Rohit Shah

Chapter II

The first dead

How a body became a problem, grief became a practice, and the grave became the first place where the living met the unseen.

About seventy-eight thousand years ago, at a cave called Panga ya Saidi in the coastal hills of Kenya, a child of two and a half or three died. Someone dug a shallow pit in the cave floor, laid the small body on its right side with the knees drawn up toward the chest, and covered it with earth. The positioning of the skull and upper vertebrae suggests that the child's head may have been resting on something soft that has since decayed, perhaps a folded hide, perhaps a pillow of leaves. The researchers who excavated the remains, and published them in 2021, named the child Mtoto, the Swahili word for child. It is the oldest known deliberate burial of a modern human in Africa.

No one knows the child's name, language, or the words spoken as the earth went back in. But the pillow, if that is what it was, says something that no tool can. A pillow is not for the dead. It is for the sleeping. Whoever arranged that head was treating the body as if it could still be made comfortable. That impulse, the refusal to let a loved body become mere matter, is where the human story of death, and perhaps of religion, begins.

A pillow is not for the dead. It is for the sleeping.

Before burial: the grief of animals

To understand what is new in human mortuary behaviour, we need a baseline. Many social animals respond to death in ways that look, to a human observer, like mourning. At Bossou in Guinea, researchers recorded chimpanzee mothers carrying the bodies of their dead infants for days and even weeks, grooming them and fending off flies, until the bodies were mummified. Elephants linger over the bones of their own species, turning them with their trunks and feet. Corvids gather around dead members of their flock. Dolphins support dead calves at the surface.

What these animals do not do, as far as anyone has observed, is transform the dead: move them to a special place, position them, cover them, adorn them, or return to them. Animal grief seems to be an extension of attachment, a bond that does not immediately switch off. Human mortuary practice is something else. It is a public act, performed according to shared expectations, that changes the status of the dead body and, with it, the status of the living. That is the threshold archaeologists are looking for when they ask when burial began.

The care of the living

Before the first burial, there is an earlier and in some ways more moving sign: the survival of the badly injured and the disabled. At Dmanisi in Georgia, among fossils dated to about 1.77 million years ago, is the skull of an elderly hominin who had lost all but one tooth years before death; the bone of the jaw had reabsorbed around the empty sockets. Such an individual could have survived only on soft foods, and some researchers have argued that this implies the help of others, though whether that help amounted to care in any deliberate sense is debated.

The case becomes stronger with the Neanderthals of Shanidar Cave in Iraqi Kurdistan, excavated by Ralph Solecki in the 1950s. The individual known as Shanidar 1 had suffered a crushing blow to the left side of the face, which likely blinded him in one eye; his right arm was withered and had possibly been amputated below the elbow; he had injuries to his legs and probably serious hearing loss. Yet he lived into what, for a Neanderthal, was old age, perhaps his forties. He could not have done so alone.

Much later, around eleven thousand years ago, at Riparo del Romito in southern Italy, a young man with a form of dwarfism that severely limited the length of his limbs was buried beside an adult. He had survived to his late teens in a mountainous hunting economy that he could scarcely have participated in fully. Bioarchaeologists such as Lorna Tilley have developed what they call the bioarchaeology of care, reading such skeletons not only as evidence of pathology but as evidence of social decisions: someone chose, again and again, to feed, carry, and protect a person who could not return the favour in kind.

The significance for religion is indirect but real. A society that invests in the vulnerable is a society in which individuals have value beyond their immediate usefulness. That valuation, of a person as a person, is the precondition for treating a dead person as someone rather than something.

The pit of bones

The oldest candidate for deliberate treatment of the dead lies deep in the Sierra de Atapuerca in northern Spain, at a site called the Sima de los Huesos, the Pit of Bones. At the bottom of a vertical shaft, roughly thirteen metres deep and reachable only after a long crawl through the cave system, excavators have recovered the remains of at least twenty-eight individuals dated to about 430,000 years ago. They belong to an early member of the Neanderthal lineage. Almost no animal bones are mixed in, other than those of cave bears and carnivores that seem to have fallen or wandered in.

