Chapter X
The high gods arrive
Remote creators, watchful sky fathers, temple cities, oracle bones, and how the size of a society changed the shape of its heaven.
At the end of the nineteenth century, the Scottish folklorist Andrew Lang noticed something that did not fit the reigning theories of religion. According to Tylor and his followers, religion had begun with animism, belief in many souls and spirits, and had slowly progressed, through polytheism, toward belief in a single god, the achievement of advanced civilizations. But in the ethnographic reports he was reading, Lang found that some of the peoples whom Victorians regarded as the most "primitive" on earth, in southeastern Australia, in Tierra del Fuego, and elsewhere, spoke of a great being who had made the world, who lived in the sky, and who, in some accounts, cared about human conduct. In The Making of Religion (1898), Lang argued that the idea of a supreme being was not a late development at all. It might be very old.
The Austrian priest and ethnologist Wilhelm Schmidt took this argument much further. In a monumental twelve-volume work, The Origin of the Idea of God, published between 1912 and 1955, he argued for what he called Urmonotheismus, primordial monotheism: the theory that the earliest human beings had believed in a single, benevolent creator god, and that animism, magic, and polytheism were later degenerations. Schmidt was a Catholic missionary, and his critics pointed out that his theory conveniently confirmed the biblical account of a pure original revelation followed by a fall. They also argued that many of the high gods he found among hunter-gatherers might have been influenced by contact with missionaries and neighbouring peoples.
Schmidt's theory has few defenders today. But the puzzle that Lang and Schmidt identified is real, and it is our starting point in this chapter. Some hunter-gatherer peoples do speak of great beings, creators, sky gods, or supreme spirits. Yet these beings are, in most cases, strikingly different from the gods of the great civilizations. Understanding that difference is the key to understanding how the gods, in the full sense, emerged.
The god who went away
Mircea Eliade gave the phenomenon a Latin name: deus otiosus, the idle god. In many traditions, especially in Africa, there is a supreme being who created the world long ago and then withdrew into the sky, no longer concerned with human affairs. Myths often explain the withdrawal. The sky, once close to the earth, was pushed away because a woman pounding grain with a long pestle kept striking it; or humans offended the creator, who departed. The creator remains acknowledged, but is rarely worshipped. People address their prayers and sacrifices instead to ancestors, spirits, and lesser deities who are closer and more responsive.
Among many hunter-gatherers, too, whatever high beings exist tend to be remote, ambivalent, or unconcerned with morality. Among the Ju/'hoan San, there is a great god who is powerful but capricious, and a lesser god associated with sickness and death; neither is primarily a guardian of human morality. The San trickster, the mantis Kaggen, is a creator but also a fool, a thief, and a joker. The Hadza of Tanzania associate the sun with a being called Haine, but, according to the anthropologist Frank Marlowe, who lived with them for many years, Haine does not punish wrongdoing or reward virtue. Morality, among the Hadza, is enforced by people, not gods.
This is the crucial finding of the cross-cultural study of hunter-gatherers by Peoples, Duda, and Marlowe that we met in Chapter IV. Across their sample, animism was universal, belief in an afterlife and shamanism were very common, and belief in high gods existed in a portion of societies. But belief in high gods who are active in human affairs and concerned with morality was rare among foragers. The gods of small societies, where they existed, were rarely moral police.
The gods of small societies, where they existed, were rarely moral police. Morality was enforced by people.
Why small groups do not need watchers
The reason becomes clear when we recall what life in a hunter-gatherer band was like. Everyone knows everyone. Every act of generosity or selfishness is seen, remembered, and discussed around the fire. The anthropologist Christopher Boehm, in Hierarchy in the Forest (1999), documented how foragers maintain equality through what he called a "reverse dominance hierarchy": the group collectively suppresses anyone who tries to boss others, hoard, or bully, using ridicule, gossip, ostracism, and, in extreme cases, violence. In a world where everyone is watched by everyone else, there is little need for an invisible watcher in the sky.
The situation changes when societies grow. In a village of a few hundred, you still know most people. In a town of several thousand, you do not. In a city or a kingdom of hundreds of thousands, most people you meet are strangers. How can you trust a stranger? How can you be sure a merchant will not cheat you, a neighbour will not steal from you, or an official will not abuse his power when no one is looking?
