Rohit Shah

Chapter VII

The temple before the city

Göbekli Tepe, the hunters who moved mountains, and the unsettling possibility that belief came before bread.

The hill is called Göbekli Tepe, which in Turkish means something like "potbelly hill." It rises about fifteen metres above the limestone plateau northeast of the city of Şanlıurfa, in the far southeast of Turkey, not far from the Syrian border. In 1963, a joint survey by the University of Istanbul and the University of Chicago noted the mound and the broken slabs of limestone on its surface, and concluded that it was probably a medieval cemetery. For thirty years no one looked again.

In 1994, the German archaeologist Klaus Schmidt, re-reading the old survey reports, visited the hill. He recognized that the flint lying everywhere on its surface was Stone Age, and that the broken slabs were not gravestones but the tops of great pillars. He is said to have realized within minutes that he could either walk away and tell no one, or spend the rest of his life there. He spent the rest of his life there. When he died in 2014, his excavations had uncovered one of the most important archaeological sites ever found, and had forced a fundamental rethinking of how civilization began.

What was found

Beneath the mound, Schmidt and his team found a series of great round or oval enclosures, each ringed by a stone wall and by massive limestone pillars, shaped like a capital T. In the centre of each enclosure stand two especially large pillars, facing each other. The tallest are more than five metres high and weigh perhaps ten tons or more. They were quarried from the surrounding bedrock with stone tools, moved, raised, and set into sockets cut in the floor. The oldest enclosures date to about 9600 BCE, near the very end of the last Ice Age, some eleven and a half thousand years ago. That is roughly six thousand years before Stonehenge and seven thousand years before the Great Pyramid.

Enclosure D at Göbekli Tepe, a ring of T-shaped limestone pillars with two tall pillars at the centre
PlateEnclosure D at Göbekli Tepe, the best preserved of the excavated enclosures: an oval about twenty metres across, ringed by T-shaped pillars, with two tall pillars at its centre. Photo: Dosseman / Wikimedia Commons

The pillars are not blank. The two central pillars in Enclosure D, the best preserved, have arms carved in low relief running down their sides, with long-fingered hands meeting over the belly. Below the hands are belts, and hanging from the belts are loincloths made of fox pelts. The T-shaped tops are heads, seen from the side. These pillars, in other words, are not just pillars. They are colossal, abstracted beings, standing in the middle of a stone circle, surrounded by a ring of lesser beings.

Plan of a Göbekli Tepe enclosure and elevation of a T-shaped pillarPlan of an enclosure5 m and moreA central T-pillar
FigureGöbekli Tepe, about 9600 BCE: oval enclosures ringed by T-shaped limestone pillars, with two larger pillars facing each other at the centre. The central pillars carry carved arms, hands meeting over a belt, and loincloths, as if the stone were a body.

And they are surrounded by animals. Carved on the pillars are foxes, boars, snakes, wild cattle, wild asses, cranes, vultures, scorpions, spiders, and lions or leopards, most of them dangerous, many shown snarling or in attack, some carved in high relief so that they seem to be climbing down the stone. On one pillar, known as Pillar 43 or the Vulture Stone, a great vulture spreads its wings above a scorpion, with a circular object near its wing, and a headless human figure lower down. Snakes pour down the sides of pillars in cascades. The imagery is not gentle. It is a world of predators, poison, and death.

A Göbekli Tepe pillar with a carved arm running down its side and a fox in relief
PlateThe inner face of one of the central pillars of Enclosure D: a carved arm running down the stone, and a fox leaping beneath it. Photo: Guérin Nicolas / Wikimedia Commons
These pillars are not just pillars. They are colossal beings standing in a circle, surrounded by a ring of lesser beings.

Hunters, not farmers

What made Göbekli Tepe a sensation was not only its age and scale. It was who built it. When the earliest enclosures were raised, there was no agriculture in the region, or anywhere else in the world. There were no domesticated animals other than the dog. There was no pottery, no metal, no writing, and no wheel. The animal bones found at the site belonged overwhelmingly to wild species, especially gazelle, wild boar, aurochs, and wild ass. The people who built Göbekli Tepe were, by every conventional definition, hunter-gatherers.

According to the textbook narrative that prevailed for most of the twentieth century, this should have been impossible. The standard story, most influentially articulated by the Australian archaeologist V. Gordon Childe, whose phrase "Neolithic Revolution" dates from the 1930s, held that agriculture came first. Farming produced food surpluses; surpluses allowed people to settle permanently and to support specialists such as priests and craftsmen; and settled, stratified societies then built monuments and temples. Religion, in this view, was part of the superstructure that grew on the economic base.

Göbekli Tepe turned this sequence on its head. Here were monumental architecture and complex religious imagery, built by people who had not yet begun to farm. Schmidt summarized his interpretation in a memorable phrase: first came the temple, then the city.

A cathedral of the hunt?