How did so many human bodies end up at the bottom of a shaft? The excavation's co-director, Juan Luis Arsuaga, and his colleagues have argued that the bodies were deliberately dropped there by other members of their group, making the Sima the earliest known example of intentional funerary deposition. They point to a single, finely made hand axe of reddish quartzite, unused and found among the bones, which the excavators nicknamed Excalibur, and which they suggest may have been an offering. One skull from the pit, known as Cranium 17, bears two fractures made by the same object, apparently from blows delivered face to face; it has been proposed as the earliest known case of lethal interpersonal violence.

Other researchers remain sceptical, suggesting alternative explanations such as bodies washed in by water or accumulated by carnivores. But even the cautious reading leaves an eerie possibility: that nearly half a million years ago, a hominin group had developed the habit of taking its dead to a particular dark place and letting them fall.

The Rising Star controversy

An even more contentious claim comes from South Africa's Rising Star cave system, where teams led by the palaeoanthropologist Lee Berger have recovered more than two thousand fossil elements belonging to Homo naledi, a small-brained hominin that lived between roughly 335,000 and 236,000 years ago. The bones lie in chambers reachable only through fissures a few centimetres wider than a human torso. In 2023, Berger's team announced that they had identified deliberate burials there, and engraved marks on the cave walls, which would suggest that mortuary ritual, and perhaps symbolic behaviour, was not unique to large-brained humans.

The claims were met with sharp criticism during peer review and from other specialists, who argued that the evidence for dug graves and for intentional engraving was not yet convincing. The question remains open. But the controversy is instructive. It forces us to ask whether the ritual treatment of the dead requires the kind of cognitive capacity we associate with our own species, or whether it is an older, deeper hominin response to death that expressed itself in whatever minds happened to be present.

Qafzeh, Skhul, and the antlers

The oldest widely accepted intentional burials come from two caves in what is now Israel, Skhul and Qafzeh, dating to roughly 120,000 to 90,000 years ago and belonging to early modern humans. At Qafzeh, a young woman and a child were buried together. An adolescent known as Qafzeh 11, who had survived a head injury, was laid in a pit with the antlers of a red deer placed against the chest, clasped, it seems, in the hands. At Skhul, a man was buried holding the jaw of a wild boar.

Antlers and a jaw: not tools, not food, not clothing. They are fragments of powerful animals placed in intimate contact with a human body. We cannot know whether they were meant as offerings, as markers of identity, as protective spirits, or as some expression of kinship between the dead person and the animal world. But it is striking that from the very beginning of the human burial record, the animal is there in the grave. It will remain there for tens of thousands of years, and it will lead us, in later chapters, into the heart of animism.

The Neanderthal dead

The question of whether Neanderthals buried their dead has swung back and forth for more than a century. In 1908, excavators at La Chapelle-aux-Saints in France uncovered an elderly Neanderthal lying in a pit, and claimed a burial. Critics in later decades argued that the "grave" might be a natural depression, and the whole idea of Neanderthal burial an artefact of wishful excavation. In 2014, a team led by William Rendu re-excavated the site and concluded that the pit had indeed been dug and the body covered soon after death.

At Kebara Cave in Israel, a Neanderthal man dated to about sixty thousand years ago lies in a grave with his skull missing, but with his lower jaw and the delicate hyoid bone of the throat still in place. This pattern suggests the skull was removed deliberately after the flesh had decayed, a practice that would echo, tens of thousands of years later, in the plastered skulls of Neolithic Jericho.

And then there is Shanidar again. In 1960, Solecki found soil samples around the individual known as Shanidar 4 that contained dense clusters of pollen from flowering plants. He proposed that the body had been laid on a bed of flowers, and the "flower burial" became one of the most beloved images of prehistory, helping to transform the popular image of the Neanderthal from brute into mourner. Later work has argued that the pollen was more likely carried in by burrowing rodents or bees. The flowers may be gone. But renewed excavations at Shanidar since 2015 have found further Neanderthal remains, including an individual known as Shanidar Z, in circumstances that continue to suggest the cave was a place where the dead were repeatedly brought.

From the very beginning of the human burial record, the animal is there in the grave.

The grave becomes a cosmos

After about forty thousand years ago, burials in Eurasia and Australia change character. They become fewer in number relative to population, which suggests that burial was reserved for particular people, and far more elaborate.