Big gods
The Canadian psychologist Ara Norenzayan, in Big Gods (2013), argued that belief in powerful, watchful, moralizing gods was one solution to this problem. If people believe that an all-seeing god is watching them, and will punish wrongdoing even when no human witness is present, they are more likely to behave honestly and cooperatively with strangers. Norenzayan and his colleagues cited experiments in which people who were subtly reminded of God, for example by unscrambling sentences containing religious words, behaved more generously toward anonymous others in economic games. Societies whose members believed in such gods, he argued, could grow larger and more cooperative than their rivals. "Watched people are nice people," he wrote.
The idea has been tested and debated extensively. In 2019, a large team using a historical database called Seshat, led by Harvey Whitehouse, published a study in Nature concluding that moralizing gods tended to appear only after societies had already become large and complex, with populations around a million, rather than before, suggesting that big gods were a consequence rather than a cause of social complexity. The study was sharply criticized for its handling of missing data, and a fierce methodological debate followed. The question of which came first, the big society or the big god, remains open. Most scholars now suspect that the two grew together, each reinforcing the other.
What is less disputed is the general correlation. Across the historical and ethnographic record, the larger, more hierarchical, and more complex a society, the more likely it is to have gods who are powerful, who are concerned with human morality, and who are organized in hierarchies that mirror the hierarchies on earth. Guy Swanson had seen this in 1960. The structure of heaven follows the structure of society.
The sky father
One of the most striking pieces of evidence for the ancient history of gods comes not from archaeology but from language. In the nineteenth century, scholars of comparative philology discovered that many languages of Europe and South Asia, including Sanskrit, Greek, Latin, the Germanic languages, the Celtic languages, and Persian, descend from a common ancestor, now called Proto-Indo-European, spoken perhaps six thousand years ago, most likely on the steppes north of the Black and Caspian seas, by the pastoral peoples whose migrations were described in Chapter VI.
By comparing the words for gods in the daughter languages, linguists have reconstructed at least one Proto-Indo-European deity with confidence. In the Rigveda, the oldest text of the Sanskrit tradition, there is a god called Dyauṣ Pitṛ, "Sky Father." In Greek, the king of the gods is Zeus, and in formal invocation Zeus Patēr, "Father Zeus." In Latin, the chief god is Jupiter, from an older Diespiter, "Sky Father." The names are the same name, descending from a reconstructed Proto-Indo-European form, Dyḗus ph₂tḗr, "Father Sky" or "Father of the Bright Sky." The same root gives us the Latin deus, "god," the Sanskrit deva, and, through Latin, the English words "divine" and "deity." When an English speaker says "divine," he or she is echoing a prayer to the bright sky spoken on the steppes six thousand years ago.
This sky father is a paradigm of the high god: male, celestial, paternal, and associated with the order of the cosmos. He fits a pastoral, patrilineal society in which fathers controlled herds and lineages were traced through the male line. His appearance across so many Indo-European cultures, and similar sky gods among Turkic and Mongol peoples, such as Tengri, suggests that the high god of the sky was especially at home among herders of the open grasslands, where the sky is vast and everywhere, and where cattle, the source of wealth, depend on the rains it brings.
When an English speaker says "divine," he is echoing a prayer to the bright sky spoken on the steppes six thousand years ago.
The first temple cities: Sumer
The first cities in the world arose in southern Mesopotamia, in what is now Iraq, in the fourth millennium BCE. The greatest of them was Uruk, which by around 3200 BCE may have held forty thousand people or more, an unprecedented concentration of human beings. At the heart of Uruk were two great sacred precincts. One, the Eanna, was dedicated to the goddess Inanna, goddess of love, war, and the morning and evening star, later known as Ishtar. The other was dedicated to An, or Anu, the god of the sky, whose temple, known as the White Temple for its whitewashed walls, stood on a high terrace, an early form of the ziggurat, the stepped temple-mountain that would become the defining architecture of Mesopotamian religion.

In Uruk, we can see the transformation of religion into an institution. The temples were not only places of worship. They were economic centres, which owned land, herds, and workshops, employed large numbers of workers, and collected and redistributed goods. The earliest writing in the world, proto-cuneiform tablets from Uruk around 3300 to 3100 BCE, consists overwhelmingly of temple accounts: records of barley, sheep, beer, textiles, and workers' rations. Writing was invented, in part, to keep the gods' books. On the Warka Vase, a great alabaster vessel from the Eanna precinct, dating to about 3000 BCE, rows of naked men carry baskets and jars of produce in procession toward a female figure, probably Inanna or her priestess, who stands before her shrine. The whole economy of the city is shown flowing toward the goddess.
