Rohit Shah

Chapter VIII

Seeds and ancestors

How farming moved the dead under the floor, gave them faces of plaster, and made them the owners of the land.

In 1953, the British archaeologist Kathleen Kenyon was excavating at Jericho, in the Jordan Valley, when her team uncovered a human skull whose face had been rebuilt in plaster. The features were modelled with care: a nose, lips, cheeks, and closed or open eyes made of inlaid seashells. Traces of paint remained. The effect was of a face both alive and serene. Over the following seasons, more plastered skulls came to light at Jericho, and at other sites across the Levant and Anatolia. They date from the Pre-Pottery Neolithic B period, roughly nine to ten thousand years ago, when the first farming villages were spreading across the Near East.

A human skull from Jericho with a face modelled in plaster and shells set in the eye sockets
PlateA plastered skull from Jericho, about 7200 BCE, now in the British Museum. The face was rebuilt in lime plaster and shells were set in the eye sockets. Photo: Zunkir / Wikimedia Commons

The plastered skulls of Jericho are among the most arresting objects of the ancient world. They are also among the most revealing. They show us that, as human beings began to farm and settle, they did not simply bury their dead and forget them. They dug them up, removed their heads, rebuilt their faces, and kept them among the living. The dead, in the first villages, did not go away. They stayed at home.

In the first villages, the dead did not go away. They stayed at home.

What farming changed

The transition to farming, which began independently in perhaps a dozen regions of the world between about eleven thousand and four thousand years ago, including the Fertile Crescent, China's Yellow and Yangtze river valleys, New Guinea, Mesoamerica, the Andes, the Sahel, and the Indian subcontinent, was not an event but a slow, uneven process lasting thousands of years. In each region, it transformed not only how people ate but how they lived, how they related to land and to each other, and how they understood the world.

Consider the difference between a hunter-gatherer and a farmer in their relationship to time and place. A hunter-gatherer moves through a landscape, following animals and seasons, returning to places but not owning them. Food is gathered and eaten, shared immediately, rarely stored. The farmer, by contrast, invests labour in a particular piece of land, clears it, plants it, waits months for a harvest, and stores the surplus to survive until the next. The farmer's wealth is tied to a place and to the future. The land must be defended, and it must be passed on. That raises a question that hunter-gatherers seldom needed to ask so urgently: who owns this land, and by what right?

The answer, in many farming societies, was the ancestors. The land belonged to those who had first cleared it and were buried in it, and it passed to their descendants. To be able to name your ancestors and point to their graves was to prove your claim. The dead became title deeds. This is one of the most important transformations in the history of religion: the shift from the generalized, often anonymous, sometimes dangerous dead of hunter-gatherer societies to specific, named, powerful ancestors, venerated by their descendants, who guaranteed the continuity of the lineage and its right to the land.

The skull cult

The plastered skulls of Jericho belong to a widespread practice. At sites across the Neolithic Near East, from Jericho and 'Ain Ghazal in the Levant to Çayönü and Çatalhöyük in Anatolia, the dead were buried beneath the floors of houses. After the flesh had decayed, the graves were often reopened and the skulls removed. Some were plastered and painted; others were cached in groups, in special buildings or under floors. At Çayönü, in southeastern Turkey, a building known as the Skull Building contained the remains of more than four hundred individuals, many of them skulls, stacked in chambers; later analysis found residues of blood on a stone slab within, suggesting sacrifice, whether animal or human, though the interpretation remains contested.

Burials beneath the floor of a Neolithic houseThe living abovethe ancestors below the floor
FigureAcross the early farming Near East, from Jericho to Çatalhöyük, the dead were buried beneath the floors of houses. Land and home were shared with named forebears, who could later be lifted, handled and reburied.

Why the skull? The head is the seat of the face, and the face is the seat of identity. To remove the head and preserve it is to preserve the person, or at least the part of the person that others recognize. The plastered faces, rebuilt over the bone, suggest a desire to restore the dead to their social existence, to give them back their features so they could be seen, addressed, and remembered. Some researchers have suggested that the plastered skulls were portraits of particular individuals, perhaps respected elders or founders of households. Others think the faces are idealized, not individual. Either way, they turned the dead into presences.

Recall Robert Hertz and his study of double burial in Chapter II. The Neolithic skull cult is a double burial on a monumental scale. The body is first buried, allowed to decay, and then the skull is retrieved for a second, transforming treatment that turns a corpse into an ancestor. The ancestor is then kept, displayed, handled, and eventually reburied, perhaps under the floor of a new house, perhaps in a collective cache. The death of the individual is completed by being incorporated into the enduring body of the community.

The statues of 'Ain Ghazal

In 1983, road builders on the outskirts of Amman, in Jordan, cut through an ancient settlement called 'Ain Ghazal. Archaeologists who then excavated the site found two pits containing extraordinary statues: more than two dozen human figures and busts, made of lime plaster modelled over bundles of reeds, about nine thousand years old. Some of the figures are nearly a metre tall. Their eyes are wide and staring, outlined in bitumen, with irises that give them an intense, almost hypnotic gaze. Several of the busts have two heads.