Schmidt saw Göbekli Tepe as a sanctuary, a place of pilgrimage and ritual for hunter-gatherer groups scattered across the region, built at a sacred spot on a hilltop visible for miles. The T-shaped pillars, he suggested, represented supernatural beings, perhaps ancestors, perhaps the first gods. The animals were their companions or guardians, or perhaps totems of the groups who came together there. He believed that the people who built the enclosures did not live there, and that after a time each enclosure was deliberately buried.

He also saw a direct connection with agriculture. Building and using Göbekli Tepe would have required hundreds of people working together for extended periods, and all of those people needed to be fed. That demand, Schmidt suggested, created pressure to intensify the collection and eventually the cultivation of wild cereals. It is striking that the Karacadağ mountains, less than a hundred kilometres away, are the place where genetic studies have located the wild ancestors of domesticated einkorn wheat. The temple, on this view, did not just precede agriculture; it may have helped cause it. The human impulse to gather for ritual, to feast, and to build sacred places may have driven the most important economic revolution in human history.

This idea had a precedent. In 1994, the French archaeologist Jacques Cauvin published a book whose English title is The Birth of the Gods and the Origins of Agriculture. Cauvin argued, from evidence at sites in the Levant, that a "revolution of symbols" preceded the economic revolution of farming. In the art of the late hunter-gatherers and early farmers, he saw two symbols becoming dominant: a woman and a bull. He argued that a new religious psychology, in which human beings began to see themselves as separate from and in a sense above the natural world, looking up to divine powers, preceded and made possible the domestication of plants and animals. The mind changed first, Cauvin argued. Then the economy followed.

First came the temple, then the city. And perhaps the temple helped to cause the farm.

A more complicated picture

In the decade since Schmidt's death, excavations led by the German Archaeological Institute, under Lee Clare and others, have revised aspects of his picture. Researchers now think that people did live at Göbekli Tepe, at least for part of the year. They have found structures that look like houses, cisterns to collect rainwater, and huge quantities of grinding stones, more than any other site of the period in the region, used to process wild cereals. Some researchers have suggested that the site's enclosures may not have been deliberately buried, but partially filled by slope slides and debris. Göbekli Tepe begins to look less like a pure sanctuary in the wilderness and more like a settlement, or a series of settlements, in which extraordinary ritual buildings were embedded in daily life.

This refinement does not diminish the site's significance. It sharpens it. If people were living in communities large enough to build Göbekli Tepe, without agriculture, then the transition to settled life happened before, not after, farming, and it happened in a world already saturated with monumental ritual. The distinction between "temple" and "village" may itself be a modern one. For the people of Göbekli Tepe, sacred architecture was part of how they lived together.

Some of the most dramatic evidence of what that ritual involved has come from the bones. In 2017, a team led by Julia Gresky reported fragments of three human skulls from the site bearing deep, deliberate grooves carved along their length, and in one case a drilled hole, apparently to allow the skull to be suspended. The skulls had been defleshed. Some researchers have connected this to the skull cult known from other sites of the period, which we will explore in the next chapter. Among the carvings at Göbekli Tepe are figures holding human heads, and a carved statue of a human head with the face missing. The dead, or at least parts of them, were present in the enclosures.

The Stone Hills

Göbekli Tepe is not alone. Since 2019, a coordinated project known as Taş Tepeler, "the Stone Hills," has investigated a dozen sites in the Şanlıurfa region with similar architecture and imagery from roughly the same period. Nevalı Çori, excavated earlier by Harald Hauptmann and now flooded by the waters of the Atatürk Dam, had a cult building with T-shaped pillars and carvings of human and bird figures.

At Karahan Tepe, about forty kilometres from Göbekli, excavations led by Necmi Karul have uncovered a chamber cut into the bedrock that contains eleven pillars, also carved from the living rock, rising from the floor. Several of them are phallic in form. From one wall of the chamber emerges a carved human head, with a long neck, facing the pillars. A narrow channel connects this chamber to another. The effect, for anyone who stands in the room, is uncanny: a stone face watching a gathering of stone figures, in a space that seems designed for initiation or ceremony, perhaps involving liquid flowing through channels.

In Şanlıurfa itself, beneath the modern city, workers in 1993 found a limestone statue of a man, about 1.9 metres tall, with obsidian eyes and hands clasped over his groin. Known as the Urfa Man, it is often described as the oldest life-sized sculpture of a human being ever found, dating to the same period as Göbekli Tepe.

Together, the Taş Tepeler sites reveal not a single mysterious temple but a regional culture, with shared symbols, architecture, and practices, spread across a landscape, involving thousands of people over more than a millennium. The dominant imagery is male: phalluses, men, predators. Female images are rare, one of the few being a woman engraved on a slab, in an explicit birthing or display posture. This contrasts sharply with the female figurines of the Palaeolithic and with the prominence of female imagery in some later Neolithic sites, and it raises questions, as yet unanswered, about gender and power in these communities.

