Chapter 4
Desire in Captivity
Why the closeness that makes a marriage feel safe can quietly dim its passion, and what Esther Perel, David Schnarch and research on novelty suggest about keeping both.
Case history: Aman and Ritu, married eight years
Aman and Ritu are, by any measure, a good couple. They’re best friends. They share everything: finances, household chores, the care of their two children, every detail of their days. They text dozens of times a day. They finish each other’s sentences. And for months now, the romance has quietly gone out of their life together.
“I love her more than ever,” Aman says. “But somewhere along the way she became family. Wanting her feels almost strange, like wanting a sister.” Ritu, separately, says much the same thing. “We’re a great team. But I don’t feel seen by him as a woman any more. I feel seen as a co-parent.”
Neither of them is having an affair. Neither wants out. They’re puzzled. How can a relationship this close feel this unromantic?
The paradox Perel named
The Belgian-American psychotherapist Esther Perel built her reputation on exactly this puzzle. In Mating in Captivity (2006), she argued that the modern ideal of marriage contains a contradiction. We ask our partner to give us security: stability, reliability, predictability, belonging, a sense of home. And we ask the same partner to give us passion: mystery, novelty, adventure, risk. But security and passion, Perel argues, draw on opposite human needs.
Security grows from closeness, familiarity and knowing. Desire, in Perel’s account, grows from distance, from the space between two people, from the sense that the other is separate, a little unknown, not fully possessed. You can’t desire what you already completely have. Desire needs something to reach toward. Paraphrasing a line of hers often quoted: love seeks closeness, while desire needs a certain amount of space. Fire needs air.
Love wants to close the gap. Desire needs a gap to cross.
This is why the closest couples aren’t always the most passionate ones. When two people merge, sharing everything, knowing everything, fusing their identities, the separateness that desire feeds on can disappear. The partner becomes so familiar that there’s nothing left to reach for.
Perel asks couples a revealing question: When do you feel most drawn to your partner? The answers, she reports, fall into patterns. People often feel most attracted when they see their partner from a slight distance: on stage giving a talk, absorbed in something they’re good at, laughing with friends at a party, being admired by others, after a time apart. In those moments the partner is briefly other, a whole, separate person with a life and radiance of their own, not an extension of oneself. The familiar person becomes, for a moment, mysterious again.
Notice what the answers don’t include. People rarely say they feel most desire when their partner is doing the dishes, organizing the family calendar or comforting them in a crisis. Those moments build love. They don’t usually build desire.
Differentiation: the self that can desire
The psychologist and marital therapist David Schnarch, in Passionate Marriage (1997), approached the same problem from a different angle. Drawing on the family therapist Murray Bowen, Schnarch put a concept called differentiation at the centre of his work. Differentiation is the ability to stay a clear, distinct self while staying emotionally close to someone else: to hold on to your own thoughts, feelings and values without either merging with your partner or running from them.
Poorly differentiated couples, Schnarch argued, depend on each other for emotional regulation. If she’s upset, he must make her feel better or he can’t rest. If he’s distant, she panics. Each needs the other’s approval to feel secure. Schnarch called this other-validated intimacy: I can only be close to you if you validate me in return. It feels safe, but it’s fragile, and it’s deadly to desire, because desire requires risk. To show real desire, to reveal what you want, to be seen in your desire, you have to tolerate the possibility that your partner won’t share it, might judge it or might say no.
Well-differentiated partners can practise what Schnarch called self-validated intimacy: showing themselves honestly without needing the partner’s approval. That’s frightening. It’s also, Schnarch argued, what makes deep intimacy, physical as well as emotional, possible. He saw marriage as a crucible, a vessel in which the pressures of long-term intimacy force both partners to grow up: to soothe themselves, hold on to themselves and stop needing the other to be a perfect mirror.
