Chapter VI
Venus and the Mother
Small carved women, a century of projection, and a triangular stone in the Son valley that is still being worshipped.
In September 2008, the German archaeologist Nicholas Conard and his team were excavating the cave of Hohle Fels in the Swabian Jura, the same region that produced the lion-man. Near the bottom of the Aurignacian layers, some three metres below the surface, they found six fragments of carved mammoth ivory. When the pieces were fitted together, they made a figure about six centimetres tall: a woman with enormous breasts, a deeply incised vulva, broad hips, short arms with carefully carved fingers resting on her belly, and no head. Where the head should have been, the carver had made a small ring, polished by wear, as if the figure had been hung on a cord and worn. Dated to at least thirty-five thousand years ago and possibly closer to forty, the Venus of Hohle Fels is the oldest undisputed representation of a human being in the world.
It is a tiny object with an enormous burden. Ever since the first such figurines were found in the nineteenth century, they have been asked to answer some of the biggest questions about the primordial mind: whether the first deity was a goddess, whether early societies honoured women or merely looked at them, and what human beings of the Ice Age thought about sex, birth, abundance, and the body. This chapter is about the figurines themselves, and about the long history of what we have wanted them to say.
A name that was a joke
Start with the word. In 1864, the Marquis de Vibraye found a small ivory female figure at Laugerie-Basse in the Dordogne. It was slender, with no breasts to speak of and a clearly marked vulva. He named it the Vénus impudique, the "immodest Venus," as an ironic contrast with the classical Greek sculptural type of the Venus pudica, the modest Venus who covers herself with her hands. The joke stuck. By the twentieth century, nearly every Palaeolithic female figurine was a "Venus," a word that silently imported an entire set of assumptions: that these objects were about beauty, erotic appeal, and fertility, and that they belonged to a single category with a single meaning.
Many archaeologists now avoid the term or use it in quotation marks. It is a useful reminder that the lenses through which we look at the past are often ground in our own time. Nineteenth-century European men looked at ancient carved women and saw what nineteenth-century European men were accustomed to seeing.
Nineteenth-century men looked at ancient carved women and saw what nineteenth-century men were accustomed to seeing.
The Gravettian sisterhood
The largest group of figurines comes from a cultural period archaeologists call the Gravettian, roughly thirty-three thousand to twenty-one thousand years ago, and from a territory stretching astonishingly far: from the Pyrenees in the west, across France, Italy, Austria, the Czech lands, and Ukraine, to the Russian plain, and beyond to Siberia.
The Venus of Willendorf, found in 1908 near the Danube in Austria, is the most famous. About eleven centimetres tall, carved from oolitic limestone and originally coloured with red ochre, she is roughly thirty thousand years old. Her body is voluminous, her breasts and belly large, her vulva carefully rendered, her arms thin and resting on her breasts. Her head is covered entirely by what look like rows of braided hair or a woven cap, and she has no face. A 2022 study of the stone's microstructure suggested that the limestone may have come from a source hundreds of kilometres away, possibly in northern Italy, which would mean that either the figure or its raw material travelled across the Alps.
The Venus of Dolní Věstonice, from the same Moravian site as the triple burial described in Chapter II, is made of fired clay and dates to around thirty thousand years ago. She is one of the oldest ceramic objects in the world, made nearly twenty thousand years before pottery vessels. Thousands of fired clay fragments were found at the site, many of them broken animal and human figurines. In 1989, the archaeologist Pamela Vandiver and colleagues suggested that many had been deliberately placed in the fire while still wet so that they would explode, perhaps as a form of divination or ritual performance, in which the breaking, not the finished object, was what mattered.
From Lespugue in France comes an ivory figure whose breasts, belly, and buttocks are arranged in an almost abstract, symmetrical composition. From Brassempouy comes a small ivory head of a woman with a hood or elaborate hair, about twenty-five thousand years old, one of the earliest known representations of a human face. From Laussel in the Dordogne comes a limestone relief of a woman holding in her raised right hand what appears to be a bison horn, marked with thirteen notches, while her left hand rests on her belly; interpreters have seen in the thirteen notches the number of lunar months in a year, or of menstrual cycles, though this, like so much else, remains speculative. From Kostenki and Avdeevo on the Russian plain come dozens of figures carved from ivory and stone, and from Mal'ta near Lake Baikal in Siberia come figurines that appear to be dressed in fur garments.