The Natufian prelude

Göbekli Tepe did not appear from nowhere. In the southern Levant, from about fifteen thousand to eleven and a half thousand years ago, lived the Natufians, a culture of hunter-gatherers who were beginning to settle down in permanent or semi-permanent villages, harvesting wild cereals with sickles of flint set in bone handles. The Natufians buried their dead within their settlements, sometimes under the floors of their houses, sometimes with ornaments of shell and bone. At Ain Mallaha, in northern Israel, an elderly person was buried about twelve thousand years ago with a hand resting on a puppy, one of the earliest known expressions of the bond between humans and dogs.

We have already met the Natufian "shaman" of Hilazon Tachtit, buried with fifty tortoises and parts of many animals. In the same cave, archaeologists found evidence of feasting: the remains of at least seventy-one tortoises and three wild cattle, apparently eaten at funerary gatherings. Evidence of beer-brewing at Raqefet Cave, another Natufian burial site, suggests that feasting with intoxicating drink was connected to the treatment of the dead. The Natufians were already doing, on a smaller scale, the things that would culminate at Göbekli Tepe: settling, gathering, feasting, and ritually honouring the dead.

The feast

The archaeologist Brian Hayden has argued that feasting was one of the central engines of social change in prehistory. Feasts are powerful. They create debts and obligations; they display the wealth and generosity of the hosts; they attract followers and allies; and they generate the intense emotional experiences, the collective effervescence, that bind people together. Ambitious individuals in hunter-gatherer societies could use feasts to accumulate prestige and influence. The need to supply ever-larger feasts, Hayden suggests, may have encouraged the intensification of food production, the storage of surpluses, and eventually the domestication of plants and animals.

At Göbekli Tepe, the hunting of large numbers of gazelle, apparently during the seasonal migrations of herds, and the grinding of vast quantities of wild cereals point toward feasting on a large scale. In 2012, the German archaeologist Oliver Dietrich and colleagues suggested that some of the large stone vessels at the site may have been used to brew a kind of beer. Whether or not this is confirmed, it is clear that the site was a place where people ate together in large numbers. Feasting, labour, and ritual were fused.

Feasting, labour, and ritual were fused. The sacred was built by many hands, and those hands had to be fed.

Two modes of religion

The British anthropologist Harvey Whitehouse has proposed a theory that helps explain the kind of religion Göbekli Tepe may represent. Whitehouse distinguishes between two "modes of religiosity." The imagistic mode involves rare, intensely emotional, often terrifying rituals, such as painful initiations, which are remembered vividly by the individuals who experience them and create powerful bonds among small groups of participants. The doctrinal mode involves frequent, routine, low-arousal rituals, such as weekly services and daily prayers, combined with standardized teachings transmitted by specialists, which allow religions to spread across large populations.

Göbekli Tepe, with its snarling predators, its dark enclosures, its skulls, and its massive communal building projects, looks like a monument of the imagistic mode on an unprecedented scale. Whitehouse has worked with the Göbekli Tepe researchers and has suggested that the site may represent a moment of transition, when the intense, bonding rituals of hunter-gatherer religion were being expanded to bind together larger groups than ever before. The doctrinal mode, with its routines and priesthoods, would come later, with the first states.

From partner to power

There is one more change visible at Göbekli Tepe, and it may be the most important of all for the emergence of gods. Recall the animist world of Chapter IV: a world in which animals were persons, partners, relatives, and gift-givers, with whom human beings had to maintain relationships of respect and reciprocity. The animals of Göbekli Tepe are something else. They are predators and poisoners, shown in postures of threat, crawling over giant humanoid figures. They surround beings who stand in the centre, large, abstract, human-shaped, and dominant.

Some interpreters, following Cauvin, have seen in this imagery a new vision of the cosmos, in which human-like beings stand above the animal world and command it. The anthropologist Ian Hodder, whom we will meet at Çatalhöyük, has spoken of the Neolithic as a process of "domestication" in the broadest sense: not only of plants and animals, but of the wild, of death, and of human beings themselves, who became bound to places, houses, possessions, and one another in ever-tighter webs of dependence. The central pillars of Göbekli Tepe, standing in their circles like chiefs in a council of animals, may be among the first images of that new order. They are not yet gods in the full sense. We do not know their names or what was asked of them. But they stand at the point where the spirits of the animate world began to condense into something larger, more human-shaped, and more commanding.

Göbekli Tepe tells us that the human impulse to gather, to build sacred spaces, and to represent powers greater than ourselves did not wait for agriculture. It may even have driven it. It tells us that hunter-gatherers were capable of monumental achievement, and that the boundary between the "primitive" and the "civilized" is far blurrier than the textbooks once supposed. And it hints that the gods, when they came, would come not only from the sky or the heart, but from the gathered crowd, the shared feast, and the enormous shared effort of raising stones.

Curated by Claude from my favourite reads. About this material