Rohit Shah

Epilogue

Back to the Market

What changes when you have learned to see a market, a queue, a file, a festival, or your own shame as something made, and therefore something that could be made differently.

It is Thursday again, and the haat is gathering under the trees. The women are walking in from the villages with tamarind and broom grass on their heads. The traders are unrolling their plastic sheets. The watch repairer has set up his table, and the young man with dyed hair is checking his phone. Nothing has changed, and everything has, because we have learned, over a long journey, to look at it differently. The question this epilogue asks is not what the thinkers said, which the chapters have tried to show, but what it means to carry their ways of seeing into an ordinary morning.

The woman with the tamarind

Watch the old woman sell her tamarind. Before this book, she was simply a woman selling a product at a price. Now look again.

Through the lens of Part One, she is held in a web of belonging. She sits where her grandmother sat and knows every face around her. Next month she will be at the festival when the village gods are carried in procession, and there she will feel the surge that Durkheim called collective effervescence. If her sons leave for construction sites in distant cities and her village empties, she may feel what Durkheim called anomie and Arendt called loneliness, a world losing its shape.

Through the lens of Part Two, she is at the end of a chain of value that stretches to a processing plant and a wholesale market she will never see. The price she receives, which feels to her like a fact of nature, is a social relation hiding its own power, Marx's fetish. Her poverty and the wealth of the traders who buy from her are not simply the result of her being behind. As Wallerstein would say, they are produced together, by her region’s place in a larger machine. And her grandchildren’s chances at school will depend not only on their intelligence but on the cultural capital she cannot give them, as Bourdieu showed. So their eventual failure or success will look like personal merit.

Through the lens of Part Three, she is a self made in the eyes of others: Cooley's looking glass, Mead's generalized other, the voice in her head asking what people will say. Her posture before the forest guard, her lowered eyes before the official, her ease among her own people, are carried in her body, as Elias and Bourdieu described. When she goes to the district office for a certificate, Schutz's stranger, she will find that her stock of knowledge does not work there.

Through the lens of Part Four, she lives under authority she accepts as legitimate, mostly, and inside files she will never read. The registers that record her family's rations, forest rights, and identity are Foucault's archive and Dorothy Smith's relations of ruling. If a dam or a mine is planned upstream, the decision will be made far away, on maps, by people who will never see her face, and Bauman's warning will apply.

Through the lens of Part Five, she may be an Adivasi woman whose community colonial researchers classified as primitive. Her knowledge of the forest is still dismissed as custom rather than science, and her work at home counts for nothing in the survey. She stands where caste, gender, class and region meet, and no single policy sees all of her.

And through the lens of Part Six, she lives in a world changing faster than at any time in her life. A road, a mobile tower and the coming and going of migrants are reassembling the market around her. Her world is becoming liquid, and her grandchildren will build selves she cannot imagine.

None of these lenses is the truth about her. Together they show something no single lens can: that one ordinary woman's morning is crossed by forces of belonging and exploitation, meaning and power, exclusion and change, stretching across centuries and continents. And she is not merely their object. She bargains, jokes, refuses, remembers, chooses, and sometimes, with others, organizes.

The habits of mind

If this book has done its work, it leaves behind a few habits of mind that are more valuable than any list of names or concepts.

The first is the habit of astonishment: refusing to take the obvious as natural. The queue, the wedding, the exam, the uniform, the price, the shame you feel at using the wrong fork, the respect you feel for a certain accent, the disgust you feel at certain foods, the gods you pray to, the work you look down on: all of these have histories. They were made by people, at particular times, for particular reasons, often serving particular interests. Once you have seen this, you cannot unsee it, and the world becomes both stranger and more open.

The second is the habit of connecting troubles to issues. When a farmer is in debt, a student breaks down, a family cannot leave a violent home, a young man drifts toward crime or rebellion, or a graduate cannot find work, it is tempting to look only at the individual. Mills taught us to look also at the structures around them. This is not an excuse for any person's choices. It is a correction to the cruelty of blaming people for conditions they did not make, and the beginning of the collective action that can change those conditions.