What is remarkable is how similar many of these objects are, across thousands of kilometres and thousands of years. Leroi-Gourhan noticed that many share a common composition: narrow at the top and bottom, with the breasts, belly, and hips forming a central, swelling mass, like a lozenge. Heads are often faceless and bowed; feet are often absent or reduced to points, as though the figures were meant to be pressed into the ground or held in the hand. This consistency suggests a shared tradition, a set of ideas about what a female figure should look like, maintained across one of the largest cultural spaces of the Ice Age world.
The Great Goddess
What did they mean? The most famous answer, and the most influential in popular culture, is that they represent a Great Goddess or Mother Goddess, a divine female principle of fertility, birth, and regeneration, worshipped across prehistoric Europe and perhaps the world.
The idea has deep roots. In 1861, the Swiss jurist Johann Jakob Bachofen published Das Mutterrecht, "Mother Right," arguing that human societies had originally been matriarchal, governed by women and devoted to female deities, before being overthrown by patriarchy. In the twentieth century, the psychologist Carl Jung and his follower Erich Neumann developed the idea of the Great Mother as an archetype of the collective unconscious. And from the 1950s onward, the Lithuanian-American archaeologist Marija Gimbutas, drawing on the thousands of figurines found in Neolithic southeastern Europe, argued that "Old Europe" had been a peaceful, egalitarian, goddess-worshipping civilization, overrun from about 4500 BCE by patriarchal, warlike, horse-riding pastoralists from the Pontic-Caspian steppe, who imposed their sky gods and their Indo-European languages.
Gimbutas's legacy is complicated. Part of her argument, that steppe peoples moved into Europe and spread Indo-European languages, has been dramatically supported by ancient DNA research since 2015, which has shown a massive migration from the steppe around five thousand years ago that transformed the genetic makeup of Europe. But her vision of a unified goddess religion has not fared well. Critics have pointed out that the figurines she interpreted as goddesses are enormously varied; that many are sexless or ambiguous; that they are often found in rubbish pits and domestic contexts rather than shrines; and that there is no independent evidence that they were objects of worship at all. In 1968, the archaeologist Peter Ucko had already demonstrated, in a study of Cretan and Egyptian figurines, that small human figures in known societies serve many purposes: toys, dolls, teaching aids, portraits, charms, votive offerings, sorcery, and initiation objects.
The archaeologist Lynn Meskell, reviewing the goddess debate in the 1990s, argued that the Great Goddess was as much a product of twentieth-century longings, for a past in which women were revered and the earth was sacred, as of any archaeological evidence. That does not make the longings illegitimate. It does mean that the figurines cannot bear the full weight of the story.
The Great Goddess was as much a product of twentieth-century longings as of any evidence from the ground.
Other readings
Several alternative interpretations have been proposed, each capturing something.
In 1996, the artist and researcher LeRoy McDermott suggested that the figurines might be self-representations made by women. If a pregnant woman looks down at her own body, without a mirror, what does she see? Large breasts in the foreground, a swelling belly, the tops of her thighs, and her feet foreshortened or invisible. Her face, of course, she cannot see at all. McDermott argued that the peculiar proportions of many figurines match this perspective. The theory is ingenious and hard to test. But it opens a door that had long been closed: that the makers of the figurines might have been women, and that the figures might express female knowledge of the female body rather than male fantasy.
Others have emphasized the variety of the figurines. The archaeologist Sarah Nelson pointed out in 1990 that textbooks tended to illustrate only the most voluminous examples, giving a false impression of uniformity. In fact, the figurines depict women of many ages and body types, some slender, some pregnant, some apparently past childbearing. In this reading, they may represent the stages of a woman's life, and their use may have been connected to rites of passage such as puberty, pregnancy, and childbirth, dangerous and sacred moments in every hunter-gatherer society.
A 2020 study led by Richard Johnson took a different, ecological approach. It found that figurines depicting heavier women tended to come from sites closer to the advancing glaciers during the coldest phases of the Ice Age. In a world where food shortages could be lethal, and where fat reserves were essential for surviving pregnancy and nursing through a hard winter, the authors suggested, a well-nourished female body may have been an ideal, a talisman of survival and plenty. The theory is suggestive, not conclusive. But it reminds us that the figurines were made by people living on the edge of an ice sheet, for whom the relationship between food, fat, fertility, and survival was not abstract.