Schnarch made a provocative claim. A lull in a marriage’s physical life isn’t a sign that something’s wrong. It’s a predictable stage, and it carries an invitation to growth. Many couples, he observed, find their deepest intimacy not in their twenties but in middle age, if they’ve done the work of becoming more differentiated. The capacity for profound closeness, in his view, is tied to emotional maturity, and maturity takes time.
For Schnarch, the boredom of a long marriage isn't the end of desire. It's an invitation to grow up.
The science of novelty
Perel and Schnarch were clinicians writing from their consulting rooms. But research psychologists have tested some related ideas, with suggestive results.
The psychologist Arthur Aron, the same Aron who ran the suspension bridge study, developed what’s known as the self-expansion model of relationships. People, Aron proposed, have a basic motivation to expand the self: to gain new knowledge, new experiences, new identities and new abilities. Falling in love is one of the most rapid forms of self-expansion there is. Suddenly you’re absorbing a whole new person, with their history, their views and their world. That’s part of why new love feels so exhilarating.
Over time, as partners get to know each other fully, the rate of self-expansion slows. Aron argued that this slowing, not the familiarity itself, is a major source of declining satisfaction. The solution? Do new and challenging things together.
In a well-known set of experiments published in 2000, Aron and colleagues brought married couples into the laboratory. Some were given a mundane task. Others were given a novel, mildly challenging one: tied together at the wrist and ankle with Velcro straps, they had to carry a cushion across a gym mat and over a barrier without using their hands or teeth, racing against a clock. Couples who did the novel, arousing activity reported greater increases in relationship satisfaction than couples who did the mundane one. Field studies in which couples spent time each week on “exciting” activities, rather than merely “pleasant” ones, found similar effects.
The finding fits with Perel. What revives desire isn’t more closeness of the familiar kind. It’s shared newness: seeing your partner in unfamiliar settings, facing challenges together, discovering parts of each other you didn’t know.
Rotation, revisited
Recall from Chapter 1 Kierkegaard’s young aesthete and his essay on the rotation of crops. His lesser method was to keep changing fields: new partners, new places, new thrills. His more refined method was to change how one cultivates the same field, finding novelty through attention, imagination and variation.
Strip away the aesthete’s cynicism and you have something close to Perel and Aron’s advice. The solution to familiarity isn’t necessarily a new partner, who’ll become familiar in turn. It’s learning to see the same partner freshly: travelling together, taking up a new skill, letting each other have separate lives worth admiring, talking about things you’ve never talked about. A line often attributed to Proust, though usually paraphrased, puts it well: the real voyage of discovery lies not in seeking new landscapes but in having new eyes.
What Aman and Ritu did
Their therapist didn’t start with the bedroom. She started by talking about separateness. Aman and Ritu had merged so completely that neither had a life the other didn’t know about. She asked each of them to reclaim something of their own: a friendship, a hobby, a space in the week that belonged only to them. Ritu went back to dance classes she’d dropped after the children were born. Aman started cycling with a group on weekends.
They also cut the endless logistical texting and agreed to talk about something other than the household at least once a day. They took a weekend trip to a city neither had visited. And they talked, awkwardly at first, about desire itself: what each of them found arousing, what they missed, what they’d always been too shy to say.
It didn’t transform overnight. But a few months later Aman described watching Ritu perform at her dance school’s showcase. “She looked like someone I didn’t know,” he said. “Confident. Beautiful. I couldn’t take my eyes off her.” That’s Perel’s insight in a sentence: you have to let your partner be a stranger sometimes in order to want her.
What to take from this chapter
- Security and passion draw on opposite needs: closeness and familiarity on one side, separateness and mystery on the other.
- Desire often comes back when we see our partner from a distance, as a separate, radiant person.
- Differentiation, staying yourself while staying close, is the foundation of lasting intimacy, physical and emotional.
- Shared novelty and challenge measurably boost relationship satisfaction.
- Change how you see the same person instead of hunting for a new one to see.