Rohit Shah

For the reader

A Reader’s Companion

Key ideas in one place, a short summary of the argument, and questions for a reading group or a classroom.

The argument in brief

Long before anyone named a god, human beings were burying their dead, blowing ochre around their hands on cave walls, and treating animals, rivers and the dead as persons to be reckoned with. The essay traces how those older habits of mind (care for the dead, ecstatic experience, an animate world, and a talent for reading intentions into everything) slowly gathered into the named, watchful, moralising gods of the first cities. Three threads run through it:

  • The mind came first, the gods later. The capacities that make religion possible, such as theory of mind, agency detection and the ability to imagine absent others, were in place long before any recognisable deity.
  • Place and ritual may have come before farming. Sites like Göbekli Tepe suggest that people gathered to build sacred places before they settled down to farm, not only after.
  • Scale changed the gods. Small foraging bands enforced morality face to face. Large anonymous societies seem to have needed gods who watched when no one else could.

None of this is settled. The essay flags where the evidence is thin, and the questions below are meant to keep that honesty alive.

Key terms

Animism. The understanding of the world as a community of persons, only some of them human. Animals, plants, rivers and mountains have inner lives and must be treated with etiquette: greeting, gift, respect and apology. Animism appears to be universal among recorded hunter-gatherers.

Ancestor cult. Ritual attention to named forebears who are believed to remain present and to care about their descendants. It becomes prominent with farming, when land and its inheritance tie the living to particular dead.

Axial Age. Karl Jaspers’s name for roughly 800–200 BCE, when thinkers in India, China, Iran, Israel and Greece began to judge kings, sacrifice and custom against a higher, universal standard and to turn inward toward the individual soul.

Big Gods hypothesis. Ara Norenzayan’s argument that belief in powerful, all-seeing, moralising gods helped large societies of strangers cooperate, because people who believe they are watched behave better even when no one human is looking.

Entoptic phenomena. The geometric forms (grids, dots, zigzags, nested curves) that the human visual system produces in altered states. In the neuropsychological model of David Lewis-Williams, they are the first of three stages of trance and a possible source of abstract cave signs.

Hyperactive agency detection. Justin Barrett’s term for our tendency to sense a deliberate agent behind ambiguous events. Mistaking wind for an intruder is cheap; mistaking an intruder for wind can be fatal, so selection favoured over-detection.

Cathedral of the mind. Steven Mithen’s image of the early human mind as separate chapels (social, natural-history and technical intelligence) whose walls came down in modern humans, allowing metaphor, art and hybrid beings such as the lion-man.

Neolithic. The “New Stone Age”, when people in several regions independently began farming, herding and living in permanent villages, beginning around 11,500 years ago in the Fertile Crescent.

Rites of passage. Arnold van Gennep’s three-phase pattern of separation, liminality (a dangerous in-between state) and incorporation. Funerals often follow it, moving the dead person from the living into the company of ancestors.

Ṛta. The Vedic order that governs both the regular motion of nature and right human conduct, guarded by Varuna. It is an ancestor of the later idea of dharma.

Shamanism. A cluster of practices in which a specialist enters altered states to travel among spirits, heal or find game. The term comes from Siberian ethnography, and scholars debate how far it can be stretched across times and places.

Social brain hypothesis. Robin Dunbar’s proposal that primate brains grew larger to manage larger social groups. It helps explain why human minds are so ready to read intentions, and why ritual, song and shared belief help bind groups beyond the size grooming can hold together.

Terror management theory. The research programme, built on Ernest Becker’s The Denial of Death, showing that reminders of mortality make people cling more tightly to their worldview and group.

Totemism. The association of a social group with an animal, plant or other natural being. Émile Durkheim treated it as the simplest form of religion; Claude Lévi-Strauss argued that totems are chosen because they are “good to think” with, not because they are worshipped.

Upper Palaeolithic. The later Old Stone Age, roughly 50,000 to 12,000 years ago, the period of the great painted caves, carved figurines and elaborate burials.

Sites worth knowing

  • Bhimbetka (Madhya Pradesh): rock shelters with one of the densest concentrations of rock art on earth, now a UNESCO World Heritage Site.
  • Baghor (Son valley, Madhya Pradesh): a late Upper Palaeolithic stone with natural triangular banding, set on a platform, read by its excavators as a possible early shrine to a female power.
  • Blombos Cave (South Africa): engraved ochre and shell beads, among the oldest known symbolic objects.
  • Göbekli Tepe (Turkey): monumental carved enclosures built by hunter-gatherers around 9600 BCE.
  • Hohle Fels (Germany): a carved female figure and early flutes, some of the oldest figurative art in the world.
  • Jericho (the Jordan Valley): plastered and painted human skulls, a vivid sign of the ancestor cult in early farming villages.
  • Sungir (Russia): burials with thousands of ivory beads, implying staggering effort spent on the dead.

Questions for discussion

On the opening chapters (Prologue to Chapter III).

  1. The essay says it is easier to infer technology from archaeology than beliefs. What can a burial tell us for certain, and what can it not?
  2. Why might care for the dead come before any idea of an afterlife, rather than after it?
  3. Of the theories of cave art (hunting magic, structuralism, shamanism), which explains the most evidence? Which explains the least, and why has it lasted anyway?

On Chapters IV to VI.

  1. Descola describes four ways of answering whether other beings share our inner life and our physical nature. Which describes your own everyday assumptions, and where do you slip into another?
  2. Agency detection and theory of mind explain why gods are easy to believe in. Do they say anything about whether gods exist? Why or why not?
  3. What are the dangers of reading the female figurines of the Palaeolithic as evidence for a single “Mother Goddess”?

On Chapters VII to IX.

  1. If Göbekli Tepe really came before farming, what does that do to the usual story that religion grew out of settled agricultural life?
  2. How does farming change the relationship between the living and the dead? Think about land, inheritance and the right to name one’s ancestors.
  3. Monuments aligned to the solstices appear in many places. Is this better explained by shared practical needs, by shared psychology, or by something else?

On Chapters X and XI.

  1. Small foraging societies tended to enforce morality through people, not gods. What changed when societies grew to thousands of strangers?
  2. Which habits of the “primordial mind” can you still see in modern life, in sport, in politics, in grief, in the way we talk to machines?
  3. The essay ends at the Axial Age. In what sense did those thinkers break with the older religious world, and in what sense did they continue it?

A note on evidence

Dates in the essay are approximate and several are actively debated. A good habit when reading anything on prehistory is to ask three questions of each claim: What was actually found? Who dated it, and how? What else could explain it? The guide to further reading lists the scholars whose work the essay draws on, so any thread can be followed back to its source.

Curated by Claude from my favourite reads. About this material