Chapter XI
What remains in us
A coda on the primordial mind that still lives inside the modern one: in grief, in crowds, in awe, and in the hand pressed to a wall.
It would be comforting to end this story with the Axial Age, as if the long, dark prehistory of the human spirit had finally been left behind, and reason and ethics had lifted us out of the cave. But that is not what happened, and it is not what the evidence of our own lives suggests. The primordial mind did not disappear. It went underground, into habits, feelings, and intuitions that most of us rarely notice, and it surfaces constantly, sometimes in the most ordinary places.
This final chapter is not about the past. It is about the present, seen in the light of everything that came before.
The dead who do not leave
For much of the twentieth century, Western psychology taught that healthy grieving meant "letting go." Following an influential essay by Sigmund Freud, "Mourning and Melancholia" (1917), the task of the mourner was understood as withdrawing emotional attachment from the dead person, so that it could be reinvested in the living. People who continued to talk to the dead, keep their belongings, or feel their presence were regarded as stuck, even disordered.
In 1996, the researchers Dennis Klass, Phyllis Silverman, and Steven Nickman published a book called Continuing Bonds, which challenged this view. They showed that many bereaved people, perhaps most, maintain an ongoing relationship with the dead: talking to them, asking their advice, sensing their presence, visiting their graves, keeping their photographs in view, and feeling that they are still part of the family. Surveys in many countries have found that a large proportion of widows and widowers report sensing the presence of their dead spouse, sometimes seeing or hearing them. Far from being a sign of pathology, these continuing bonds are often a source of comfort and meaning. Grief, the new view holds, is not about breaking bonds but about transforming them.
That is exactly what Robert Hertz described in 1907, and what the people of Jericho were doing when they gave their dead faces of plaster. The dead are not simply gone. They are changed, and a new relationship with them must be built. When a family in Kerala keeps a lamp burning for a dead grandmother, when a Mexican family builds an altar with marigolds and photographs for the Day of the Dead, when a Chinese family sweeps the ancestral graves at Qingming, when a Hindu son performs shraddha to feed his ancestors, or when an atheist in London speaks aloud to a dead father at a gravestone, the continuity with the woman of Çatalhöyük who was buried embracing a plastered skull is not a metaphor. It is the same human act.
When someone speaks aloud to a dead father at a gravestone, the continuity with the Stone Age is not a metaphor. It is the same act.
The crowd and the sacred
Durkheim's collective effervescence did not end with the Arrernte. It fills stadiums every weekend. Football supporters sing in unison, wear the colours of their tribe, identify themselves with animal mascots, treat certain grounds as sacred, and experience, in moments of victory, an overwhelming sense of union with thousands of strangers. Researchers who study fans have measured synchronized heart rates and hormonal changes in crowds, and some have described intense sports fandom as an identity fusion comparable to the bonds formed by soldiers or initiates. Concerts, festivals, political rallies, and religious gatherings from the Kumbh Mela, one of the largest human gatherings on earth, to the Hajj produce the same effect: the self dissolves into the group, and the group feels charged with a power greater than any individual.
The neuroscience of synchrony that Dunbar and his colleagues have explored shows why this works. Moving, singing, and chanting together releases endorphins, raises pain thresholds, and increases feelings of closeness. The same mechanisms that bound the dancers in the trance circles of the Kalahari and the feasters at Durrington Walls operate in any crowd that sings the same song at the same moment. Human beings are built to be carried away together.
The persons in the world
The hyperactive agency detection device is still running. We see faces in electrical sockets and the fronts of cars, a phenomenon called pareidolia. We shout at computers that freeze, apologize to furniture we bump into, name our cars and boats, and feel guilty about throwing away a stuffed animal. Children talk to their toys, and many adults admit to feeling that objects have personalities. People form emotional attachments to robotic vacuum cleaners, give them names, and feel sad when they break. And, not least, people now talk every day with artificial conversational systems and find themselves attributing to them feelings, intentions, and inner lives. The question of which things are persons, which the Ojibwe elder answered with such care, has returned as one of the urgent questions of our time.
In some places, animist intuitions have even entered the law. In 2017, the Parliament of New Zealand passed legislation recognizing the Whanganui River as a legal person, Te Awa Tupua, in accordance with the view of the Māori iwi of the river, for whom it is an ancestor. In the same year, the High Court of the Indian state of Uttarakhand declared the Ganga and Yamuna rivers to be living entities with the rights of legal persons, a ruling later stayed by the Supreme Court of India. Similar moves have been made in Ecuador, whose constitution recognizes the rights of nature, and elsewhere. Whatever one thinks of these legal innovations, they show that the ancient idea that rivers, mountains, and forests can be persons, with whom humans have obligations, is not merely a relic. It is being proposed, by some, as part of the answer to the ecological crisis of the modern world.
Awe
There is one experience that runs through every chapter of this essay and that remains as powerful as ever: awe. The psychologist Dacher Keltner, who has studied awe for more than two decades, defines it as the feeling of being in the presence of something vast that transcends our current understanding of the world. People around the world report experiencing awe in nature, in music and art, in collective gatherings, in the presence of birth and death, and in spiritual and religious experiences. Keltner's research suggests that awe diminishes the sense of self, what he calls the "small self," increases generosity and humility, and makes people feel more connected to others and to something larger than themselves.