The most astonishing are at Sungir, on the Klyazma River east of Moscow, dated to around thirty-four thousand years ago. In one grave lies an adult man covered with nearly three thousand beads of mammoth ivory, once sewn onto his clothing, along with ivory bracelets and a pendant. In another, two children, a boy and a girl, lie head to head. Together they wore more than ten thousand ivory beads, and beside them lay spears made of mammoth tusk that had been straightened, a remarkable technical feat, along with ivory discs, animal carvings, and a belt adorned with hundreds of arctic fox canines. The archaeologist Randall White, who studied the beads, estimated that each took perhaps an hour to make. The children's grave alone represents thousands of hours of labour, in a world where hours were measured against hunger and cold.

Reconstruction of an Upper Palaeolithic burial at Sungir, Russia, the skeleton covered in strings of ivory beads
PlateA museum reconstruction of an Upper Palaeolithic burial at Sungir, Russia: the dead man lies under thousands of ivory beads, an extraordinary investment of labour in a single grave. Photo: José-Manuel Benito Álvarez / Wikimedia Commons, public domain

Why lavish such wealth on children who could not yet have earned status of their own? One possibility is that status was already inherited, and that Sungir offers a glimpse of hereditary inequality long before agriculture. Another is that the children were special for other reasons, perhaps connected to how they died, or to a belief that the dead needed these goods in another world. One of the children had a bowed and shortened thigh bone, suggesting a congenital condition. Genetic analysis published in 2017 showed, surprisingly, that the Sungir individuals were not closely related to one another, suggesting that even these small Ice Age communities maintained wide networks of marriage and exchange to avoid inbreeding. Religion and kinship were, it seems, already entangled.

At Dolní Věstonice in the Czech Republic, around thirty-one thousand years ago, three young people were buried side by side. The one in the middle had a deformed spine and was probably disabled; the heads of all three were covered with red ochre, and ochre had also been placed at the pelvis of the central figure. The individual on the left lay with his hands reaching toward the pelvis of the one in the centre. The scene has inspired interpretations ranging from a ritual sacrifice to a childbirth tragedy to a family grave, and it has resisted them all.

At Arene Candide on the Ligurian coast of Italy, about twenty-eight thousand years ago, a young man in his mid-teens, now called Il Principe, the Prince, was laid out wearing a cap covered in hundreds of perforated shells, with ochre on his body and a long flint blade in his hand. He had suffered a terrible wound to his jaw and shoulder, possibly inflicted by an animal. The death was violent; the burial was a gesture of immense care.

Mungo: the ancestors who came home

On the other side of the world, in the dry lake basins of the Willandra region of New South Wales, the geologist Jim Bowler found in 1968 the partly cremated remains of a young woman, now known as Mungo Lady. Her body had been burned, the bones crushed, and then burned again before burial. In 1974 he found a man, Mungo Man, laid on his back with his hands clasped at the groin, his body sprinkled with red ochre that must have been carried from a source some distance away. Both are dated to around forty thousand years ago. The cremation of Mungo Lady is among the oldest known in the world.

These discoveries sit within a living tradition. For the Paakantyi, Mutthi Mutthi, and Ngiyampaa peoples, the traditional custodians of the Willandra Lakes, the remains were not specimens but ancestors. After years of advocacy, Mungo Lady was returned to her country in 1992 and Mungo Man in 2017. The return journey, accompanied by ceremony and by the descendants themselves, was itself a mortuary rite, performed by descendants for ancestors who had died forty millennia earlier. It is the strongest possible reminder that the deep past is not dead for everyone.

Reading the graveArchaeologists look for specific signs that a burial is intentional: a pit cut into existing deposits; an articulated skeleton, meaning the bones lie in anatomical order and the body was protected from scavengers soon after death; a consistent body position, often flexed; and objects placed in a way that could not have happened by chance. Ochre, ornaments, and animal parts strengthen the case. None of these alone is proof; together they can be persuasive.

What the dead taught the living

So much for the evidence. What did it mean? Here the great theorists of religion have offered frameworks that, while built largely on later societies, help us think about the primordial encounter with death.

In 1871 the English anthropologist Edward Burnett Tylor proposed that the first religious idea was the soul. Early human beings, he suggested, would have been puzzled by two experiences in particular: dreams, in which one travels and meets absent or dead people while the body lies still; and death, in which the body remains but something essential has gone. From these, he argued, they inferred the existence of a detachable life-principle, a soul or spirit, and then extended it to animals, plants, and objects. He called this belief animism, and he considered it the root of all religion.