What the absences say
Sometimes the most eloquent evidence is what is missing. Male figures are rare in Upper Palaeolithic sculpture. There are phallic objects, including a polished siltstone phallus from Hohle Fels about twenty-eight thousand years old, which may also have been used as a tool for knapping flint. But carved men are few. Animals dominate the cave walls; women dominate the portable sculpture. This division is itself suggestive, hinting at different domains of meaning, perhaps different makers and users. Faces are rare, too, in both. It is as if the individual, the particular person, was not what these images were about. They were about types, or powers, or states of being: fertility, abundance, the animal, the dead.
The stone in the Son valley
Let us travel to India, where the question of the Mother Goddess takes on a remarkable continuity.
In 1980, in the Son valley near the village of Baghor in the Sidhi district of Madhya Pradesh, archaeologists from the University of Allahabad and the University of California at Berkeley, including G. R. Sharma, J. Desmond Clark, and J. M. Kenoyer, excavated a late Upper Palaeolithic site dated to around nine to eleven thousand years ago. There they found a circular platform of sandstone rubble. At its centre had lain a naturally formed triangular piece of stone, about fifteen centimetres tall, whose surface showed concentric triangular layers in yellowish-red and reddish-brown.
What made the find extraordinary was what the archaeologists observed around them. The local Kol and Baiga communities still collect similar stones, with natural triangular laminations, and install them on platforms as representations of the goddess, known as Mai, or as forms of Devi, the great goddess of Hindu tradition. The triangle is one of the most ancient and persistent symbols of the feminine and of the goddess in India, visible in tantric yantras to this day. Kenoyer and his colleagues suggested that the Baghor stone may be an early instance of this practice, a shrine to a female power, set up by hunter-gatherers perhaps ten thousand years ago, in a form that local people continue to recognize.
The interpretation is not proven. Continuity across ten millennia is always hard to demonstrate, and there may have been many breaks and reinventions. But the Baghor stone stands as one of the most suggestive links anywhere in the world between a prehistoric ritual object and a living religious tradition. It suggests that at least in some places, the veneration of a female power in the form of a natural stone may reach back to the end of the Ice Age.
Later, the Indian subcontinent became one of the great centres of figurine-making. At Mehrgarh, at the foot of the Bolan Pass in Baluchistan, one of the earliest farming villages in South Asia, occupied from around 7000 BCE, archaeologists found clay female figurines that grew more elaborate over the millennia, with heavy jewellery, elaborate hairstyles, and, in later periods, infants in their arms. In the cities of the Indus Valley civilization, clay female figurines with fan-shaped headdresses were common, and the scholar John Marshall, who directed excavations at Mohenjo-daro in the 1920s, interpreted them as evidence of a Mother Goddess cult that anticipated the worship of Shakti. That interpretation is debated, like its European equivalents. But the density of female figures in the South Asian record, and the enduring centrality of the goddess in Indian religion, from village deities to the great Devi of the Puranas, makes the question more than academic. In India, the Mother is not only an archaeological hypothesis. She is present in thousands of village shrines where a stone, smeared with vermilion, is a goddess.
In India, the Mother is not only a hypothesis. She is a stone smeared with vermilion in a thousand village shrines.
The womb and the tomb
If we step back from the individual debates, a larger pattern emerges, one that connects the figurines to the burials of Chapter II and the caves of Chapter III.
For primordial societies, birth and death were the two great mysteries of existence, and they were closely linked. Both involved blood. Both were moments of danger and transition. Both concerned the passage of beings between the visible world and some other realm. In many hunter-gatherer and early farming traditions, the dead return to the womb of the earth; the flexed position of so many burials, knees drawn up to the chest, resembles the position of a child in the womb; and ancestors are reborn in children. Red ochre, the colour of blood, appears on the dead and on the figurines alike. The cave, dark, enclosed, entered through narrow passages, has been compared by many writers to a womb, and the emergence from it to a birth.
In this light, the figurines may not be about fertility in the narrow sense of having more babies. They may be about regeneration: the capacity of life to renew itself, of the dead to return, of the animals to come back each season, of the world to continue. The female body, which visibly creates new life from itself, would have been the most obvious and powerful image of that capacity. Whether the figurines were worshipped as goddesses, used as charms, carried through pregnancy, given to girls at initiation, or broken in the fire, they may all have been, in one way or another, meditations on the mystery of how life comes from life.
That mystery would become more urgent, and more central to religion, when human beings began to plant seeds, put them into the dark earth, and wait for them to rise again. But before the seeds, there were stones. And on a hill in southeastern Turkey, around eleven and a half thousand years ago, human beings raised stones on a scale that would force archaeologists to rethink the whole order of human history.