No one knows who or what the statues represent. They may be ancestors, mythical founders, or gods. The two-headed busts suggest beings beyond ordinary humanity. The fact that the statues were buried together, apparently with care, suggests they were ritually retired when they had served their purpose, as some traditions still retire sacred images. What is clear is that at 'Ain Ghazal, human-shaped figures, larger than the portable figurines of earlier periods, were being made to stand, to be seen, and perhaps to be addressed. They are a step closer to the cult statue, the image of a god housed in a temple, that would become central to the religions of Mesopotamia, Egypt, and India.

Their eyes, outlined in bitumen, still stare. They are a step closer to the god who lives in a temple.

Çatalhöyük: a town of the dead and the living

The richest window into the religion of the early farmers is Çatalhöyük, on the Konya plain in central Anatolia, occupied from about 7100 to 5950 BCE. At its height, it may have housed several thousand people, perhaps as many as eight thousand, making it one of the largest settlements in the world at the time. It was first excavated by the British archaeologist James Mellaart between 1961 and 1965, and then, from 1993 to 2017, by a large international team directed by Ian Hodder.

Çatalhöyük was a strange town by modern standards. It had no streets. Houses were built directly against each other, like cells in a honeycomb, and people moved across the rooftops and entered their homes through holes in the roof, climbing down a ladder. Inside, the houses were small, with raised platforms along the walls for sitting, working, and sleeping. Beneath those platforms, the inhabitants buried their dead. Over the centuries, a single house might accumulate dozens of burials. When a house was abandoned, it was carefully dismantled and filled in, and a new house was built on top of it, often following the same plan, with the platforms and burials in the same positions. Some houses were rebuilt many times, over hundreds of years, on the same spot. Hodder called these "history houses," places where the continuity of a lineage was maintained through the repeated rebuilding of a home over its dead.

The walls of the houses were plastered and painted, sometimes with geometric patterns, sometimes with scenes. Some show crowds of human figures teasing or baiting enormous wild bulls and deer. Some show vultures, with huge wings, swooping over headless human figures, which Mellaart interpreted as a depiction of excarnation, the exposure of corpses to be picked clean by birds before the bones were buried. In the walls were set the horns and skulls of wild cattle, the aurochs, sometimes in rows, modelled over with plaster so that they projected into the room. There were plaster reliefs of leopards facing each other, and of figures with raised arms and legs that Mellaart read as goddesses giving birth and others read as bears. The breasts of some modelled figures had the beaks of vultures, the jaws of foxes, or the tusks of boars embedded inside them.

Mellaart saw Çatalhöyük as the centre of a Great Goddess religion, and his most famous find supported his view: a clay figure of a large woman seated on a throne, her hands resting on two felines, found in a grain bin. The Seated Woman of Çatalhöyük, now in the Museum of Anatolian Civilizations in Ankara, became the icon of the Mother Goddess movement. But Hodder's later excavations complicated this picture. They found that most figurines at the site were not goddesses but small, casual objects, often found in rubbish, and that many depicted animals. Female figures were more often shown as older and heavier than as young and fertile. Hodder concluded that the religion of Çatalhöyük was focused less on a Great Goddess than on the house, the ancestors, and the powerful wild animals, especially the bull, whose horns lined the walls.

In 2004, Hodder's team found a burial that seems to capture the heart of that religion. A woman had been buried holding a plastered skull in her arms, the face painted red. It had been removed from someone else's grave, re-plastered, and then buried again with her, perhaps as an ancestor, perhaps a parent. She is embracing the dead.

The dying and rising seed

Farming introduced a new rhythm into human life: the annual cycle of planting, growing, harvesting, and dying. Seeds are put into the dark earth, as the dead are, and after a period of apparent death, they rise again as new life. The analogy between the seed and the dead, between the harvest and the return of the ancestors, is so natural that it appears in agricultural religions across the world.

The German ethnologist Adolf Jensen, working in the 1930s on the island of Seram in the Moluccas, recorded a myth of the Wemale people that has become famous. In the mythic time, there was a girl named Hainuwele, "coconut branch," who had been born miraculously from a coconut palm. At a great dance, she distributed precious gifts from her own body. The people, jealous or afraid, killed her and buried her in the dance ground. Her father dug up the body, cut it into pieces, and buried the pieces in different places. From the pieces grew the tuber plants, the yams, that the people have eaten ever since. Death, in this myth, is the origin of food. And the killing of a divine being is the event that brought both mortality and agriculture into the world.

Jensen called beings like Hainuwele "dema deities," and he found variations of the pattern across the tropical cultivator societies of Southeast Asia, Oceania, and the Americas. The idea of a divine being killed and dismembered to create the world, or the food supply, appears in many mythologies, from the Norse giant Ymir to the Vedic Purusha, whose sacrifice in the Rigveda's Purusha Sukta produces the universe and the social order, to the Mesopotamian Tiamat. The Scottish anthropologist James Frazer, in The Golden Bough (1890 and later editions), collected hundreds of examples of what he called dying and rising gods, figures such as Osiris, Adonis, Tammuz, and Attis, whose death and return were associated with the agricultural year. Later scholars criticized Frazer for forcing diverse myths into a single pattern. But the underlying connection between death and fertility in agricultural religions is real and profound.