Tylor's intellectualist account has been criticized for picturing early humans as lonely philosophers puzzling over logic, and for assuming a single linear progression from animism to monotheism. But its core observation remains powerful. Death presents every human community with a contradiction: the body is here, yet the person is not. Dreams present the inverse: the person is here, yet the body is not. A mind that could represent absent others, which is what storytelling and social planning require, would find it natural to imagine the dead as persisting somewhere.

In 1907, the French sociologist Robert Hertz, a student of Émile Durkheim, published an essay on what he called the collective representation of death. Studying the double burials of Borneo, in which bodies are first allowed to decay and then the cleaned bones are gathered for a second, final ceremony, Hertz argued that death is not an instant but a process. The soul's journey to the land of the dead mirrors the body's decomposition, and the mourners' period of danger and restriction mirrors both. When the bones are finally clean, the soul has arrived, the mourners are released, and society has repaired the tear in its fabric. Hertz's great insight was that funerary ritual is as much about the living as about the dead: it is how a community survives the loss of one of its members.

The Kebara skull removal, the crushed and reburned bones of Mungo Lady, and later the skull cults of the Neolithic Near East all fit Hertz's pattern of death as a process with stages. The Dutch-French folklorist Arnold van Gennep added a further frame in 1909: rites of passage, with their three phases of separation, liminality, and incorporation. The dead person is separated from the living, passes through a dangerous in-between state, and is incorporated into the community of ancestors. Burial, on this view, is not an ending but a transformation of membership.

Van Gennep's three phases of a rite of passageSeparationthe dead leavethe livingLiminalitya dangerousin-betweenIncorporationjoiningthe ancestors
FigureArnold van Gennep’s rites of passage, applied to death: the dead person is separated from the living, passes through a dangerous in-between state, and is finally incorporated among the ancestors.
Death presents every community with a contradiction: the body is here, yet the person is not.

The terror and the answer

A darker theory begins from the psyche rather than society. In 1973 the cultural anthropologist Ernest Becker published The Denial of Death, arguing that human beings, uniquely aware that they will die, are driven by a deep terror of annihilation that they manage by investing in cultural systems, including religion, that promise symbolic or literal immortality. The psychologists Jeff Greenberg, Sheldon Solomon, and Tom Pyszczynski turned Becker's ideas into terror management theory, and in hundreds of experiments have shown that reminding people of their mortality strengthens their attachment to their worldview and their group.

If Becker is right, then the first graves are not merely acts of love but acts of defence, the beginning of a long human project to build cultural walls against the knowledge of death. Critics point out that many hunter-gatherer societies seem remarkably matter-of-fact about death and that fear of the dead, rather than fear of one's own death, is often the more prominent emotion. Among many peoples, the recently dead are dangerous: they may be lonely, jealous, or angry, and must be persuaded, through ritual, to depart. Some Aboriginal communities avoid speaking the names of the dead for a period after death. Some foraging groups abandon the camp where a death occurred.

Both emotions, love and fear, were probably present from the start, and the grave served both. It kept the loved one close and it kept the dangerous one contained. Covering the body protected it from scavengers and protected the living from the sight and smell of decay; ochre could honour the dead and could perhaps also seal them. That ambivalence, the dead as beloved and as threat, will become one of the engines of religious development, producing on the one hand cults of ancestors who protect their descendants, and on the other a crowd of ghosts, spirits, and demons who must be appeased.

The first metaphysics

Put all this together and a picture emerges. For hundreds of thousands of years, hominins responded to death as other social animals do, with attachment that slowly faded. Somewhere along the line, and not necessarily only in our own species, the response became cultural: the dead were moved, placed, covered. By about a hundred thousand years ago, in the Levant, modern humans were placing animal parts with the dead. By about forty thousand years ago, from Russia to Australia, burials were being elaborated into statements about identity, status, and destiny, with ochre, ornaments, and in some cases enormous investments of labour.

The grave, in other words, was probably the first place where the human mind had to construct a model of what cannot be seen. The dead body forced a question that no other experience poses so sharply: where did the person go? Every answer to that question, whether a land beneath the earth, a journey to the sky, a return in animal form, a rebirth in a child, or a dissolution into the country itself, is a piece of metaphysics. Long before there were gods, there were the dead. And the dead, as we shall see, may have been the first beings to whom human beings addressed something like prayer.

Curated by Claude from my favourite reads. About this material