Rohit Shah

Prologue

The hand on the wall

Someone pressed a palm to the rock, filled their mouth with pigment, and blew. The question is why.

Imagine the moment in the only terms we can be sure of: stone, breath, and a flame. A person, perhaps a young woman, perhaps not, stands in a passage of limestone a few hundred metres from daylight. The air is cold and faintly metallic. A lamp of hollowed stone burns animal fat beside her, and its light does not so much illuminate the cave as argue with it. She has ground red ochre into a paste, or has powder in a small container of bone, and she takes some into her mouth. Then she spreads her left hand against the wall, fingers apart, and exhales in short, forceful bursts. When she lifts the hand away, it remains, a pale ghost of itself, printed in absence, haloed in red.

A hand stencil: pigment blown around a hand pressed to the wall
FigurePigment blown around a hand pressed to rock leaves the hand as an absence, haloed in colour. Stencils like this survive on almost every continent people reached early.

Hands like this one exist on almost every continent where human beings have lived for long enough to leave a mark. They crowd the walls of the Cueva de las Manos in Patagonia, several hundred of them, mostly left hands, as though a whole community had come to sign a register. They appear in the Maros-Pangkep karst of Sulawesi, in Indonesia, where some have been dated to around forty thousand years ago. They appear at Gargas, in the French Pyrenees, where many of the stencilled fingers seem to be missing joints, a puzzle that has been read as frostbite, as ritual amputation, and as a deliberate folding of the fingers into a kind of sign language. They appear in Arnhem Land and in the Kimberley of northern Australia, where the practice survived into living memory, so that there are elders who can say, of certain stencils, whose hand it was.

Hand stencils in red and ochre on the rock wall of the Cueva de las Manos, Argentina
PlateHand stencils at the Cueva de las Manos in Patagonia, Argentina, most of them left hands. The paintings here are thousands of years old. Photo: CarlosA.Barrio / Wikimedia Commons

The hand stencil is the most intimate artefact the deep past has given us, and also the most inscrutable. It says, unmistakably, I was here. But it does not say what "I" meant, or what "here" was. Was the wall a surface, or a membrane? Was the hand leaving a mark, or reaching through? Some ethnographers, working with Aboriginal communities and with the San of southern Africa, have heard people describe the rock face as a veil between this world and another, a skin behind which ancestors, animals, and spirit-beings move. If the woman in the cave believed anything like that, then her gesture was not decoration. It was contact.

The hand stencil says, unmistakably, I was here. It does not say what "I" meant, or what "here" was.

This essay is an attempt to follow that gesture backward and forward: backward into the long, mostly silent stretch of time in which our ancestors first began to bury their dead, paint in the dark, carve impossible creatures, and gather at sites that seem to have mattered for reasons beyond food and shelter; and forward, toward the moment when all of that diffuse, animal-haunted, ancestor-crowded experience condensed into something we would recognize as a god. It is a story about society, psyche, and mysticism, three words that, in the prehistoric context, are almost impossible to pull apart. The band was the self. The self was porous to the world. The world was full of persons, only some of whom were human.

A warning is owed at the outset, and it will be repeated, because it is the most important thing to understand about the subject. Almost everything we would most like to know about the primordial mind has left no trace. Songs do not fossilize. Neither do dances, dreams, taboos, prayers, jokes, the names of the dead, or the stories told at night. What survives is the hard residue of meaning, pigment, bone, stone, ivory, and the arrangement of these things in space. From that residue, archaeologists, anthropologists, cognitive scientists, and historians of religion have built an extraordinary edifice of inference. Some of it rests on bedrock. Some of it rests on sand. Part of the task here is to show which is which.

The other warning is that the story does not have a single hero or a single homeland. For much of the twentieth century, the narrative of human symbolic awakening was told almost entirely from the caves of France and Spain, as though the mind had switched on in the Dordogne. That picture has collapsed. The oldest known figurative paintings are now in Indonesia. The oldest engraved ochre and shell beads are in Africa. The oldest continuous living religious traditions are almost certainly Australian. India's Bhimbetka shelters hold one of the densest concentrations of rock art on earth. The primordial psyche was not European; it was human, and it emerged, as far as we can tell, wherever human beings were.

So we begin not with gods but with silence, and with the question of what can honestly be said about minds that left behind no words at all.

Curated by Claude from my favourite reads. About this material