In the myth of Hainuwele, death is the origin of food, and a murdered girl becomes the yams that feed a people.

Mehrgarh and Jiahu

The same transformation, from forager to farmer, and from the anonymous dead to the ancestral dead, can be seen across Asia. At Mehrgarh, at the edge of the Indus plains, farmers from around 7000 BCE grew barley and wheat and domesticated zebu cattle, goats, and sheep. They buried their dead in the settlement, often with grave goods: beads of shell, turquoise, and lapis lazuli brought from great distances, stone tools, and sometimes young goats. In a startling discovery reported in 2006, researchers found that some Mehrgarh individuals, between about nine thousand and seven and a half thousand years ago, had holes drilled in their molars, apparently by bow drills with flint tips, the earliest known evidence of dentistry. The same care that tended the living body was lavished on the dead.

At Jiahu, in Henan province in China, occupied from about 7000 to 5700 BCE, archaeologists found more than three hundred burials, some with remarkable objects. Among them were flutes made from the wing bones of red-crowned cranes, several still playable, with carefully spaced finger holes producing recognizable scales. They were found in the graves of what may have been ritual specialists, along with tortoise shells containing small pebbles, possibly used as rattles, some incised with signs that a few scholars have proposed as precursors to the Chinese script, a claim most remain cautious about. Chemical analysis of residues in pottery at Jiahu, published by the archaeochemist Patrick McGovern in 2004, revealed the earliest known fermented beverage, a mixture of rice, honey, and fruit, possibly hawthorn or grape. Music, divination, intoxication, and the dead were gathered together in the grave.

The tortoise shells of Jiahu are especially interesting in the light of what came much later. In the Shang dynasty, over five thousand years afterward, Chinese kings communicated with their ancestors by heating tortoise plastrons and ox shoulder blades until they cracked, then reading the cracks as answers to questions. The oracle bones of the Shang, which we will meet in Chapter X, are the earliest substantial body of Chinese writing, and they are almost entirely concerned with communication with the ancestors. The line from Jiahu to Anyang is not direct, but the persistence of the tortoise as a medium between the living and the dead is striking.

The shadow side

The Neolithic was not an age of peaceful villages under benevolent ancestors. The same processes that produced property, lineage, and ancestor veneration also produced inequality, conflict, and violence. At Talheim in southwestern Germany, around 5000 BCE, a mass grave contained the remains of thirty-four people, men, women, and children, killed by blows from stone axes of the kind used by the local farmers themselves, and apparently from behind, as they fled. At Schöneck-Kilianstädten, also in Germany, another mass grave of the same period contained victims whose shin bones had been deliberately broken, perhaps as torture or as a ritual mutilation of enemies. Skeletal studies suggest that farmers, compared with hunter-gatherers, often suffered from worse nutrition, more infectious disease, and more tooth decay, as they crowded together with domesticated animals and relied on a narrower range of crops.

These realities shaped religion too. A world in which harvests could fail, epidemics could sweep through villages, and neighbours could become killers was a world that needed powerful protectors. The ancestors, who guaranteed the land and watched over their descendants, could also punish those who neglected them, bringing illness and misfortune. Ancestral religion, in many societies, is as much about fear as about love: the dead must be fed, honoured, and kept content, or they will turn against the living.

From ancestor to god

In 1960, the American sociologist Guy Swanson published a book called The Birth of the Gods, in which he examined fifty societies to find out what kinds of social structure correlated with what kinds of religious beliefs. He found that belief in active ancestral spirits was strongly associated with societies in which kinship groups, clans and lineages, held important powers, such as control of land. Belief in a high god, a supreme being who created or rules the world, was associated with societies that had several levels of "sovereign groups," that is, a hierarchy of decision-making bodies, such as households within villages within chiefdoms. The structure of the heavens, Swanson concluded, mirrors the structure of society.

This insight points to one of the most important routes by which gods emerged. As societies grew larger and more hierarchical, some lineages became more powerful than others. The ancestors of those lineages became more important than the ancestors of lesser families. The founding ancestor of a chiefly lineage could become the ancestor of the whole community, then its protector, then its god. Among the Polynesian chiefdoms, for example, ruling chiefs claimed descent from the gods, and the most senior chiefs were so sacred, so full of mana, that their very shadow could be dangerous to commoners. Ancestors, chiefs, and gods formed a continuous hierarchy.

Farming, then, did not simply add ancestors to religion. It created the social conditions in which some dead people became more powerful than others, and in which the most powerful dead could rise, generation by generation, toward divinity. The village under whose floors the dead were buried would, in time, become the city whose temple housed a god. But between the village and the city there was one more great transformation, when human beings began to raise stones not only to their dead but to the sky.

Curated by Claude from my favourite reads. About this material