Stand under a clear night sky far from city lights, and you will feel something the watchers at Warren Field and Newgrange felt. Walk into a vast cathedral, temple, or mosque, and you will feel something the gatherers at Göbekli Tepe felt when they entered the circle of giant pillars. Watch the birth of a child or sit beside a dying parent, and you will feel something the family of the child Mtoto felt seventy-eight thousand years ago. Awe is perhaps the oldest religious emotion, older than any belief or doctrine, and it has not changed.
The fear that shapes us
The terror management researchers we met in Chapter II have shown, in hundreds of experiments across many countries, that reminders of death make people cling more tightly to their cultural worldviews, defend their groups more fiercely, and seek symbolic immortality through their children, their achievements, their nations, and their faiths. In one of the earliest studies, municipal court judges in Arizona who had been asked to think about their own deaths set bail for a hypothetical prostitute that was, on average, many times higher than judges who had not. The awareness of death, which first found expression in the graves of Qafzeh and Sungir, continues to shape our politics, our prejudices, and our loyalties, usually without our knowing it.
This is not a reason for despair. It is a reason for self-knowledge. If we know that the fear of death makes us rigid, we can notice it and choose otherwise. The same primordial psyche that produces tribalism also produces the capacity for compassion, ritual, beauty, and meaning. The same mind that sees enemies in shadows also sees persons in rivers and forests, and feels obligations to them. Everything depends on which of these capacities a culture chooses to cultivate.
The same mind that sees enemies in shadows also sees persons in rivers and forests. Everything depends on which a culture cultivates.
What we have learned
Let us gather, one final time, the insights of this long inquiry.
The deep past was not silent; it has been silenced by the decay of everything soft. What survives is the costly residue of meaning, and that residue tells us that, long before cities, writing, or gods, human beings were investing enormous effort in things that had no practical purpose: burials, paintings, carvings, ornaments, and monuments.
The first metaphysical problem was the corpse. The dead body, present but empty, forced the question of where the person had gone, and the earliest answers were written in the placement, adornment, and colouring of the dead. Care for the living, visible in the healed bones of the injured and disabled, preceded and underpinned the care for the dead.
The primordial world was full of persons, most of them not human. Animals were partners, relatives, and gift-givers, and the killing on which human life depended was a moral problem to be managed through respect, reciprocity, and ritual. Between human and animal lay a space of transformation, where the shaman travelled and the lion-man stood.
The human mind is naturally inclined to religion. Its tendency to detect agents, attribute minds, see purpose, separate mind from body, dream of other worlds, enter altered states, and bond through synchronized ritual makes religious ideas easy to think and hard to abandon.
Religion did not wait for agriculture. At Göbekli Tepe, hunter-gatherers built monumental sanctuaries, and the need to gather, feast, and build may have helped drive the domestication of plants. Belief, it seems, sometimes came before bread.
Farming transformed the dead into ancestors, the owners and guarantors of land, and some ancestors, those of the most powerful lineages, rose toward divinity. The cycle of seed and harvest joined death and fertility into a single sacred rhythm.
The megalith builders fixed sacred time in stone, aligning the dead with the turning points of the sun, and in doing so created a new kind of religious authority, based on knowledge of the sky. Human attention turned upward.
The high gods emerged as societies grew beyond the scale at which everyone could watch everyone else. Watchful, moralizing gods, mirroring the hierarchies of chiefs and kings, helped strangers trust each other, and heaven took the shape of the state. And in the Axial Age, human beings turned to question the gods themselves, seeking a transcendent order by which all earthly powers could be judged.
And nothing was lost. Every layer remains, built over but not erased, alive in how we grieve, gather, marvel, fear, and hope.
The hand on the wall, again
In schools and nurseries around the world, children dip their hands in paint and press them onto paper or walls, and their teachers write their names and the date beneath. Parents keep these handprints for decades. When the children grow up and move away, the prints stay on the refrigerator or in a drawer, and when the parents are old, they take them out and look at them, and remember a small hand that has become large.
No one needs to explain to a parent why a child's handprint matters. It says what the stencils in the caves of Sulawesi and Patagonia and the Pyrenees said, forty thousand years ago: I was here, I was small, I was real, I touched this surface and left a mark that will remain after the moment has passed. It is a gesture made against time and against forgetting, and, in the end, against death.
We do not know what the woman in the cave believed as she blew the red pigment around her hand. We do not know whether she thought the wall was a veil, whether she felt the spirits pressing against the other side, whether she was marking her membership in a group, her passage into adulthood, or her love for someone who had died. We will probably never know. But we know that she did it, that it mattered enough for her to go into the dark to do it, and that the mark she left still speaks to us, across a distance of time so great that it would take more than a thousand generations to cross.
The primordial psyche is not a stranger. It is the oldest part of ourselves. And when we stand before the hand on the wall, what we are really looking at is a mirror.