The Mesopotamian gods had names, personalities, family relationships, and specific domains. Each city had its patron deity, who was believed to own the city and dwell in its temple, in the form of a cult statue that was fed, clothed, and bathed daily by priests. The king was the god's steward, ruling on the god's behalf. When cities went to war, their gods went to war. The cuneiform sign for "god," a star, was written before the names of deities to mark them as divine. The heavens had become a court, with a divine assembly of great gods who met, debated, and decreed the fates, mirroring the councils of elders and kings on earth.
Yet much of the older world survived within this new order. Inanna's descent to the underworld, recorded in Sumerian poetry, is a myth of death and return. Her consort Dumuzi, the shepherd god, dies and is mourned each year, a dying god of the kind Frazer catalogued. The dead were buried beneath houses, as they had been at Çatalhöyük, and offerings were made to them. The primordial layers were not erased. They were built upon.
Egypt: the king becomes a god
In Egypt, the process took a different form. During the fourth millennium BCE, the communities along the Nile consolidated into larger polities, and around 3100 BCE, Upper and Lower Egypt were unified under a single king. The Narmer Palette, a ceremonial slab of siltstone found at Hierakonpolis, shows a king wearing the crowns of Upper and Lower Egypt, smiting an enemy, while the falcon god Horus holds a captive by a rope. At the top of the palette, on both sides, are the heads of a cow-eared goddess, probably Bat, later absorbed into Hathor.
In Egypt, the king was not merely the steward of the gods. He was the living Horus, a god on earth, and at death he became Osiris, lord of the dead. Egyptian religion fused the oldest themes of the primordial world, the veneration of animals, the cult of the dead, the cycle of death and renewal, with the new power of the state. Many Egyptian gods retained animal forms or animal heads: Horus the falcon, Anubis the jackal, Hathor the cow, Sobek the crocodile, Thoth the ibis. They are, in a sense, the Masters of Animals of the hunting world, promoted to the rank of cosmic deities in the service of a kingdom.
The myth of Osiris, murdered by his brother Seth, dismembered, gathered up by his wife Isis, and restored to life as ruler of the underworld, is a direct heir of the dema myths of Chapter VIII: a god who dies, whose body is broken, and whose death brings life. Osiris was associated with the grain that sprouted from the Nile's flooded fields. Egyptian tombs sometimes included "corn mummies," figures of Osiris made of earth and seeds that would sprout in the darkness. The seed in the earth, the dead in the tomb, and the god who rises from death were, in Egypt, one idea.
The Indus: a silent civilization
The cities of the Indus Valley civilization, such as Harappa, Mohenjo-daro, Dholavira, and Rakhigarhi, flourished between about 2600 and 1900 BCE, covering an area larger than Mesopotamia and Egypt combined. They were remarkable for their planned streets, drainage systems, standardized bricks and weights, and, strikingly, the apparent absence of monumental temples and palaces of the Mesopotamian or Egyptian kind. Their script, found on thousands of small seals, has not been deciphered, and so their religion must be reconstructed from objects alone.
At Mohenjo-daro stands the Great Bath, a large, carefully waterproofed pool surrounded by rooms, which many scholars interpret as a place of ritual bathing and purification, anticipating the central importance of sacred water and purity in later Indian religion. Numerous clay female figurines, as we saw in Chapter VI, have been interpreted as images of a mother goddess. And on one famous seal, number 420 from Mohenjo-daro, sits a figure with a horned headdress, in a posture with legs folded and heels together that recalls later yogic postures, surrounded by animals: an elephant, a tiger, a rhinoceros, a buffalo, and deer beneath the seat. The excavator John Marshall called it a "proto-Shiva," identifying it with Shiva as Pashupati, the Lord of Animals.
The identification has been widely challenged. The scholar Doris Srinivasan and others have argued that the figure may be a buffalo-horned being without any connection to the later Shiva, and that reading Hinduism back into the Indus is anachronistic. But whatever its identity, the seal places before us once more the ancient figure of a being enthroned among wild animals, the Master of Animals whom we met in the Arctic and in the caves, now seated at the heart of one of the world's first great urban civilizations.
The Vedic gods and the cosmic order
The Rigveda, composed in an early form of Sanskrit perhaps between 1500 and 1200 BCE and transmitted orally with astonishing fidelity for centuries before it was written down, preserves the religion of Indo-European-speaking peoples in northwestern South Asia. Its gods include Dyaus, the old sky father, now faded into the background; Indra, the warrior god who slays the serpent Vritra and releases the waters; Agni, the god of fire, who carries sacrifices to the gods; Soma, the god of a sacred intoxicating drink; and Varuna, the guardian of ṛta, the cosmic order that governs both the regular movements of nature and the moral conduct of human beings.
