For the reader
A Reader’s Companion
The book’s key ideas in one place, questions for couples and reading groups, and a note on when to look for help beyond a book.
The argument in brief
Most of the turmoil people feel around commitment, desire and comparison comes from a handful of understandable mechanisms: the pull of unchosen options, the confusion of anxiety with chemistry, the way closeness can dampen passion, the habit of measuring a partner by how they look to others. Once these mechanisms are visible they lose much of their grip. Underneath them sits a question that can actually be answered: is this someone I respect, enjoy, desire and want to keep choosing, and who will keep choosing me?
The book is written mostly from the point of view of one partner approaching marriage, but almost everything in it applies to any long relationship, whoever is in it and at whatever stage.
Key ideas
Affective forecasting. Daniel Gilbert’s research on how we predict our future feelings. We tend to overestimate how long bad feelings will last and underestimate how well we adapt.
Anxious–avoidant trap. Amir Levine and Rachel Heller’s description of the pairing in which an anxiously attached partner pursues and an avoidantly attached partner withdraws, each provoking the other. The uncertainty is easily mistaken for passion.
Attachment styles. Patterns of seeking and keeping closeness, first described in infants by John Bowlby and Mary Ainsworth and later in adults: secure, anxious and avoidant. They are tendencies, not sentences, and can change.
Bids for connection. John Gottman’s term for the small attempts partners make to get each other’s attention, interest or support. Couples who last “turn toward” these bids far more often than couples who split.
Brakes and accelerators. Emily Nagoski’s dual-control model of desire. Desire depends as much on removing what inhibits it (stress, resentment, self-consciousness) as on adding stimulation.
Contempt. The most corrosive of Gottman’s “four horsemen” (criticism, contempt, defensiveness and stonewalling) and the strongest single predictor of divorce in his studies.
Deactivating strategies. Habits, often unconscious, that keep a partner at a distance when closeness grows, such as fixating on small flaws, idealising an ex or a “phantom” ideal partner, or saying “I’m not ready”.
Differentiation. David Schnarch’s term, drawn from Murray Bowen, for the ability to stay oneself while close to another: to hold one’s views and calm one’s own anxiety without needing the partner to agree or soothe.
Mimetic desire. René Girard’s idea that we learn what to want by watching what others want. It explains why a partner can seem suddenly less after an evening spent admiring someone else’s.
Maximizers and satisficers. Barry Schwartz’s distinction, building on Herbert Simon, between people who must find the best option and people who choose the first option that meets a high standard. Maximizers tend to feel more regret.
Responsive desire. Desire that emerges after intimacy begins rather than before it. Nagoski and Rosemary Basson show it is normal and common, especially in long relationships.
Self-expansion. Arthur Aron’s model: people seek to grow through relationships, and couples who do new and challenging things together report more satisfaction.
Walls and windows. Shirley Glass’s image for healthy boundaries. Partners keep a window open between them and a wall toward outsiders. Affairs often begin when that arrangement is reversed.
Questions for discussion
These work for a reading group, and many work just as well for two partners talking honestly over tea.
Part One · Choosing (Chapters 1–3)
- Which of your big decisions have you come to like more because they were final? Which did you keep reversible, and how did that feel?
- Think of the relationships you have admired most. Did they look like “spark” or like calm? What does that suggest about the word “chemistry”?
- What did the household you grew up in teach you about anger, closeness and keeping the peace? Which of those lessons do you still follow without meaning to?
Part Two · Desire (Chapters 4–6)
- Perel asks when do you feel most drawn to your partner? What is your honest answer, and what does it say about distance and separateness?
- What are your own brakes? Which of them could you and a partner actually change?
- Epictetus separates the impression that happens to us from the judgement we add to it. Try it on a recent moment of attraction or envy: where exactly did the impression end and the story begin?
Part Three · Comparison (Chapters 7–8)
- Whose opinion do you imagine when you compare your partner with someone else’s? How long will those people actually be part of your life?
- “A full portrait compared with a postcard.” Where else in life do you make this mistake?
- What would walls and windows look like in practice for you, with friends, colleagues and phones?
Part Four · What Lasts (Chapters 9–13)
- Which of Gottman’s horsemen shows up most in your arguments? What would its antidote look like in a real sentence?
- Fromm calls love an art that needs knowledge, effort, discipline, concentration and patience. Which of these comes hardest to you?
- Which of your doubts are about the person, and which would follow you into any relationship? How could you tell the difference?
- How will the work of a shared life be divided: paid work, housework, care of children and elders, emotional labour? Have you said so out loud, or only assumed?
A conversation worth having before a wedding
Couples who talk through practical questions early tend to avoid drifting into arrangements neither of them chose. A few to start with:
- Where do we want to live in five years, and whose work decides that?
- Do we want children? If so, roughly when, and who will do what in the first years?
- How will we handle money: joint, separate, or a mix?
- What does each of us need to feel free: time alone, friends, travel, a pursuit of our own?
- How involved will our families be, and how will we answer pressure from them?
- When we disagree badly, how do we want to repair?
When a book is not enough
Reading can make patterns visible. It cannot replace a conversation with a trained person when something is seriously wrong. Consider a qualified counsellor or couples therapist if doubts persist and keep returning to the same specific concern, if arguments regularly turn contemptuous or frightening, if there is any physical, emotional or financial control, or if anxiety or low mood is affecting sleep, work or health. Seeking help early is a sign of taking the relationship seriously, not a sign that it has failed.