. But Gilbert also notes that we’re better at predicting what situations we’ll be in than how we’ll feel in them. Manish isn’t wrong that marriage often brings more responsibility. He may be wrong about how it will feel, and quite possibly about which responsibilities.

Notice too that Manish’s fear is built entirely on assumptions: that Kavya will stop working permanently, that she wants a baby soon, that the families will set the timetable, that he’ll carry everything. Any of these may be true. None has been checked. A forecast built on unchecked assumptions is a story, not information.

What children do to a marriage

The question of when to have children is among the most consequential a couple faces, and it’s worth knowing what the research shows.

In the late 1990s and 2000s, John Gottman and his colleague Alyson Shapiro followed newlywed couples through the transition to parenthood. They found that roughly two-thirds of couples experienced a significant decline in relationship satisfaction in the three years after their first child was born. Sleep deprivation, new financial pressure, changed roles, reduced time together and conflicts over the division of labour all contributed. A substantial minority of couples, though, did not decline. They kept or even increased their satisfaction. What distinguished them? In Gottman’s research, largely the strength of their friendship before the baby arrived: fondness and admiration, awareness of each other’s worlds, and the habit of turning toward each other. Gottman and Shapiro later developed a workshop, “Bringing Baby Home,” designed to build those strengths, and reported that couples who took it fared noticeably better.

The implication for timing isn’t a rule (“wait five years”) but a principle. A child arriving into a strong friendship tends to strengthen it. A child arriving into an untested or strained relationship tends to strain it further. Many couples find it valuable to have some time, often a couple of years, to build their friendship, rituals and habits of conflict repair as a couple before becoming parents. But this is something to agree on together, not a decision one partner should assume or impose.

Children tend to amplify whatever is already there. A strong friendship before the baby is the best predictor of a strong marriage after.

The second shift

In The Second Shift (1989), the sociologist Arlie Hochschild described what happened in American households as women entered the paid workforce in large numbers. Many women, she found, worked a full day at their jobs and then a “second shift” of housework and childcare at home, while their husbands contributed far less. The resentment this created was, in her account, one of the hidden stresses of modern marriage.

Decades later, time-use surveys in many countries, including India, still show women doing a large majority of unpaid household work, often even when they’re also employed. And as Nagoski’s work in Chapter 5 showed, an unfair load is one of the most reliable brakes on desire.

Why does this matter for Manish’s fear? Because the opposite fear, that he’ll carry an unfair financial load, is also real. The underlying question is the same in both directions: how will we divide the work of our shared life so that neither of us feels used? That includes paid work, housework, emotional labour, care of elders and children, and the management of the household. There’s no single correct division. Some couples both work full-time and split the household. Some choose one primary earner and one primary homemaker. Some change arrangements over the years. What matters, the research on fairness suggests, is that both partners perceive the arrangement as fair and freely chosen.

Dividing the work of a shared lifePartner APartner Bpaid work · housework · care · emotional labour · running the homewhat matters: both see the split as fair and freely chosen
FigureNo single division of labour is right. What the research on fairness points to is perception: whether both partners see the arrangement as fair and freely chosen, and keep revisiting it as life changes.

“Homemaker” isn’t a personality

There’s a quiet prejudice in the fear that a partner who doesn’t work outside the home will make life dull. It treats a role as if it were a character. Some people who work in high-powered jobs are deeply dull. Some people who manage households are endlessly curious, well-read, funny and alive. What makes a partner interesting isn’t a job title. It’s curiosity, engagement with the world and a life of their own, the qualities Perel says make desire possible.

That said, the wish for a partner with her own pursuits is entirely legitimate, and important for the reasons this book has given. A partner whose entire world is the marriage tends to become dependent and restless, and to make the other partner feel responsible for her happiness. The healthiest arrangement, whatever the division of paid work, is one in which both partners have something of their own: work, study, art, community, friendships, a cause. Finkel’s research suggests the same thing from a different angle. Marriages do better when they’re not asked to carry every need.

So the right question isn’t “Will she be a housewife?” It’s “Will each of us have a life of our own inside our life together, and will we support each other’s?”

Freedom inside commitment

Manish’s deepest fear is the loss of what he calls “friendly freedom”: the lightness of two people who are together because they want to be, not because they must be. That fear goes to the heart of the book’s first chapter. Does commitment destroy freedom?

The philosophers suggest a more complicated answer. The Gita’s idea of svadharma, one’s own path or duty, holds that each person has their own way to walk. Marriage, in that light, doesn’t erase each partner’s path. It asks two people to walk their paths side by side, sometimes supporting each other, sometimes giving each other room. Gibran, in the passage on marriage in The Prophet, asks couples to sing and dance together and be joyous, but to let each one be alone.

The freedom you lose in marriage is the freedom of no obligations. The freedom you can keep, and even deepen, is the freedom of a friendship in which both people choose, every day, to stay. That second kind doesn’t happen by accident. It’s designed. Couples who keep it tend to do certain things: they protect time that’s just for them as a couple, they keep separate friendships and interests, they don’t let family or social pressure set their timetable, and they revisit their arrangements as life changes.

Designing rather than drifting

The danger Manish faces isn’t that marriage will inevitably become a heavy, dull household. It’s that he and Kavya will drift into whatever arrangement their families, their culture and their exhaustion produce, without ever deciding what they want. Drift is how many marriages become things neither partner chose.

The alternative is to design. Before marriage, and repeatedly afterwards, couples can talk through questions like these:

  • Work: What does each of us want to do in the next five years? How will we support each other’s ambitions? What if one plan fails?
  • Children: Do we both want children? When, roughly? What would make us feel ready? How will we handle family pressure on timing?
  • Money: How will we share income and expenses? What happens if one of us isn’t earning for a while?
  • The household: Who will do what? How will we revisit it if it starts to feel unfair?
  • Freedom: What does each of us need to feel free: time alone, friendships, travel, hobbies? How will we protect those?
  • Families: How involved will our families be in decisions? Where are the boundaries?
  • Change: What if one of us wants to change careers, move cities or live differently? How will we decide together?

These aren’t romantic questions. But couples who ask them tend to stay romantic longer, because they spend less of their marriage resenting arrangements they never chose.

Many marriages become things neither partner chose, not through bad decisions, but through no decisions at all.

What Manish heard

When Manish finally asked Kavya what she pictured, he was surprised. She had no intention of staying out of work permanently. The break was a pause, not a retirement; she had already been sounding out two firms about freelance work. She didn’t want a baby for at least two or three years. She’d been dreading the family pressure as much as he had. And she’d been afraid, she admitted, that he would become a distant, career-obsessed husband who saw her as a household manager.

“We’d both been afraid of the same marriage,” Manish said. “Neither of us wanted it. We just hadn’t said so.”

They wrote down what they wanted, half as a joke, on a napkin at a café. Years later, it’s still pinned to their fridge.

What to take from this chapter

  • Fears about married life are forecasts built on assumptions. Check the assumptions by asking.
  • About two-thirds of couples see satisfaction fall after a first child. A strong friendship beforehand is the best protection. Decide timing together.
  • Unfair division of work, paid or unpaid, breeds resentment and kills desire. Aim for an arrangement both see as fair and freely chosen.
  • A role isn’t a personality. What matters is that both partners have lives of their own inside the shared one.
  • Design your shared life deliberately, and keep redesigning it. Drift is how marriages become what nobody wanted.

Curated by Claude from my favourite reads. About this material