Varuna is especially significant for our story. He sees everything; his spies watch the world; he knows when people lie or break their oaths, and he binds wrongdoers with his fetters. In Varuna, the high sky god has become a moral guardian, the kind of big god that Norenzayan describes. And the concept of ṛta, the order that holds the world together and that human beings must maintain through truthfulness and sacrifice, would evolve into dharma, the central concept of Indian religious thought. The sacrifice itself, the yajña, performed by specialist priests with precisely memorized hymns, was understood as the action that sustains the cosmos, a descendant of the solstice rites that renewed the world, now elaborated into one of the most complex ritual systems ever devised.
China: the ancestors who spoke to God
In China, the transition from ancestors to gods is visible with exceptional clarity. The Shang dynasty, which ruled from its capital near modern Anyang from about 1250 to 1046 BCE, left behind more than a hundred thousand fragments of oracle bones, ox shoulder blades and turtle plastrons on which the kings' diviners inscribed questions before heating the bones until they cracked. The kings asked about harvests, weather, warfare, hunts, illnesses, childbirth, dreams, and, above all, about which ancestors needed sacrifices and what they wanted.
At the top of the Shang spiritual hierarchy was a being called Di, or Shangdi, the "Lord Above," who controlled the rain, the wind, and the outcome of wars. But Di was remote and difficult to approach. The kings did not usually address Di directly. They addressed their ancestors, especially their royal ancestors, who, being close to Di, could intercede on their behalf. The deceased kings formed a chain of mediators between the living king and the supreme power. The Shang religion is a perfect illustration of how a high god could emerge from and stand above an ancestral cult: the ancestors of the most powerful lineage became the necessary intermediaries to the highest power, and the living king, as their descendant, became the only person who could reach it.
When the Zhou dynasty overthrew the Shang around 1046 BCE, it justified its conquest with a new concept: Tian, "Heaven," which granted a mandate to rule to virtuous kings and withdrew it from the wicked. The Shang, the Zhou claimed, had lost the mandate through their cruelty and corruption. Heaven had become a moral power, watching over the conduct of rulers. A remote Lord Above, reached through ancestors, had become a moral order that judged kings.
The ancestors of the king became the ladder to the Lord Above, and the king became the only one who could climb it.
The great turning
In 1949, the German philosopher Karl Jaspers noticed a remarkable coincidence. Between about 800 and 200 BCE, in several regions of the world that had little or no contact with each other, there appeared a series of thinkers and movements that transformed religious and philosophical thought: the Upanishads, the Buddha, and Mahavira in India; Confucius, Laozi, and Mozi in China; the Hebrew prophets in Israel; Zoroaster in Iran, though his dates are uncertain; and the philosophers of Greece. Jaspers called this period the Axial Age, the time when human history turned on its axis.
What the Axial thinkers shared, according to Jaspers and those who have developed his idea, such as the sociologist Robert Bellah in his great book Religion in Human Evolution (2011), was a new capacity for reflection and critique. They stepped back from the world and asked universal questions: What is the good? What is the self? What is ultimate reality? How should one live? They imagined a transcendent order beyond the world, whether the Brahman of the Upanishads, the Dao of Laozi, the one God of the prophets, or the Good of Plato, against which the existing order of kings, sacrifices, and customs could be judged, and often found wanting. They turned inward, toward the individual soul, and outward, toward humanity as a whole.
The Axial Age lies beyond the boundary of prehistory, and it is where our story reaches its horizon. But it is important to see how much of the primordial remains within it. The Upanishadic sages retired to the forest, as shamans once did, and sought through meditation and austerity a direct experience of ultimate reality, much as their ancestors had sought the spirit world in trance. The idea of rebirth, which became central to Indian religions, echoes the ancient belief that the dead return in new bodies, human or animal. The Buddha's compassion for all sentient beings, and the Jain principle of ahimsa, non-harm to any living creature, carry the animist sense of a world full of persons to a new, universal, ethical level.
Bellah insisted on a principle that serves as a fitting summary of this entire history: "nothing is ever lost." Each new form of religion, he argued, did not replace the old but was built on top of it, incorporating and transforming what came before. The Axial religions contain the archaic religions of kings and temples, which contain the tribal religions of ancestors and totems, which contain the primordial experiences of dreams, trance, ritual, and the encounter with death. The gods, when they came, did not come from nowhere. They rose out of the whole long history we have been tracing: from the grave, the cave, the animal, the mother, the feast, the ancestor, and the sky.