The third is the habit of switching lenses and noticing what each one hides. Marx sees exploitation and misses the sacred. Durkheim sees solidarity and misses power. Weber sees meaning and legitimacy and may miss the body. Foucault sees discipline and may miss consent. Bourdieu sees how inequality reproduces itself and may miss change. Latour sees things and may miss intentions. A person who can use only one lens sees a great deal and is blind to much more. A person who can switch, and who knows what each lens is blind to, begins to see the world whole.

The fourth is the habit of looking from below. Du Bois’s second sight, Smith’s standpoint of women, Collins’s outsider within, Ambedkar’s view from the bottom rung of graded inequality, Ilaiah’s history written by the producers: again and again, the sharpest views of a society have come from those who had to understand it from its edges in order to survive. Those of us who stand nearer the centre of any hierarchy can borrow some of that vision only by listening, patiently and without defensiveness, to those who stand at its edges.

The fifth is the habit of remembering the face behind the file. The more powerful our institutions become, the more decisions about human lives are made at a distance, through maps, targets, categories, and algorithms. Bauman and Arendt showed what happens when the distance becomes total. The remedy is not to abolish files, which modern societies cannot do without. It is to keep restoring closeness: to visit the riverbank before signing the order, to meet the family behind the number, and to ask not only whether something was done correctly but whether it was right.

The fragility of what we have

Garfinkel showed how a single question about a flat tyre can break a conversation. Elias showed how the restraints of civilization, built over centuries, can collapse in a season of fear. Arendt showed how loneliness and lies can turn ordinary people toward terror. Durkheim showed how the breakdown of belonging produces despair. Tilly showed that the state's monopoly of legitimate force is an achievement that must be renewed, not a fact that persists by itself. Social order, all these thinkers agree, is not guaranteed. It is a daily accomplishment, sustained by trust, ritual, law, and countless small courtesies, and it can be lost.

Those who maintain it, teachers, nurses, judges, clerks, constables, health workers, parents, the people who keep the queue orderly and the market fair, carry a responsibility that is easy to forget until something fails. Sociology does not make that responsibility lighter. It makes it visible.

The freedom at the end

And yet the deepest lesson of these thinkers is not about fragility or constraint. It is about freedom. Every structure described in this book was built by human beings. Berger and Luckmann called it reification when we forget this. Marx called it alienation, and Lukács called it second nature. Ambedkar saw it in the holiness of the shastras, which made a human arrangement seem divine. To remember that the world was made is to remember that it can be remade.

The evidence is all around us. Handkerchiefs replaced fingers, and toilets are replacing fields. Untouchables drank at Chavdar Tank and wrote a constitution. Women who were taught to be the Other became presidents, scientists, and pilots. Villagers who never saw their own records read the muster rolls aloud and changed a nation's law. Hill women hugged trees and stopped the axes. Forest communities stood in their assemblies and said no to a mine on their sacred mountain. A boy who could not drink from the school tap became one of the most learned men of his century. In each case, people saw something presented as natural, eternal, or inevitable, recognized it as made, and made something else.

Mead's I can answer the me differently. Gramsci's good sense can grow within common sense. Butler's performance can be repeated otherwise. Foucault's histories show that what seems necessary was once a choice. Touraine's movements struggle over a society's right to choose its own future. Wright's real utopias already exist in the cracks. hooks's love can be practised as an ethic. Bourdieu said that sociology is a martial art: it defends us against the forces that would make us mere products of our circumstances.

To remember that the world was made is to remember that it can be remade.

The haat is in full swing now. The old woman has sold her tamarind and bought salt and a length of cloth. The young man has bought a phone cover and is laughing with his friends. The forest guard has passed through. Two families have, perhaps, agreed on a marriage. In the evening the traders will pack up and drive back to town, and the women will walk home under a darkening sky. Tomorrow the ground under the mahua trees will be empty, littered with leaves and wrappers, until Thursday comes again.

It looks simple. It is the most complicated thing in the world: human beings, who need one another and fear one another. They make meanings and then live inside them. They build hierarchies and then struggle against them. They are shaped by forces they cannot see, and every so often they see them, and change them. The thinkers in this book spent their lives trying to see. Some went to prison for it, some into exile; some died young; some were forgotten and then remembered. They left us their eyes. The least we can do is to look, and then, having looked, to act with a little more understanding and a little more tenderness toward the people with whom we share the world.

Curated by Claude from my favourite reads. About this material